This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Fuel Economy Engine Oils: Scientific Rationale and Controversies
Technical Paper
2021-24-0067
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
This content contains downloadable datasets
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Since a significant part of energy losses in the internal combustion engine comes from viscous dissipation, the trend has shifted toward low-viscosity oils from SAE 40 and 50 in the 1960s-1980s to current SAE 20 and lower viscosity grades. Use of low viscosity engine oils significantly reduces energy losses in the main bearing and piston/bore systems, while tribological stresses on the valvetrain - especially in flat-tappet cammed engines - may increase. This makes a strong argument for deploying new classes of friction modifiers and antiwear additives. However, development of a balanced formulation is not as straightforward as it appears, and numerous pitfalls may be encountered due to additive interactions. Another serious problem is that the definition of “fuel-economy engine oil” is rather vague, as it depends on choice of reference oil. Nowadays, the assessment of fuel economy is often based on the Sequence VIE or VIF tests using a 2012 3.6L GM V6 gasoline engine. It is not unexpected that the results of this test turn to be largely misleading when extrapolated to modern heavily boosted low-displacement engines. Hence, many OEM-specific fuel economy tests also exist and different engine designs often produce controversial results. Furthermore, the “fuel economy” performance of the same oil in the same engine may change dramatically depending on the driving cycle.
All the aforesaid circumstances are to be taken into account when trying to harmonize normative performance claims with customer expectations.
Citation
Zhmud, B., Coen, A., and Zitouni, K., "Fuel Economy Engine Oils: Scientific Rationale and Controversies," SAE Technical Paper 2021-24-0067, 2021, https://doi.org/10.4271/2021-24-0067.Data Sets - Support Documents
Title | Description | Download |
---|---|---|
Unnamed Dataset 1 |
Also In
References
- Yang , Z. , Rutherford , D. Japan 2030 Fuel Economy Standards ICCT September 2019
- Holmberg , K. , Andersson , P. , and Erdemir , A. Global Energy Consumption Due to Friction in Passenger Cars Tribology International 47 2012 221
- Zhmud , B. Developing Energy-Efficient Lubricants and Coatings for Automotive Applications Tribology and Lubrication Technology 67 9 2011 42
- Zhmud , B. Pursuit for Better Fuel Economy: Reducing Engine Friction Helps Maxing Out Miles Per Gallon The Vehicle Component 5 2012 18
- Taylor , R.I. , Morgan , N. , Mainwaring , R. , and Davenport , T. How Much Mixed/Boundary Friction is there in an Engine - and Where is it? Proc IMechE Part J: J. Engineering Tribology 234 2020 1563
- Zhmud , B. Engine Tribology: a Thorny Way from Lab to Field Lube 154 2019 20
- Taylor , R.I. and Coy , R.C. Improved Fuel Efficiency by Lubricant Design: A Review Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. 214 1999 1
- Kleijwegt , P. , Ter Rele , R. , Sabater Ferret , M. , Van Den Bulk , R. Global Heavy-Duty Engine Oil Specifications and their Impact on Current and Next Generation Lubricants Benelux Smeermiddelen Congres Retie, Belgium 26 Sep 2019
- Zhmud , B. , Tomanik , E. Optimizing the Piston/Bore Tribology: The Role of Surface Specifications, Ring Pack, and Lubricant International Colloquium Tribology Esslingen, Germany 28 30 January 2020
- Lee , P. and Zhmud , B. Fuel Economy Engine Oils: The Formulator’s Dilemma Lube 162 2021 23
- Sander , D.E. , Allmaier , H. , Knauder , C. , and Strömstedt , F. Potentials and Risks of Reducing Friction with Future Ultra-Low-Viscosity Engine Oils MTZ Worldwide 79 2018 21
- Lechner , G. , Knafl , A. , Assanis , D. , Tseregounis , S. et al. Engine Oil Effects on the Friction and Emissions of a Light-Duty, 2.2L Direct - Injection - Diesel Engine Part 1 - Engine Test Results SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-2681 2002 https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-2681
- Tung , S. , McMillan , M. , Hong , G. , and Bardasz , E. Engine Oil Effects on Friction and Wear Using 2.2L Direct Injection Diesel Engine Components for Bench Testing Part 2: Tribology Bench Test Results and Surface Analyses SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-2005 2004 https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-01-2005
- Zhmud , B. , and Tatievski , B. Preparing for ILSAC GF-6: Advantages of Full-Synthetic Motor Oils for Boosting Fuel Economy World Tribology Congress Beijing, China 17 22 Sep 2017
- Zhmud , B. Current Advances in Crankcase Lubricants European Base Oil & Lubricants Summit Rotterdam, The Netherlands 20 21 Nov 2019
- Spikes , H. Friction Modifier Additives Trib. Lett. 60 2015 5
- Zhmud , B. and Roegiers , M. New Base Oils Pose a Challenge for Solubility and Lubricity Tribology and Lubrication Technology 65 7 2009 34
- Roegiers , M. and Zhmud , B. Tribological Performance of Ionized Vegetable Oils as Lubricity and Fatty Oiliness Additives in Lubricants and Fuels Lubrication Science 21 2009 169
- Southby , M.C. , Gao , H. , Chen , C. , Chin , C.A. et al Dec. 2015
- Li , S. , Zhang , R. , Jin , Y. , Wang , Y. et al. Tribocarbonisation of a Synthetic Engine Oil in Lubricated Piston Ring/Cylinder Bore Sliding Contact and its Relation to Friction and Wear Journal of Synthetic Lubrication 20 2003 203
- Zhmud , B. In-Manufacture Running-in of Engine Components by Using the Triboconditioning® Process Wahab , M.A. FFW 2018 LNME 2019 671 681
- Ashworth , S. , Mistry , K. , Morina , A. , and Neville , A. Single Cam Tribometer for Evaluating Tribological Parameters and Tribochemistry of DLC Coated Valve Train Follower Tribology - Materials, Surfaces & Interfaces 6 2012 31
- Li , S. , Zhang , R. , Jin , Y. , Wang , Y. et al. Competitive Surface Interactions of Critical Additives with Piston Ring/Cylinder Liner Components Under Lubricated Breaking-in Conditions Tribology Transactions 46 2003 200
- Knauder , C. , Allmaier , H. , Sander , D.E. , and Sams , T. Investigations of the Friction Losses of Different Engine Concepts. Part 2: Sub-Assembly Resolved Friction Loss Comparison of Three Engines Lubricants 7 2019 105
- Zhmud , B. , Tomanik , E. , Jiménez , A. , Profito , F. et al. Powertrain Friction Reduction by Synergistic Optimization of Cylinder Bore Surface and Lubricant - Part 2: Engine Tribology Simulations and Tests SAE Technical Paper 2021-01-1217 2021
- König , J. , Lahres , M. , and Methner , O. Quality Designed Twin Wire Arc Spraying of Aluminum Bores J. Therm. Spray Tech. 24 2015 63
- Bhasin , S. Long Term Trends in Vehicle Development 5th ICIS Indian Base Oil & Lubricants Conference Mumbai 6 April 2017
- Reduced SAPS Lubricants June 2019
- Yoshida , S. , Yamamori , K. , Hirano , S. , Sagawa , T. et al. The Development of JASO GLV-1 Next Generation Low Viscosity Automotive Gasoline Engine Oils Specification SAE Technical Paper 2020-01-1426 2020 https://doi.org/10.4271/2020-01-1426