This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Impact Performance of Some Designs of Steering Assembly in Real Accidents and Under Test Conditions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper describes the results of a three year field study into the crash performance of three basic designs of steering assembly, fitted to British cars. These systems have evolved to comply with current European and United States safety standards. While one design, involving a large-area, self-aligning steering wheel mounted on a conventional column, appeared from the field data to be highly effective in preventing serious chest and abdominal injury, the two systems utilizing axial-collapse steering columns proved to be essentially ineffective in practice. This finding is based on a field accident sample of 108 cases, so sampled as to be representative of the severe end of the collision speed and injury spectra. A test program was undertaken to examine the procedures currently used to evaluate steering assemblies. It was found that tests carried out in compliance with FMVSS 203 failed to differentiate between the safe and unsafe systems described above. Additionally, it was noted that the mode of damage to the steering assemblies produced by normal testing was quite unlike anything seen in the field. Modifications to the test procedures were made that enabled accident damage to be accurately reproduced, but even under these conditions, the peak load injury criterion failed to show any differences between the designs tested. Only when both peak load and effective loaded area were taken into account could the major differences observed in the field be demonstrated under test. In conclusion, suggestions are made for alterations to present steering assembly testing techniques that will allow the impact equipment currently used to predict usefully the field performance of steering assemblies.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Subcompact Vehicle Energy-Absorbing Steering Assembly Evaluation |
| Technical Paper | Stress Relaxation as Used in Underhood Component Design Verification |
| Aerospace Standard | Test Procedure to Measure the R.F. Shielding Characteristics of E.M.I. Gaskets |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Gloyns, P. and Mackay, G., "Impact Performance of Some Designs of Steering Assembly in Real Accidents and Under Test Conditions," SAE Technical Paper 741176, 1974, https://doi.org/10.4271/741176.Also In
References
- Marquis D. P. “The General Motors Energy Absorbing Column.” Paper 670039 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1967
- Gadd C. W. Patrick L. M. “System versus Laboratory Impact Tests for Estimating Injury Hazard.” Paper 680053 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1968
- Skeels P. C. “The General Motors Energy Absorbing Column.” Paper 660785 , Proceedings of Tenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 12 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1966
- Huelke D. F. Chewning W. A. “The Energy Absorbing Steering Column.” Ann Arbor: Highway Safety Research Institute The University of Michigan 1968
- Patrick L. M. Van Kirk D. J. “Correlation of Accident and Laboratory Impacts to Energy Absorbing Steering Assemblies.” Paper 690185 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1969
- Lundstrom L. C. Cichowski W. G. Huelke D. F. Chewning W. A. Patrick L. M. Van Kirk D. J. Garrett J. W. “Energy Absorbing Steering Column Successfully Reduces Injury But New Impact Patterns Emerge.” SAE Journal 77 5 May 1969 60 64
- Nelson W. D. Wilson R. A. “Field Accident Research.” Proceedings of General Motors Automotive Safety Seminar 11 July 11-12 1968
- Marquis D. P. Rasmussen T. “Status of Energy Absorption in Steering Columns.” Proceedings of General Motors Automotive Seminar 12 July 11-12 1968
- Lasky I. I. Siegel A. W. Nahum A. M. “Cardiac Injuries Incurred by Drivers in Automobile Accidents.” JrI. Forensic Sciences 14 1 January 1969 13 33
- Huelke D. F. Chewning W. A. “Accident Investigations of the Performance Characteristics of Energy Absorbing Steering Columns.” Paper 690184 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1969
- Adams, D. III Cassle R. S. “Chrysler Energy Absorbing Antitheft Steering Column.” Paper 700001 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1970
- Voigt G. E. Wilfert K. “Mechanisms of Injuries to Unrestrained Drivers in Head-On Collisions.” Paper 690811 Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 28 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1969
- Lange W. “Severe Frontal Collisions and Resulting Injuries With and Without Restraining Devices.” AGARD Conference NATO June 1971
- Huelke D. F. Sherman H. W. “Some Injury Mechanisms in New Car Collisions.” Proceedings of Fifteenth AAAM Conference SAE New York 8 26 1972
- Nahum A. M. Siegel A. W. Brooks S. “The Reduction in Collision Injuries: Past, Present and Future.” Paper 700895 Proceedings of Fourteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 33 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1970
- Anderson T. E. “Analysis of Vehicle Injury Sources.” New York Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory, Inc. 1972
- Giffen W. “A Review of Seat Belt Effectiveness and Investigation of Potential Improvements Including Passive Systems.” Fourth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Kyoto March 1973
- Levine D. N. Campbell B. J. “Effectiveness of Lap Seat Belts and the Energy Absorbing Steering System in the Reduction of Injuries.” Chicago National Safety Council Jrl. Safety Research 4 3 1972 106 118
- Trosien K. R. Patrick L. M. “Steering Wheel Airbag Collision Performance.” Paper 710020 SAE Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit January 1971
- Patrick L. M. Nyquist G. W. Trosien K. R. “Safety Performance of Shaped Steering Assembly Airbag.” Paper 720976 Proceedings of Sixteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 45 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1972
- Searle J. “The Effect of Steering Column Design on the Injuries Received by Drivers in Road Accidents.” Ph.D. Thesis Research Group in Traffic Studies University College London 1972
- Garrett J. W. Hendricks D. L. “Factors Influencing the Performance of the Energy Absorbing Steering Column in Accidents.” Fifth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles London June 1974
- Gloyns P. F. Mackay G. M. Hardy J. L. G. Aston S. J. “Field Investigations of the Injury Protection Offered by Some Energy Absorbing Steering Systems.” Proceedings of International Conference on the Biokinetics of Impacts Amsterdam June 1973 399 410
- Gloyns P. F. “The Impact Performance of Some Designs of Steering Assembly in Real Accidents and Under Test Conditions.” Ph.D. Thesis Dept. of Transportation and Environmental Planning University of Birmingham 1973
- States J. D. “The Abbreviated and Comprehensive Research Injury Scales.” Paper 690810 Proceedings of Thirteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 28 New York Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. 1969
- Mackay G. M. Aston S. J. “Injuries in Collisions Involving Small Cars in Europe.” Paper 730284
- Siegel S. “Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioural Sciences.” London McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1956