This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Fatigue Evaluation of Flow Drill Screw Joints Using the Equilibrium-Based Structural Stress Method
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 14, 2020 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
According to the increasing demands for light-weight design in the automotive industry, the use of thinner and lighter materials such as aluminum alloys for automotive parts has led to significant weight reduction. The joining of these materials has required development of new technologies in joining/fastening rather than welding. Flow drill screwing is one of the latest technologies created to fasten sheet metal panels.
This paper discusses results of an evaluation of fatigue characteristics of flow drill screw (FDS) joints based on experimental data and observations from the literature. It was observed that the important fatigue-related geometric parameters of FDS joints were the gap between sheets and the extruded (or bulged) zone during screwing. Major failure modes were observed such as sheet failures where cracks grow from the inner surface of the sheet and around the extruded zone.
In this paper, the fatigue evaluation procedure for FDS joints using the mesh-insensitive equilibrium-based structural stress (ESS) method was used. The ESS-based simplified modeling procedure was used for the fatigue-evaluation procedure for FDS joints. The effectiveness and applicability of the ESS-based simplified procedures for modeling and simulating resistance spot welds and self-piercing rivet (SPR) joints have been proven by previous investigations. After accounting for geometric and fatigue characteristics of FDS joints, an ESS-based simplified procedure and a master S-N curve approach-based procedure were established. It was observed that the fatigue data in the interim design S-N curve became consolidated with a small scatter band regardless of sheet thickness and sheet preparation (with and without a clearance hole).
Additionally, the design S-N curve for FDS joints is a little bit lower than that for SPR joints from the interim design S-N curve comparison. From the residual stress observation for FDS joints and SPR joints, it can be inferred that the compressive residual stress distribution around the SPR helps to improve fatigue life compared with FDS joints.
CitationHong, J. and Wilkowski, G., "Fatigue Evaluation of Flow Drill Screw Joints Using the Equilibrium-Based Structural Stress Method," SAE Technical Paper 2020-01-0189, 2020, https://doi.org/10.4271/2020-01-0189.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
- Sønstabø, J.K., Holmstrom, P.H., Morin, D., and Langseth, M. , “Macroscopic Strength and Failure Properties of Flow-Drill Screw Connections,” Journal of Materials Processing Technology 222:1-12, 2015.
- Sønstabø, J.K., Morin, D., and Langseth, M. , “Testing and Modelling of Flow-Drill Screw Connections under Quasi-Static Loadings,” Journal of Materials Processing Technology 255:724-738, 2018.
- Sønstabø, J.K., Morin, D., and Langseth, M. , “Static and Dynamic Testing and Modelling of Aluminium Joints with Flow-Drill Screw Connections,” International Journal of Impact Engineering 114:58-75, 2018.
- Graf, M., Sikora, S.P., and Roider, C.S. , “Macroscopic Modeling of Thin-Walled Aluminum-Steel Connections by Flow Drill Screws,” Thin-Walled Structures 130:286-296, 2018.
- Khanna, S., Long, X., Krishnamoorthy, S., and Agrawal, H. , “Fatigue Properties and Failure Characterization of Self-Piercing Riveted 6111 Aluminium Sheet Joints,” Science and Technology of Welding and Joining 11(5):544-549, 2006.
- Su, Z., Lin, P., Lai, W., and Pan, J. , “Fatigue Analyses of Self-Piercing Rivets and Clinch Joints in Lap-Shear Specimens of Aluminum Sheets,” International Journal of Fatigue 72:53-65, 2015.
- Sun, X., Stephens, E., and Khaleel, M. , “Fatigue Behaviors of Self-Piercing Rivets Joining Similar and Dissimilar Sheet Metals,” International Journal of Fatigue 29:370-386, 2007.
- Li, D., Han, L., Thornton, M., and Shergold, M. , “Influence of Rivet to Sheet Edge Distance on Fatigue Strength of Self-Piercing Riveted Aluminum Joints,” Material Science and Engineering A 558:242-252, 2012.
- Kang, S. and Kim, H. , “Fatigue Strength Evaluation of Self-Piercing Riveted Al-5052 Joints Under Different Specimen Configurations,” International Journal of Fatigue 80:58-68, 2015.
- Hong, S., Yan, F., Sung, S., Pan, J. et al. , “Investigation of Failure Mode and Fatigue Behavior of Flow Drill Screw Joints in Lap-Shear Specimens of Aluminum 6082-T6 Sheets,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 9(3):746-750, 2016, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2016-01-0501.
- Pan, J., Chen, W.-N., Sung, S.-J., Su, X. et al. , “Failure Mode and Fatigue Behavior of Flow Drill Screw Joints in Lap-Shear Specimens of Aluminum 6082-T6 Sheets Made with Different Processing Conditions,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 11(4):327-340, 2018, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2018-01-1237.
- Pan, J., Chen, W.-N., Sung, S.-J., Su, X. et al. , “Failure Mode and Fatigue Behavior of Flow Drill Screw Joints in Lap-Shear Specimens of Aluminum 6082-T6 Sheets of Different Thicknesses,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 11(4):315-326, 2018, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2018-01-1239.
- Skovron, J., Mears, L., Ulutan, D., Detwiler, D. et al. , “Characterization of Flow Drill Screwdriving Process Parameters on Joint Quality,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 8(1):35-44, 2015, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-01-2241.
- “2007 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code,” Section VIII, Div.2, ASME, 2007.
- “API Standard 579-1/ASME FFS-1 Fitness for Service,” API, 2007.
- Dong, P., Hong, J.K., and De Jesus, A.M.P. , “Analysis of Recent Fatigue Data Using the Structural Stress Procedure in ASME Div 2 Rewrite,” Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology 129(3):355-362, 2007.
- Dong, P. and Hong, J.K. , “The Master S-N Curve Approach to Fatigue Evaluation of Offshore and Marine Structures,” OMAE 2004-51324, ASME, 2004.
- Dong, P. and Hong, J.K. , “The Master S-N Curve Approach to Fatigue of Piping and Vessel Welds,” Welding in the World 48(1/2):28-36, 2004.
- Dong, P., Hong, J.K., Potukuchi, R., and Agrawal, H. , “Master S-N Curve Development and Validations for Aluminum MIG and Laser Welds,” IIW Doc. XIII-2035-04/XV-1172-04, 2004.
- Hong, J. and Forte, T. , “Development of Friction Stir Weld Fatigue Evaluation Procedure Using Battelle Structural Stress Method,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 7(2):432-438, 2014, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-01-0909.
- Kang, H.T., Dong, P., and Hong, J.K. , “Fatigue Analysis of Spot Welds Using a Mesh-Insensitive Structural Stress Approach,” International Journal of Fatigue 29:1546-1553, 2007.
- Hong, J.K. , “The Development of a Simplified Spot Weld Model for Battelle Structural Stress Calculation,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manuf. 4(1):602-612, 2011, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-01-0479.
- Hong, J.K. , “Fatigue Evaluation Procedure Development for Aluminum Alloy Spot Welds Using the Battelle Structural Stress Method,” SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-0545 , 2015, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-0545.
- Cox, A. and Hong, J.K. , “Fatigue Evaluation Procedure Development for Self-Piercing Riveted Joints Using the Battelle Structural Stress Method,” SAE Technical Paper 2016-01-0384 , 2016, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2016-01-0384.
- Zhang, L., Sung, S., Pan, J., Su, X. et al. , “Closed-Form Structural Stress Solutions for Fatigue Life Estimation of Flow Drill Screw Joints in Lap-Shear Specimens of Aluminum 6082-T6 Sheets,” SAE Int. J. Mater. Manf. 10(2):154-159, 2017, doi:https://doi.org/10.4271/2017-01-0470.
- Hong, J.K. and Forte, T.P. , “Fatigue Evaluation Procedures for Multiaxial Loading in Welded Structures Using Battelle Structural Stress Approach,” OMAE 2014-23459, ASME, 2014.
- Milner, J.L., Gnaupel-Herold, T., and Skovron, J.D. , “Residual Stresses on Flow Drill Screwdriving of Aluminum Alloy Sheets,” MSEC 2016-8823, ASME, 2016.
- Haque, R., Wong, Y.C., Paradowska, A., Blacket, S. et al. , “SPR Characteristics Curve and Distribution of Residual Stress in Self-Piercing Riveted Joints of Steel Sheets,” Advances in Materials Science and Engineering, 2017:2017 Article ID 5824171.