This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison of Fixed Wing Reusable Booster Concepts
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Space Technology Conference
Language:
English
Abstract
Eight fixed-wing reusable horizontal landing booster point design concepts are presented and compared on the basis of weight, cost, technical difficulty, and availability date. The eight vehicle types considered are all basically two-stage systems with a lifting body reusable second stage, with all vehicles normalized to place 40,000 lbs. payload in orbit. All flight vehicles are fully recoverable and capable of flying back and landing at the launch site. Vehicle types discussed are vertical take-off horizontal landing rockets, sled launched horizontal take-off rockets, runway launched horizontal take-off rockets, air breathing first stages, combined air breathing and rocket first stages, oxidizer collection concepts, supersonic combustion ramjets, and in-flight refueling vehicles. Each of these vehicle types is depicted in the paper and its design and performance characteristics are discussed.
System non-recurring costs tend to be proportional to the inert weight of the vehicle, and therefore the rocket propelled vehicles have lower investment costs than the airbreathing types. The turnaround or recurring costs are relatively independent of the launch vehicle types with the exception of the in-flight refueling system, which is about double those of the other systems because of the large weight of flight hardware to be maintained. The airbreathing first stage boosters, however, may offer more mission flexibility than the rocket first stages because of their capability to fly for longer periods within the earth's atmosphere.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Air-Breathing Reusable Launchers |
Technical Paper | A French Concept for an Aerospace Transporter |
Technical Paper | Development of a Reduced Smoke Combustor for the JT3D Engine |
Authors
Citation
Nau, R., "A Comparison of Fixed Wing Reusable Booster Concepts," SAE Technical Paper 670384, 1967, https://doi.org/10.4271/670384.Also In
References
- Vaglio-Laurin R. Finke R. G. “Reusable Space Launch Vehicle Concepts: Outlook 1965” SAE Paper 650801 SAE National Aeronautic and Space Manufacturing Meeting Los Angeles, Calif. October 4-8, 1965
- Finke R. G. Brady G. W. “The Significance of Reusability in Future Launch Vehicle Systems (U)” Transactions, Eleventh Symposium on Space and Ballistic Missile Technology IV
- “Reusable Orbital Transport Second Stage Summary Technical Report (U)” General Dynamics/Convair Report No. GD/C-DCB-65-018 I April 1965
- “Reusable Orbital Transport First Stage Final Summary Technical Report (U)” Lockheed-California Co. Report No. LR 18790 21 May 1965
- Peoples P. L. et al. “Performance and Cost Analysis of Advanced Rocket and Air-breathing Launch Systems” Boeing Aerospace Division Document No. DZ-90604-1 November 1964
- Knaur J. S. “Reusability - The Next Major Launch Vehicle Development” SAE Paper 660452 SAE Advanced Launch Vehicles and Propulsion Systems Conference Huntsville, Alabama June 14-16, 1966
- Soderberg L. R. “The Rocket Approach to Recoverable Orbital Launch Systems” Transactions, Eighth Symposium on Ballistic Missile and Space Technology November 1963
- Spieth C. W. “The Economic Feasibility of the Rocket Approach to Reusable Launch Systems” Transactions, Ninth Symposium on Ballistic Missile and Space Technology August 1964
- “Reusable Launch Systems” Astronautics and Aeronautics 2 1 January 1964
- Hornby H. Havill C. D. “Some Trends in Future Launch Vehicles” SAE Paper 660463 SAE Advanced Launch Vehicles and Propulsion Systems Conference Huntsville, Alabama June 14-16, 1966
- “ACES Vehicle Systems Summary” General Dynamics/Convair Report No. GD/A-DCB-64-046 1 30 April 1964
- Jarlett F. E. “Aerospaceplane Payload and Potential” Transactions, Eighth Symposium on Ballistic Missile and Space Technology November 1963
- “Supersonic Combustion Ramjets” General Dynamics/Convair Report No. GD/A-DCB-64-102 December 15 1964
- Pinkel B. Watts A. F. “Potential of the Scramjet for Several Aerospace Applications” Transactions, Eleventh Symposium on Space and Ballistic Missile Technology IV