This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Literature Review on Dual-Fuel Combustion Modelling
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 9, 2019 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
In the search for low greenhouse gas propulsion, the dual fuel engine provides a solution to use low carbon fuel at diesel-like high efficiency. Also a lower emission of NOx and particles can be achieved by replacing a substantial part of the diesel fuel by for example natural gas. Limitations can be found in excessively high heat release rate (combustion-knock), and high methane emissions. These limitations are strongly influenced by operating parameters and properties of the used (bio)-gas. To find the dominant relations between fuel properties, operating parameters and the heat release rate and methane emissions, a combustion model is beneficial. Such a model can be used for optimizing the process, or can even be used in real time control. As precursor for such a model, the current state of art of dual fuel combustion modelling is investigated in this work.
The focus is on high speed dual fuel engines for heavy duty and marine applications, with a varying gas/diesel ratio. Modelling is limited to the closed part of the 4-stroke engine cycle. A methodology part is included, describing the origin of the treated work.
Modelling of the dual fuel process can be done in various ways. In this Literature Review Paper a structured overview is given of the various modelling approaches used nowadays, to simulate the dual fuel combustion. The covered models include 0D, multi-zone and 3D CFD approaches. All intermediate steps for each approach are explained, and their strong and weak points are mentioned. The modelling techniques are rated on their precision and predictive capabilities in relation to their computational cost.
The majority of the models was able to give a good description of the heat release rate, although not always predictive. A good match with experimental results is seen by Wiebe and double-Wiebe functions, but prediction is limited. By including a detailed description of the combustion process, a better predictive heat release rate can be created. Also combinations of a Wiebe model and detailed combustion models are seen.
A good prediction of NOx emissions is achieved by models that include the oxidation reactions of nitrogen in their reaction scheme, or make use of the Zeldovich mechanism. A good description of local temperature is needed. This is achieved by 3D CFD models, but also multi-zone models have shown reasonable results here.
Although often mentioned as a significant source for CH4 emissions in a dual fuel engine, crevices were hardly included in the simulation work. The 3D models that did include the volume above the piston rings, confirmed the large amount of methane emission originating from this source. When prediction of uncombusted methane is a goal of simulation, it seems this aspect is not to be neglected.
The precise spatial description and detailed reaction schemes produce useful results, but come at the cost of high computational effort. Simplified models can be fast, but lack the output of detailed predictive information. This creates an interesting outlook for further development of an intermediate class of models, with enough precision at a calculation effort feasible for control purposes.
CitationMerts, M. and Verhelst, S., "Literature Review on Dual-Fuel Combustion Modelling," SAE Technical Paper 2019-24-0120, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-24-0120.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 2]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 3]|
- Merker, G.P., Schwarz, C., and Teichmann, R. , Combustion Engines Development: Mixture Formation, Combustion, Emissions and Simulation (Heidelberg: Springer, 2012).
- Abagnale, C., Cameretti, M.C., Ciaravola, U., Tuccillo, R., and Iannaccone, S. , “Dual Fuel Diesel Engine at Variable Operating Conditions: A Numerical and Experimental Study,” 2015.
- Cho, H., Krishnan, S.R., Luck, R., and Srinivasan, K.K. , “Comprehensive Uncertainty Analysis of a Wiebe Function-Based Combustion Model for Pilot-Ignited Natural Gas Engines,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part D-Journal of Automobile Engineering 223(D11):1481-1498, Nov. 2009.
- Indrajuana, A., Bekdemir, C., Feru, E., and Willems, F. , “Towards Model-Based Control of RCCI-CDF Mode-Switching in Dual Fuel Engines,” in WCX World Congress Experience, 2018.
- Poetsch, C., Ofner, H., and Schutting, E. , “Assessment of a Multi Zone Combustion Model for Analysis and Prediction of CI Engine Combustion and Emissions,” SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-1439 , 2011, doi:10.4271/2011-01-1439.
- Stoumpos, S., Theotokatos, G., Boulougouris, E., Vassalos, D. et al. , “Marine Dual Fuel Engine Modelling and Parametric Investigation of Engine Settings Effect on Performance-Emissions Trade-Offs,” Ocean Engineering 157:376-386, Jun. 2018.
- Xu, S., Anderson, D., Singh, A., Hoffman, M. et al. , “Development of a Phenomenological Dual-Fuel Natural Gas Diesel Engine Simulation and its Use for Analysis of Transient Operations,” SAE International Journal of Engines 7(4):1665-1673, Oct. 2014.
- Xu, S., Anderson, D., Hoffman, M., Prucka, R., and Filipi, Z. , “A Phenomenological Combustion Analysis of a Dual-Fuel Natural-Gas Diesel Engine,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part D-Journal of Automobile Engineering 231(1):66-83, Jan. 2017.
- Woschni, G. , “A Universally Applicable Equation for the Instantaneous Heat Transfer Coefficient in the Internal Combustion Engine,” 1967.
- Aklouche, F.Z., Loubar, K., Bentebbiche, A., Awad, S., and Tazerout, M. , “Predictive Model of the Diesel Engine Operating in Dual-Fuel Mode Fuelled with Different Gaseous Fuels,” Fuel 220:599-606, May 2018.
- Mansour, C., Bounif, A., Aris, A., and Gaillard, F. , “Gas-Diesel (Dual-Fuel) Modeling in Diesel Engine Environment,” International Journal of Thermal Sciences 40(4):409-424, Apr. 2001.
- Papagiannakis, R.G., Hountalas, D.T., and Kotsiopoulos, P.N. , “Experimental and Theoretical Analysis of the Combustion and Pollutants Formation Mechanisms in Dual Fuel DI Diesel Engines,” in SAE 2005 World Congress & Exhibition, 2005.
- Liu, Z. and Karim, G.A. , “Simulation of Combustion Processes in Gas-Fuelled Diesel Engines,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy 211(2):159-169, Mar. 1997.
- Alla, G.A., Soliman, H.A., Badr, O.A., and Rabbo, M.A. , “Combustion Quasi-Two Zone Predictive Model for Dual Fuel Engines,” Energy Conversion and Management 42(12):1477-1498, 2001.
- Maghbouli, A., Saray, R.K., Shafee, S., and Ghafouri, J. , “Numerical Study of Combustion and Emission Characteristics of Dual-Fuel Engines Using 3D-CFD Models Coupled with Chemical Kinetics,” Fuel 106:98-105, Apr. 2013.
- Shu, J. et al. , “Effects of Injector Spray Angle on Combustion and Emissions Characteristics of a Natural Gas (NG)-Diesel Dual Fuel Engine Based on CFD Coupled with Reduced Chemical Kinetic Model,” Applied Energy 233:182-195, Jan. 2019.
- Zhang, Y., Kong, S.-C., and Reitz, R.D. , “Modeling and Simulation of a Dual Fuel (Diesel/Natural Gas) Engine with Multidimensional CFD,” in SAE 2003 World Congress & Exhibition, 2003.
- Han, Z. and Reitz, R.D. , “A Temperature Wall Function Formulation for Variable-Density Turbulent Flows with Application to Engine Convective Heat Transfer Modeling,” International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 40(3):613-625, Feb. 1997.
- Wurzenberger, J.C. and Katrasnik, T. , “Dual Fuel Engine Simulation - A Thermodynamic Consistent HiL Compatible Model,” SAE International Journal of Engines 7(1):183-194, Apr. 2014.
- Mikulski, M. and Wierzbicki, S. , “Validation of a Zero-Dimensional and 2-Phase Combustion Model for Dual-Fuel Compression Ignition Engine Simulation,” Thermal Science 21(1 Part B):387-399, 2017.
- Hountalas, D.T. and Papagiannakis, R.G. , “Development of a Simulation Model for Direct Injection Dual Fuel Diesel-Natural Gas Engines,” SAE Technical Paper 2000-01-0286 , 2000, doi:10.4271/2000-01-0286.
- Hountalas, D.T. and Papagiannakis, R.G. , “A Simulation Model for the Combustion Process of Natural Gas Engines with Pilot Diesel Fuel as an Ignition Source,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-01-1245 , 2001, doi:10.4271/2001-01-1245.
- Hountalas, D.T. and Papagiannakis, R.G. , “Theoretical and Experimental Investigation of a Direct Injection Dual Fuel Diesel-Natural Gas Engine,” SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0868 , 2002, doi:10.4271/2002-01-0868.
- Walther, H.-P., Schlatter, S., Wachtmeister, G., and Boulouchos, K. , “Combustion Models for Lean-Burn Gas Engines with Pilot Injection,” MTZ Worldwide 73(2):56-63, 2012.
- Pirouzpanah and Saray, K. , “A Predictive Model for the Combustion Process in Dual Fuel Engines at Part Loads Using a Quasi Dimensional Multi Zone Model and Detailed Chemical Kinetics Mechanism,” IJE Transactions B: Applications 19(1):16, 2005.
- Barro, C., Nani, C., Hutter, R., and Boulouchos, K. , “Spray Model Based Phenomenological Combustion Description and Experimental Validation for a Dual Fuel Engine,” 2017.
- Taritas, I., Kozarac, D., Sjeric, M., Sierra Aznar, M. et al. , “Development and Validation of a Quasi-Dimensional Dual Fuel (Diesel - Natural Gas) Combustion Model,” SAE International Journal of Engines 10(2):483-500, Mar. 2017.
- Eder, L., Ban, M., Pirker, G., Vujanovic, M. et al. , “Development and Validation of 3D-CFD Injection and Combustion Models for Dual Fuel Combustion in Diesel Ignited Large Gas Engines,” Energies 11(3):643, Mar. 2018.
- Ga, B.V., Nam, T.V., Tu, B.T.M., and Trung, N.Q. , “Numerical Simulation Studies on Performance, Soot and NOx Emissions of Dual-Fuel Engine Fuelled with Hydrogen Enriched Biogas Mixtures,” Iet Renewable Power Generation 12(10):1111-1118, Jul. 2018.
- Costa, M., La Villetta, M., Massarotti, N., Piazzullo, D., and Rocco, V. , “Numerical Analysis of a Compression Ignition Engine Powered in the Dual-Fuel Mode with Syngas and Biodiesel,” Energy 137:969-979, Oct. 2017.
- Mattarelli, E., Rinaldini, C.A., and Golovitchev, V.I. , “CFD-3D Analysis of a Light Duty Dual Fuel (Diesel/Natural Gas) Combustion Engine,” Energy Procedia 45:929-937, 2014.
- Cordiner, S., Rocco, V., Scarcelli, R., Gambino, M., and Iannaccone, S. , “Experiments and Multi-Dimensional Simulation of Dual-Fuel Diesel/Natural Gas Engines,” 2007.
- Feng, S. , “Numerical Study of the Performance and Emission of a Diesel-Syngas Dual Fuel Engine,” Mathematical Problems in Engineering 6825079, 2017.
- Frühhaber, J. et al. , “Modeling the Pilot Injection and the Ignition Process of a Dual Fuel Injector with Experimental Data from a Combustion Chamber Using Detailed Reaction Kinetics,” in International Powertrains, Fuels & Lubricants Meeting, 2018.
- Li, Y., Li, H., Guo, H., Li, Y., and Yao, M. , “A Numerical Investigation on Methane Combustion and Emissions from a Natural Gas-Diesel Dual Fuel Engine Using CFD Model,” Applied Energy 205:153-162, Nov. 2017.
- Mancaruso, E., Sequino, L., Vaglieco, B.M., Cameretti, M.C., De Robbio, R., and Tuccillo, R. , “CFD Analysis of the Combustion Process in Dual-Fuel Diesel Engine,” in WCX World Congress Experience, 2018.
- Mousavi, S.M., Saray, R.K., Poorghasemi, K., and Maghbouli, A. , “A Numerical Investigation on Combustion and Emission Characteristics of a Dual Fuel Engine at Part Load Condition,” Fuel 166:309-319, Feb. 2016.
- Soriano, B.S., Richardson, E., Wright, Y.M., and Schlatter, S. , “Conditional Moment Closure and G-Equation Hybrid Modelling for Dual-Fuel Methane / N-Heptane Combustion,” 2017.
- Yousefi, A., Guo, H., and Birouk, M. , “Effect of Diesel Injection Timing on the Combustion of Natural Gas/Diesel Dual-Fuel Engine at Low-High Load and Low-High Speed Conditions,” Fuel 235:838-846, Jan. 2019.
- Liu, J., Zhang, X., Wang, T., Zhang, J., and Wang, H. , “Experimental and Numerical Study of the Pollution Formation in a Diesel/CNG Dual Fuel Engine,” Fuel 159:418-429, Nov. 2015.
- Hockett, A. , “A Computational and Experimental Study on Combustion Processes in Natural Gas/Diesel Dual Fuel Engines,” 249.
- Naber, J.D. and Siebers, D.L. , “Effects of Gas Density and Vaporization on Penetration and Dispersion of Diesel Sprays,” SAE Technical Paper 960034 , 1996, doi:10.4271/960034.
- Hiroyasu, H., Kadota, T., and Arai, M. , “Development and Use of a Spray Combustion Modeling to Predict Diesel Engine Efficiency and Pollutant Emissions : Part 1 Combustion Modeling,” Bulletin of JSME 26(214):569-575, 1983.
- Reitz, R. , “Modeling Atomization Processes in High-Pressure Vaporizing Sprays,” Atomisation and Spray Technology 3(4):309-337, 1987.
- Beale, J.C. and Reitz, R.D. , “Modeling Spray Atomization with the Kelvin-Helmholtz/Rayleigh-Taylor Hybrid Model,” 9(6):623-650, 1999.
- Karim, G.A. , Dual-Fuel Diesel Engines (CRC Press, 2015).
- Hiroyasu, H. , “Diesel Engine Combustion and its Modeling,” in COMODIA, 1985, 85, 53-75.
- Hardenberg, H.O. and Hase, F.W. , “An Empirical Formula for Computing the Pressure Rise Delay of a Fuel from its Cetane Number and from the Relevant Parameters of Direct-Injection Diesel Engines,” 1979.
- Cameretti, M.C., Tuccillo, R., Simio, L.D., Iannaccone, S., and Ciaravola, U. , “A Numerical and Experimental Study of Dual Fuel Diesel Engine for Different Injection Timings,” Applied Thermal Engineering 101:630-638, May 2016.
- Papagiannakis, R.G. , “Comparative Assessment for Improvement of Performance and Exhaust Emissions in Existing Dual-Fuel Diesel Engines,” Journal of Energy Engineering 144(5):04018054, Oct. 2018.
- Papagiannakis, R.G., Hountalas, D.T., Krishnan, S.R., Srinivasan, K.K. et al. , “Numerical Evaluation of the Effects of Compression Ratio and Diesel Fuel Injection Timing on the Performance and Emissions of a Fumigated Natural Gas-Diesel Dual-Fuel Engine,” Journal of Energy Engineering 142(2):E4015015, Jun. 2016.
- Whitehouse, N.D. and Sareen, B.K. , “Prediction of Heat Release in a Quiescent Chamber Diesel Engine Allowing for Fuel/Air Mixing,” 1974.
- Al-Himyary, T.J. and Karim, G.A. , “A Correlation for the Burning Velocity of Methane-Air Mixtures at High Pressures and Temperatures,” Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power 109(4):439-442, Oct. 1987.
- Kozarac, D., Taritas, I., Sjeric, M., Krajnovic, J., and Sremec, M. , “The Optimization of the Dual Fuel Engine Injection Parameters by Using a Newly Developed Quasi-Dimensional Cycle Simulation Combustion Model,” in WCX World Congress Experience, 2018.
- Tänzler, A.G. , Experimentelle Untersuchung Eines Dual-Fuel-Brennverfahrens für Schwere Nutzfahrzeugmotoren (Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden, 2017).
- Pattas, K. and Häfner, G. , “Stickoxidbildung bei Der ottomotorischen Verbrennung,” Motortechn. Z. 34(12), 1973.
- Zeldovich, Y.A., Frank-Kamenetskii, D., and Sadovnikov, P. , “Oxidation of Nitrogen in Combustion,” Publishing House of the Acad of Sciences of USSR, 1947.
- Zhao, F., Yang, W., Zhou, D., Yu, W. et al. , “Numerical Modelling of Soot Formation and Oxidation Using Phenomenological Soot Modelling Approach in a Dual-Fueled Compression Ignition Engine,” Fuel 188:382-389, Jan. 2017.