This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Minimization of Occupant Injury by Optimum Front-End Design - La Diminution des Fatalités des Occupants d'une Automobile par une Modification Idéale du Front - Minimierung der Besitzerverletzung durch Optimalen Wagenvorderentwurf
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1970 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The objective sought in this research is the optimization of vehicle deceleration to minimize serious injury and fatalities for harnessed occupants. The injury criterion is head acceleration, which from biomechanical considerations is not permitted to exceed 80 G. Head injuries account for 70% of accident fatalities, and the most reliable indicator of such injuries is recognized to be head acceleration. Further biomechanical limitations on head motion appear to be the rate of change of acceleration which cannot exceed 1000 G/sec. and the injury severity index which is limited to the value 1000. From these criteria, a tentative selection of optimum head acceleration profiles for different vehicle impact speeds has been made. These traces serve as the desired output from a four-degree-of-freedom model of a lap-and-shoulder-belted front-seat occupant. It is required to find the vehicle deceleration input which causes this optimized head response during a crashing situation. The equations of motion for the occupant have been programmed on a digital computer, and the solutions presented graphically.
The results show that the optimum vehicle deceleration waveform is a flat deceleration versus time history with a superimposed, early-impulse peak. This differs widely from present day car performance. A comparison of existing vehicle deceleration with the ideal traces suggests that the early-impulse criterion can be implemented in existing designs by moving the engine block forward. Simple calculations using collision models confirm this finding. Other recommended changes in the design of automobile forestructure include a lengthening of the front-end and a stiffened bumper to distribute impact loads. Using statistical data available from many sources, an empirical equation has been derived to show the savings in fatalities that would result using the optimized design.
CitationMoore, D., "Minimization of Occupant Injury by Optimum Front-End Design - La Diminution des Fatalités des Occupants d'une Automobile par une Modification Idéale du Front - Minimierung der Besitzerverletzung durch Optimalen Wagenvorderentwurf," SAE Technical Paper 700416, 1970, https://doi.org/10.4271/700416.
- Gadd C. W. “Analytical Versus Intuitive Approaches to Reducing Crash Injury,” General Motors Corp. Research Publication GMR-670 May 10 1967
- Kihlberg J. K. “Head Injury in Automobile Accidents,” Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory Report #VJ-1823-R17 Nov. 1965
- Patrick L. M. “Prevention of Instrument Panel and Windshield Head Injuries,” Highway Safety Research Institute The University of Michigan April 1967
- Gadd C. W. “Use of a Weighted-Impulse Criterion for Estimating Injury Hazard,” Proc. 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference Nov. 8-9 1966 164 174
- Renneker D. N. “Basic Study of Energy Absurbing Vehicle Structure and Occupant Restraints by Mathematical Model,” SAE Math. Model Conference Anaheim, California Oct. 12 1967
- Naab K. N. “Measurement of Detailed Inertial Properties and Dimensions of a 50th Percentile Anthropometric Dummy,” Proc. 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference Nov. 8-9 1966 187 195
- Patrick L. M. Mertz, H. J. Jr. “Impact Dynamics of Unrestrained, Lap-Belted and Lap-and-Diagonal-Chest-Belted Vehicle Occupants,” Proc. 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference Nov. 8-9 1966 46 93
- Mertz, H. J. Jr. “Car Occupant Responses to Rear-End Collisions -- A Mathematical Model,” Proc. 1st International Conference on Vehicle Mechanics Wayne State University Detroit July 1968
- Daniel R. P. Patrick L. M. “Instrument Panel Impact Study,” Proc. 9th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1965 165 179
- Kaufman H. Larson D. B. “Calculation of Deceleration Waveforms Using Optimal Control Theory,” Proc. 1st International Conference on Vehicle Mechanics Wayne State University Detroit July 1968
- Egli A. “Stopping the Occupant of a Crashing Vehicle -- A Fundamental Study,” SAE Paper # 670038 Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit Jan. 1967
- Wolf R. A. Garrett J. W. et. al. “Estimated Traveling Speed and Fatalities,” Cornell Aeronautical Laboratory Report #VJ-2721-R-1 Jan. 1969
- Lister R. D. “Controlled Vehicle Impact Experiments at the British Road Research Laboratory,” 12th International FISITA Automobile Congress Barcelona, Spain May 1968
- Emori R. I. “Analytical Approach to Automobile Collisions,” SAE Paper # 680016 Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit, Michigan Jan. 1968
- Warner C. Y. “Hydraulic-Plastic Cushions for Attenuation of Roadside Barrier Impacts,” Highway Research Board 48th Annual Meeting Washington Jan. 1969
- Martin D. E. Kroell C. K. “Vehicle Crush and Occupant Behavior,” SAE Paper # 670034 Automotive Engineering Congress Detroit Jan. l967