This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Evaluation of Vehicle Exhaust Gas Odor Intensity Using Natural Dilution
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1970 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Although exhaust gas odorants are generally a product of engine and fuel parameters, it is the vehicle that the public associates with exhaust odor. The vehicle and its movements have a large influence on the dispersion of exhaust odorants and, therefore, on the actual public exposure to exhaust odor. A considerable amount of public exposure to vehicle exhaust odor results from municipal operation of diesel-powered buses, especially during the bus-stop sequence. Panel test procedures were developed for field evaluation of full-scale vehicle exhaust odor intensity during the idle and acceleration portions of a simulated bus-stop sequence.
Odor tests, based on natural dilution of the vehicle exhaust to the odor threshold, were conducted in a controlled environment, indoors in large buildings. Different degrees of exhaust dilution were achieved by randomly varying the distance from the test vehicle to the panelists. Panelists were required to make yes-or-no decisions on whether or not they could detect an odor above the background level.
Exhaust odor intensity was expressed in terms of the threshold response distance, with greater threshold response distances indicating greater exhaust odor intensity. The test procedures gave adequate repeatability. Six repeat idle tests with one bus gave threshold response distances ranging from 27 - 32 ft, averaging 29 ft. Four repeat acceleration tests with another bus gave threshold response distances ranging from 32 - 41 ft, averaging 36 ft.
Idle tests with two different buses in two different test facilities showed repeatable differences in the exhaust odor intensity, indicating that the procedure was capable of discriminating between two odor sources of differing intensity.
CitationColucci, J. and Barnes, G., "Evaluation of Vehicle Exhaust Gas Odor Intensity Using Natural Dilution," SAE Technical Paper 700105, 1970, https://doi.org/10.4271/700105.
- “The Automobile and Air Pollution: A Program for Progress, Part II, Subpanel Reports to the Panel on Electrically Powered Vehicles” Morse R.S. Chairman, U.S. Department of Commerce December 1967
- Kinosian J. R. et al “The Diesel Vehicle and Its Role In Air Pollution.” A Report to the California Legislature California Department of Public Health, Bureau of Air Sanitation Berkeley, California December 1962
- “Aesthetic Diesel Smoke Levels in Both Acceleration and Lug Down Are Set to Begin in 1970” SAE Journal 77 April 1969
- State of California Administrative Code November 12 1966
- Stahman R. C. Kittredge G. D. Springer K. J. “Smoke and Odor Control for Diesel-Powered Trucks and Buses.” Paper 680443 SAE Mid-Year Meeting Detroit May 1968
- Merrion D. F. “Effect of Design Revisions on Two-Stroke Cycle Diesel Engine Exhaust.” Paper 680422 SAE Mid-Year Meeting Detroit May 1968
- Reckner L. R. Squires R. E. “Diesel Exhaust Odor Measurement Using Human Panels.” Paper 680444 SAE Mid-Year Meeting Detroit May 1968
- Barnes G.J. “Relation of Lean Combustion Limits in Diesel Engines to Exhaust Odor Intensity.” Paper 680445 SAE Mid-Year Meeting Detroit May 1968
- Finney D. J. “Probit Analysis.” London Cambridge University Press 1952 1 64