Risk of Concussion in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions Evaluated Using Head Acceleration-Based Metrics
Published April 2, 2019 by SAE International in United States
Downloadable datasets for this paper availableAnnotation of this paper is available
Over the past decade, there has been an increase in awareness and concern about the occurrence and long-term effects of concussions. Traumatic brain injury (TBI)-related emergency department (ED) visits associated with motor vehicle collisions, including patients with a diagnosis of concussion or mild TBI (mTBI), have increased while deaths and hospital admissions related to TBI have decreased. The diagnostic criteria for concussion have evolved and broadened, and based on current assessments and diagnostic imaging techniques, there are often no objective findings, yet a diagnosis of concussion may still be rendered. Clinical assessment of concussion may be based only on patient-reported symptoms and history, making it difficult to objectively relate the reported increase in TBI-related ED visits due to motor vehicle collisions to specific collision parameters. This study aims to perform a scientific evaluation of concussion risk during motor vehicle collisions, strengthened by objective, quantitative data, specifically focusing on head acceleration-based metrics. Data from full-scale passenger vehicle crash tests are reported for frontal and rear-end collisions with delta-Vs ranging from 6.0 to 19.0 kph (3.7 to 11.8 mph) and 5.6 to 19.5 kph (3.5 to 12.1 mph), respectively. Head linear and rotational kinematic data were recorded from instrumented Hybrid III 50th percentile male anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) restrained in the driver’s seats. Several acceleration-based metrics currently used to assess risk of concussion were calculated and compared to published injury risk relationships that have been developed from field accident data, human subjects, and biomechanical models. Overall, the magnitudes of acceleration were low and the injury metrics corresponded to a negligible risk of concussion in these low- to moderate-speed collisions.
CitationPasquesi, S., Bruno, A., Courtney, A., Imler, S. et al., "Risk of Concussion in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions Evaluated Using Head Acceleration-Based Metrics," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-1218, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-01-1218.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 2]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 3]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 4]|
- Taylor, C.A., Bell, J.M., Breiding, M.J., and Xu, L., “Traumatic Brain Injury-Related Emergency Department Visits, Hospitalizations, and Deaths-United States, 2007 and 2013,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, Surveillance Summaries (Washington, DC: 2002), 66(9):1-16, 2017, doi: 10.15585/mmwr.ss6609a1.
- Woodard, T.J. and Allen, S.N., “An Overview of the Management of Concussion,” US Pharm 42(1):37-40, 2017.
- Teasdale, G., Maas, A., Lecky, F., Manley, G. et al., “The Glasgow Coma Scale at 40 Years: Standing the Test of Time,” The Lancet Neurology 13(8):844-854, 2014, doi:10.1016/S1474-4422(14)70120-6.
- Chong, C.D. and Schwedt, T.J., “Research Imaging of Brain Structure and Function after Concussion,” Headache: The Journal of Head and Face Pain 58(6):827-835, 2018, doi:10.1111/head.13269.
- Jackson, C.E., Nordstrom, L., Fonda, J.R., Fortier, C.B. et al., “Reporting of Symptoms Associated with Concussion by OEF/OIF/OND Veterans: Comparison between Research and Clinical Contexts,” Brain Injury 31(4):485-492, 2017, doi:10.1080/02699052.2017.1280740.
- Courtney, A.C., Campbell, I.C., Courtney, E., and Pasquesi, S.A., “Risk of Concussion due to Head Acceleration in Rear Impact Sled Tests of Passenger Automobile Seats,” in 62nd Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Oct. 7-10, 2018, doi:10.1080/15389588.2018.1532200.
- NHTSA, “Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 208; Occupant Crash Protection. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Volume 6, Section 571, Part 208,” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation, 2017.
- Toney-Bolger, M.E., Campbell, I.C., Miller, B.D., Davis, M.S. et al., “Evaluation of Occupant Loading in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions,” SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-1220, 2019, doi:10.4271/2019-01-1220.
- Bruno, A., Toney-Bolger, M., George, J., Koller, J. et al., “Evaluation of Occupant Kinematics in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions,” SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-1226, 2019, doi:10.4271/2019-01-1226.
- SAE International Surface Vehicle Recommended Practice, “Instrumentation for Impact Test - Part 1 - Electronic Instrumentation,” SAE Standard J211-1, Rev. Mar. 2014, https://www.sae.org/standards/content/j211/1_201403/.
- Feuerstein, D., Parker, K.H., and Boutelle, M.G., “Practical Methods for Noise Removal: Applications to Spikes, Nonstationary Quasi-Periodic Noise, and Baseline Drift,” Analytical Chemistry 81(12):4987-4994, 2009, doi:10.1021/ac900161x.
- Padgaonkar, A.J., Krieger, K.W., and King, A.I., “Measurement of Angular Acceleration of a Rigid Body Using Linear Accelerometers,” Journal of Applied Mechanics 42(3):552-556, 1975, doi:10.1115/1.3423640.
- Bussone, W.R., Bove, R., Thomas, R., Richards, D. et al., “Six-Degree-of-Freedom Accelerations: Linear Arrays Compared with Angular Rate Sensors,” SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-1017, 2010, doi:10.4271/2010-01-1017.
- Bussone, W.R., Olberding, J., and Prange, M., “Six-Degree-of-Freedom Accelerations: Linear Arrays Compared with Angular Rate Sensors in Impact Events,” SAE Int. J. Trans. Safety 5(2):194-207, 2017, doi: 10.4271/2017-01-1465.
- Winter, D.A., Biomechanics and Motor Control of Human Movement Third Edition (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2004). ISBN:978-0471449898.
- Rowson, S. and Duma, S.M., “Development of the STAR Evaluation System for Football Helmets: Integrating Player Head Impact Exposure and Risk of Concussion,” Annals of Biomedical Engineering 39(8):2130-2140, 2011, doi:10.1007/s10439-011-0322-5.
- Rowson, S., Duma, S.M., Beckwith, J.G., Chu, J.J. et al., “Rotational Head Kinematics in Football Impacts: An Injury Risk Function for Concussion,” Ann Biomed Eng 40(1):1-13, 2012, doi:10.1007/s10439-011-0392-4.
- Funk, J.R., Rowson, S., Daniel, R.W., and Duma, S.M., “Validation of Concussion Risk Curves for Collegiate Football Players Derived from HITS Data,” Biomed Eng 40(1):79-89, 2012, doi:10.1007/s10439-011-0400-8.
- Funk, J.R., Duma, S.M., Manoogian, S.J., and Rowson, S., “Biomechanical Risk Estimates for Mild Traumatic Brain Injury,” in 51st Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Oct. 15-17, 2007.
- Rowson, S. and Duma, S.M., “Brain Injury Prediction: Assessing the Combined Probability Using Linear and Rotational Head Acceleration,” Ann Biomed Eng 41(5):873-882, 2013, doi:10.1007/s10439-012-0731-0.
- Rowson, B., “Evaluation and Application of Brain Injury Criteria to Improve Protective Headgear Design,” Dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2016.
- Greenwald, R.M., Gwin, J.T., Chu, J.J., and Crisco, J.J., “Head Impact Severity Measures for Evaluating Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Risk Exposure,” Neurosurgery 62(4):789-798, 2008, doi:10.1227/01.neu.0000318162.67472.ad.
- Naunheim, R.S., Standeven, J., Richter, C., and Lewis, L.L., “Comparison of Impact Data in Hockey, Football, and Soccer,” J. Trauma 48(5):938-941, 2000, doi:10.1097/00005373-200005000-00020.
- Tierney, R.T., Higgins, M., Caswell, S.V., Brady, J. et al., “Sex Differences in Head Acceleration during Heading while Wearing Soccer Headgear,” J Athl Train 43(6):578-584, 2008, doi:10.4085/1062-6050-43.6.578.
- Bayly, P., Naunheim, R., Standeven, J., Neubauer, J., et al., “Linear and Angular Accelerations of the Human Head during Heading of a Soccer Ball,” in Proceedings of the Second Joint EMBS/BMES Conference, Houston, TX, 2002.
- Pincemaille, Y., Trosseille, X., Mack, P., Tarriere, C. et al., “Some New Data Related to Human Tolerance Obtained from Volunteer Boxers,” SAE Technical Paper 892435, 1989, doi:10.4271/892435.
- Viano, D.C. and Parenteau, C.S., “Concussion, Diffuse Axonal Injury, and AIS4+ Head Injury in Motor Vehicle Crashes,” Traffic Injury Prevention 16(8):747-753, 2015, 2015, doi:10.1080/15389588.2015.1013188.
- Takhounts, E.G., Craig, M.J., Moorhouse, K., McFadden, J. et al., “Development of Brain Injury Criteria (BrIC),” SAE Technical Paper 2013-22-0010, 2013, doi:10.4271/2013-22-0010.
- Laituri, T.R., Henry, S., Pline, K., Li, G. et al., “New Risk Curves for NHTSA’s Brain Injury Criterion (BrIC): Derivations and Assessments,” SAE Technical Paper 2016-22-0012, 2016, doi:10.4271/2016-22-0012.
- Kleinberger, M. et al., “Development of Improved Injury Criteria for the Assessment of Advanced Automotive Restraint Systems,” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), Sept. 1998.
- NHTSA, “Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards,” https://one.nhtsa.gov/cars/rules/import/fmvss/index.html.
- Hertz, E., “A Note on the Head Injury Criterion (HIC) as a Predictor of the Risk of Skull Fracture,” in 37th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, San Antonio, TX, Nov. 4-6, 1993.
- Eppinger, R., Sun, E., Bandak, F., Haffner, M. et al., “Development of Improved Injury Criteria for the Assessment of Advanced Automotive Restraint Systems-II,” National Highway Transportation and Safety Administration, Nov. 1999.
- Mertz, H.J., Irwin, A.L., and Prasad, P., “Biomechanical and Scaling Basis for Frontal and Side Impact Injury Assessment Reference Values,” Stapp Car Crash J 60:625-657, 2016.
- NHTSA, “Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 201; Occupant protection in interior impact. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Volume 6, Section 571, Part 201,” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation, 2017.
- NHTSA, “Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 214; Side impact protection. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Volume 6, Section 571, Part 214,” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation, 2017.
- NHTSA, “Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 202a; Head restraints; Mandatory applicability begins on September 1, 2009. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49, Volume 6, Section 571, Part 202a,” National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Department of Transportation, 2017.
- Exponent. Rear Impact Research, March 22-23, 1994.
- Davee, D., Brown, J., and Raasch, C., “Case Study of Clothing Fabric Transfer to Seat Belt Webbing under Accident Forces,” SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-0904, 2006, doi:10.4271/2006-01-0904.
- Welch, T.D.J., Bridges, A.W., Gates, D.H., Heller, M.F. et al., “An Evaluation of BioRID II and Hybrid III During Low-and Moderate-Speed Rear Impact,” SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-1031, 2010, doi:10.4271/2010-01-1031.
- Kim, A., Anderson, K.F., Berliner, J., Bryzik, C. et al., “A Comparison of the Hybrid III and BioRID II Dummies in Low-Severity, Rear-Impact Sled Tests,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-22-0012, 2001, 2001, doi:10.4271/2001-22-0012.
- Kim, A., Anderson, K.F., Berliner, J., Hassan, J. et al., “A Biofidelity Evaluation of the BioRID II, Hybrid III and RID2 for use in Rear Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 2003-22-0022, 2003, doi:10.4721/2003-22-0022.
- Kim, A., Sutterfield, A., Rao, A., Anderson, K. F., et al., “A Comparison of the BioRID II, Hybrid III, and RID2 in Low Severity Rear Impacts. in Proceedings of the 19th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV), 2005, 6-9.
- Mkandawire, C., Mazzucco, D., Vijayakumar, V., Scher, I., et al., “Head Kinematics and Upper Neck Loading during Simulated Low-Speed Lateral Impact Collisions,” in Proceedings of FISITA 2006 World Automotive Congress, 2006.
- Funk, J.R., Cormier, J.M., Bain, C.E., Guzman, H. et al., “An Evaluation of Various Neck Injury Criteria in Vigorous Activities,” in Proceedings of the International Research Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact (IRCOBI), 2007, 233-248.
- Funk, J.R., Cormier, J.M., Bain, C.E., Guzman, H. et al., “Head and Neck Loading in Everyday and Vigorous Activities,” Ann Biomed Eng 39(2):766-776, 2011, doi:10.1007/s10439-010-0183-3.
- Kloppenborg, N., Amenson, T., Wernik, J., and Wiechel, J., “Vehicle and Occupant Response in Low-Speed Go-Kart Crash Tests,” in Proceedings of the ASME 2015 International Mechanical Engineering Congress and Exposition, IMECE2015-53585, 2015, doi: 10.1115/IMECE2015-53585.
- Cormier, J., Gwin, L., Reinhart, L., Wood, R., and Bain, C., “A Comprehensive Review of Low-Speed Rear Impact Volunteer Studies and a Comparison to Real-World Outcomes,” Spine 43(18):1250-1258, 2018, doi: 10.1097/BRS.0000000000002622.
- Goodwin, V., Martin, D., Sackett, R., Schaefer, G. et al., “Vehicle and Occupant Response in Low Speed Car to Barrier Override Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0442, 1999, doi:10.4271/1999-01-0442.
- Matsushita, T., Sato, T., Hirabayashi, K., Fujimura, S. et al., “X-Ray Study of the Human Neck Motion Due to Head Inertia Loading,” SAE Technical Paper 942208, 1994, doi:10.4271/942208.