This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Study of the Energy Utilization of Gasoline and Battery-Electric Powered Special Purpose Vehicles
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1976 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The depletion of the supply of liquid hydrocarbon fuels in the predictable future has accelerated interest in vehicles powered by different forms of energy. The battery is one form of energy storage that has successfully found application in special-purpose vehicles for nearly three-quarters of a century. Heavy duty lift-trucks and tugs, golf carts and delivery vehicles are among the vehicle types powered by battery-electric systems. Personal transportation needs have been served to only a limited extent by electric vehicles because of the low power, limited range and lack of durability provided. by the conventional lead-acid battery. However, recent changes in the energy availability picture have necessitated reconsideration of the electric vehicle.
In order to compare the efficiency of utilization of the Earth's fossil energy resources (petroleum and coal) by battery-electric and gasoline powered special-purpose urban vehicles, an analytic study was conducted. The guidelines of this study restricted it to three special-purpose cars that are smaller and have lower performance than conventional subcompact cars and a delivery van. The vehicle power train components represent demonstrated current technology. The most important guideline of the study required the performance levels and load carrying capacity of the gasoline and electric-powered vehicles to be the same. The results of the study indicate that a lead-acid battery powered, two-passenger shopper vehicle with a 40 km range consumed about 90% more petroleum per kilometer of driving than does its spark ignition engine powered counterpart. With coal as the prime source, they consume about the same amount of energy. Increases in desired range, performance and vehicle size beyond that of the shopper increase the electric vehicle energy consumption with respect to the gasoline powered version.
The position of the electric vehicle is improved with respect to the gasoline vehicle by the development of advanced batteries, increased electric component efficiencies and an actual electric vehicle mass less than assumed due to a reduced mass compounding factor. An aspect related to the conventionally powered vehicle that tends to reduce the advantage over the electric is a potential efficiency penalty of the spark ignition engine due to its small size. Incorporation of these considerations into the study produce results more favorable for the electric version. The energy consumption of a nickel-zinc battery powered shopper is only about 30 percent more than its spark ignition engine powered counterpart considering petroleum as the prime source of energy. With coal as the prime source, the advanced technology electric vehicle consumes about 30 percent less than the spark ignition engine powered version.
CitationSheridan, D., Bush, J., and Kuziak, W., "A Study of the Energy Utilization of Gasoline and Battery-Electric Powered Special Purpose Vehicles," SAE Technical Paper 760119, 1976, https://doi.org/10.4271/760119.
- Salihi Jalal T. “Energy Requirements for Electric Cars and Their Impact on Electric Power Generation and Distribution Systems,” IEEE Transactions 1A-9 5 Sept. Oct. 1973
- Hamilton W. F. “Impact of Future Use of Electric Cars in the Los Angeles Region,” EPA-460/3-74-020-a October 1974
- Heitbrink Witherspoon Winebrener “Dual Battery Electric Powerplant,” General Motors Research Publication, GMR-1035 Oct. 9 1970
- George J. H. B. et al. “Prospects for Electric Vehicles--A Study of Low-Polution Potential Vehicles-Electric,” Dept. of Health, Education and Welfare Contract No. PH 86-67-108 May 15 1968
- Waters W. C. “GPSIM General Purpose Vehicle Simulator,” SAE Preprint 720043 Jan. 1971
- Gumbleton J. J. et al. “Special Purpose Urban Cars,” SAE Preprint 690461 May 19-23 1969
- Agruss Bernard “Testing Batteries for Vehicular Applications,” Journal of the Electrochemical Society 117 9 Sept. 1970
- Cairns E. J. et al. “Development of High Energy Batteries for Electric Vehicles,” Argonne National Laboratories Progress Report Dec. 1971
- Unnewehr Lewis E. “Electric Vehicle Systems Study,” Ford Motor Co. 1974
- Mueller Gustav A. “The Gould Battery Handbook,” 1973
- Laumeister Bruce R. “The GE Electric Vehicle,” SAE Preprint 680430 1968
- Daniel W. A. et al. “Matching Future Automotive Fuels and Engines for Optimum Energy Efficiency.” General Motors Research Laboratories Symposium on Future Automotive Fuels October 1975
- McKee Robert S. et al. “Sundancer: A Test Bed Electric Vehicle,” SAE Preprint 720188 1972
- Aronson Robert R. “The Mars II Electric Car,” SAE Preprint 680428 1968
- Hafer Paul R. et al. “The Electric Multistop Fleet Delivery Vehicle--Fact or Fantasy,” SAE Preprint 750075 Feb. 24-28 1975
- Miner Donald K. Copper Development Assoc., Inc. Verbal Presentation at EV Symposium Dana Corp. June 6 1974
- 1975 Gas Mileage Guide for New Car Buyers U. S. Environmental Protection Agency Jan. 1975