This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Effects of Some Engine, Fuel, and Oil Additive Factors on Engine Rusting in Short-Trip Service
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1970 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: Mid-Year Meeting
Forty-one short-trip service tests were run using 1964-1969 model U.S. passenger cars and 19 commercial or experimental oils evaluating several aspects of engine rusting. These factors included differences in rusting severity among engine models, effects of fuel variables on rusting, and the effects of oil additive type and concentration on rusting.
Rusting severity varied widely among engine models, but different engines ranked similarly the rust protection provided by oils with differing additive treatments.
Use of either nonleaded gasoline or LPG instead of leaded gasoline greatly reduced engine rusting.
At equivalent additive treatment levels, several magnesium sulfonates provided better rust protection than did certain calcium sulfonates, calcium phenates, or a barium sulfonate. Rust protection increased greatly and approximately linearly with increasing magnesium content.
From these tests, and those reported by others, there appear to be three requirements for engine rusting to occur:
Addition to the crankcase of corrosive products from the gasoline lead antiknock scavengers and combustion products.
Cold engine operation, permitting condensation and accumulation of corrosive products in the oil.
Depletion of rust-preventing oil additives.
Since the first two requirements are at present largely uncontrolled from the customers' standpoint (most gasolines are leaded and contain scavengers, and winter weather is cold in many areas), the only other apparent avenue for improving the rust protection provided to current-design engines using leaded gasolines is better rust-preventing additives in the oil.
CitationPless, L., "The Effects of Some Engine, Fuel, and Oil Additive Factors on Engine Rusting in Short-Trip Service," SAE Technical Paper 700457, 1970, https://doi.org/10.4271/700457.
- Bennett P. A., “Engine Rusting in Service and Dynamometer Tests.” Lubrication Engineering, Vol. 16, November 1960, p. 529.
- Bennett P. A. and Malone G. K., “The Effect of Several Variables on Engine Rusting in Service Tests.” Lubrication Engineering, Vol. 20, March 1964, p. 94.
- Cordera F. J., Foster H. J., Henderson B. M., and Woodruff R. L., “TEL Scavengers in Fuel Affect Engine Performance and Durability.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 73 (1965), p. 576.
- Isringhaus, E. A. Jr. and Henderson B. M., “Engine Rusting in Automotive Service.” Paper 650868 presented at SAE National Fuels and Lubricants Meeting, Tulsa, November 1965.
- Colyer C. C. and Tom T. B., “Another Milestone in Motor Oils.” Paper 951B presented at SAE Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, January 1965.
- “Automotive Engines in ‘Light-Duty’ Service.” Lubrication, Vol. 46, No. 10 (November-December 1960), p. 121.
- Young D. A. and Farris G. J., “Evaluation of Rusting Characteristics of Motor Oils.” Paper 439B presented at SAE National Fuels and Lubricants Meeting, Houston, November 1961.
- Colyer C. C., “The MS Sequence Tests Today.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 75 (1967), paper 660540.
- Colyer C. C., Allman L. J., and Ladevich R. M., “Balanced Motor Oils for 1968 Engines.” Paper 670499 presented at SAE Mid-Year Meeting, Chicago, May 1967.
- Pless Loren G. and Bennett P. A., “The Effects of Some Engine, Operating, and Oil Variables on Engine Rusting in Short-Trip Service.” Lubrication Engineering, Vol. 25, October 1969, p. 384.
- Whitehead W. G., Union Carbide Corp., private communication.
- “Local Climatological Data, Detroit, Michigan City Airport.” Environmental Science Services Administration, U. S. Department of Commerce.
- McReynolds L. A., discussion of Ref. 3, “TEL Scavengers in Fuel Affect Engine Performance and Durability.” SAE Transactions, Vol. 73 (1965), p. 596.
- Bailey C. H., “Engine Rust-Measurements by a New Technique Shed Light on Why Lubricated Parts Rust.” Paper 717B presented at SAE International Summer Meeting, Montreal, Canada, June 1963.
- Randall T. H., Andrus R. E., Fein R. S., and Kluge H. D., “Lubricant Additive Action in Combating Low Temperature Wear in Automotive Engines.” Paper 107A presented at SAE National Fuels and Lubricants Meeting, Tulsa, November 1958.
- ASTM Designation D 664-58, “Standard Method of Test for Neutralization Number by Potentiometric Titration.” 1969 Book of ASTM Standards, Part 17, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, Pa. (1969).
- Asseff P. A., “Engine Performance as Influenced by Lubricant Deterioration.” Paper 680760, SAE Activities Proceedings AP-1, “Fuels and Lubricants 1968 Papers.” p. 456.
- “CRC Rust Rating Manual.” CRC Manual No. 7, Coordinating Research Council, Inc., New York, September 1962.