This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Modeling Vision with Headlights in a Systems Context
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1977 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A Headlight Evaluation Model has been developed which provides a broader and more comprehensive method for characterizing the performance of headlamps than is possible in traditional headlight seeing distance field tests.
The Headlamp Evaluation Model accepts as input the candlepower patterns of the headlamp system being evaluated and provides a measure of driver visual performance based on a large number of simulated seeing distance tests and glare discomfort checks on a standardized test route. The output of the Model, termed the Figure of Merit, is the percentage of the distance traveled by the simulated driver on the standardized test route in which the seeing distance to pedestrians and pavement lines, and the discomfort glare levels experienced by opposing drivers, simultaneously meet certain acceptance criteria.
The standardized test route is a computer representation of a series of highway sections in the form of a file of environmental parameters which have an influence on visual performance in night driving. The simulation includes such parameters as pavement, lane line and pedestrian reflectance, road geometry, lane configuration, ambient illumination and glare from fixed lighting, and traffic and pedestrian density. The standardized test route is a representation of a U.S. night driving environment as measured in a series of field surveys covering thousands of miles of highway and as reported in the literature.
The seeing distance calculations are performed by an integral seeing distance model which is based on the human visual performance literature and validated by field studies. Response to glare is based on published discomfort glare formulations, modified and validated on the basis of highway tests.
Because driver visual performance, as expressed in the Figure of Merit, is functionally dependent on environmental factors as well as on headlamp characteristics, the Figure of Merit is a systems measure. The Model can be used not only to evaluate headlamps but to measure the sensitivity of driver visual performance to environmental factors and thus to improvements in certain aspects of the highway itself.
Applications of the Model have shown that driver visual performance at night is more sensitive to environmental conditions and to the driver's visual capabilities than to the range of characteristics exhibited by existing and proposed headlight systems. This is partly because large increases in candlepower are required to provide useful increases in visibility and because such increases in candlepower produce a concomitant increase in glare discomfort. Other applications include a comparison of several European and mid-beam systems with current U.S. systems, evaluation of headlamp misaim effects and a determination of the effectiveness of improving the brightness of pavement lines.
|Technical Paper||Visibility Distance with Headlights: A Functional Approach|
|Technical Paper||A New Software Tool for Performance Simulation of Headlamp Beam Pattern|
|Technical Paper||Discomfort and Disability Glare from Halogen and HID Headlamp Systems|
CitationBhise, V., Farber, E., Saunby, C., Troell, G. et al., "Modeling Vision with Headlights in a Systems Context," SAE Technical Paper 770238, 1977, https://doi.org/10.4271/770238.
- Blackwell R. H. “The Problem of Specifying the Quantity and Quality of Illumination.” Illuminating Engineering 49 2 February 1954
- Fry G. A. “Evaluating Disabling Effects of Approaching Automobile Headlights.” Highway Research Board Bulletin No. 89 1954
- DeBoer J. B. “Quality Criteria for the Passing Beam of Motorcar Headlights.” CTB meeting Walldorf, West Germany September 1973
- Schulze K. H. Beckmann L. “Friction Properties of Pavements at Different Speeds.” ASTM Special Technical Publication 1962
- Forbes L. M. “Field of View from Automotive Vehicles,” SAE Report SP-381 May 1973
- Roper V. J. Howard E. A. “Seeing with Motor Car Headlamps.” Trans. Illuminating Engineering Society 33 5 1938
- Knoblauch R. Moore W. Schmitz P. Sommers B. “Causative Factors and Countermeasures for Rural Pedestrian Accidents.” Final Report of FHWA/NHTSA Contract No. DOT-HS-355-3-718 Biotechnology, Inc. Falls Church, VA November 1975
- Federal Highway Administration “Highway Statistics.” 1973
- Blackwell O. M. Blackwell R. H. “Visual Performance Data for 156 Normal Observers of Various Ages.” Journal of Illuminating Engineering Society 1 1 October 1971
- Hull R. W. Hemion R. H. Cadena D. G. “Guidelines for Improving the Stability of Headlight Aim.” Southwest Research Institute 1972
- Hare C. T. Hemion R. H. “Headlamp Beam Usage on U.S. Highways.” Proceedings of the 2nd Annual Symposium on Visibility and Driving of the Highway Research Board Illumination Engineering Research Institute and Institute of Transportation and Traffic Engineering, University of California-Berkeley July 1969
- Krumm R. L. Livingston B. R. Frankenberger C. C. “Field Evaluation of an Experimental Three Beam Headlight System.” Final Report of NHTSA Contract No. DOT-HS-1202-407 Essex Corporation March 1974
- Bhise V. D. Farber E. I. McMahan P. B. “Predicting Target Detection Distance with Headlights.” Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board Washington, D. C. January 1976 Transportation Research Record
- Hull R. W. Hemion R. H. Cadena D. G. Dial B. C. “Vehicle Forward Lighting Performance and Inspection Requirements.” Southwest Research Institute July 1971
- Mortimer R. G. Becker J. M. “Some Operational Considerations Affecting the Performance of Current and Proposed Headlamps.” Highway Research Board Meeting Washington, D. C. January 1974
- Guth S. K. “A Method for Evaluating Discomfort Glare.” Illuminating Engineering May 1963
- Lindae G. “A Few Possibilities for Improvement of the Low Beam Light: with Special Consideration of Psychological Glare.” ATZ 69 7 1967
- Schmidt-Clausen H. J. Bindels J. T. H. “Assessment of Discomfort Glare in Motor Vehicle Lighting.” Lighting Research and Technology 6 2 1974
- Fry G. A. King V. M. “The Pupillary Response and Discomfort Glare.” Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society 4 4 July 1975
- Mortimer R. G. Olson P. L. “Development and Use of Driving Tests to Evaluate Headlamp Beams.” Final Report of MVMA Contract No. UM-7102-C128 Highway Safety Research Institute, The University of Michigan March 1974
- Bhise V. D. Swigart T. F. Farber E. I. “Development of a Headlamp Dimming Request Prediction Model.” Proceedings of the 1975 Annual Meeting of the Human Factors Society Dallas, Texas October 1975
- Fry G. A. Pritchard B. S. Blackwell H. R. “Design and Calibration of a Disability Glare Lens.” Illuminating Engineering March 1963
- Cole A. E. Donaldson R. J. “Precipitation.” “Handbook of Geophysics and Space Environments.” New York McGraw-Hill 1965
- Visher S. S. “Climatic Atlas of the U.S.” Cambridge, Mass. Harvard University Press 1966
- King County Accident data files, available from the HSRI accident data systems Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan
- Institute of Traffic Engineers “Traffic Engineering Handbook.” 1965
- Mortimer R. G. “Dynamic Evaluation of Automobile Rear Lighting Configurations.” Highway Safety Research Institute, University of Michigan 1969
- Normann O. K. “Newest Stopping Ability Tables.” Traffic Safety January 1968
- Mercer S. “Locked Wheel Skid Performance of Various Tires on Clean, Dry Road Surfaces.” Highway Research Board Bulletin No. 186 1958
- Moyer R. A. “California Skid Tests with Butol Rubber Tires.” Highway Research Board No. 28 1963
- National Safety Council “Accident Facts” 1974
- Rockwell, T. H. Ernst R. L. Rulon M. J. “Researches on Visual Requirements in Night Driving,” Final Report of NCHRP Project No. 5-3 Systems Research Group, Ohio State University Columbus, Ohio April 1967
- McLean, J. R. Hoffmann E. R. “The Effects of Restricted Preview on Driver Steering Control and Performance,” Human Factors 15 4 1973 421 430
- Kondo, M. Ajimine A. “Driver's Sight Point and Dynamics of the Driver-Vehicle-System Related to It,” SAE Paper No. 680104 Automotive Engineering Congress Society of Automotive Engineers Detroit, Michigan January 1968
- Bhise, V. D. Rockwell T. H. “Role of Peripheral Vision and Time-Sharing in Driving,” Proceedings of Fifteenth Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. New York, New York 1972
- Rockwell, T. H. “Eye Movement Analysis of Visual Information Acquisition in Driving: An Overview,” Proceedings of the Sixth Conference Australian Road Research Board 6 1972 316 331
- Shinar, D. McDowell E. D. Rockwell T. H. “Eye Movements in Curve Negotiations,” Human Factors 19 1 1977 63 71
- Allen, R. W. McRuer D. T. “The Effect of Adverse Visibility on Driver Steering Performance in an Automobile Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 770239 International Automotive Engineering Congress Society of Automotive Engineers Detroit, Michigan February 1977
- Allen, R. W. Progress Report on Federal Highway Administration Contract No. DOT-FH-11-8824 “Driver's Visibility Requirements for Roadway Delineation,” Systems Technology, Inc. Hawthorne, California 1976