This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Impacts of Flashing Emergency Lights and Vehicle-Mounted Illumination on Driver Visibility and Glare
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 02, 2019 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Flashing emergency lights on police cars, fire trucks, and ambulances need to be bright enough to alert otherwise unaware drivers about their presence on and near the roadway. Anecdotal evidence suggests that public safety agencies select emergency lighting systems with red or blue flashing lights based on their apparent brightness, with brighter lights judged as "better." With the advent of light emitting diodes (LEDs), emergency flashing lights are brighter and produce more highly saturated colors, thereby causing greater discomfort and disability glare. As a result, first response workers are at higher risk for being injured or killed in vehicle crashes because approaching drivers cannot see them. In the present study, participants viewed red and blue flashing lights on a scale model police vehicle, conforming to present recommended practices for emergency lights. Lights varied in intensity and optical power (intensity × duration). Participants were asked to view the scale model police vehicle and identify whether a police officer figure was standing beside the vehicle. In some trials, white LED sources were energized, providing low-level illumination on both sides of the vehicle, near the possible locations of the police officer figure. In some trials, no police officer figure was present. Participants identified the location of the police officer figure, if any, as quickly as possible. The blue flashing lights were always perceived as brighter and as more glaring than the red flashing lights at the same intensity. While the probability of correctly detecting the police officer figure was affected by intensity, the color of the flashing lights did not matter. Importantly, the presence of low-level white illumination at the side of model vehicle significantly improved detection accuracy.
CitationBullough, J., Skinner, N., and Rea, M., "Impacts of Flashing Emergency Lights and Vehicle-Mounted Illumination on Driver Visibility and Glare," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-0847, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-01-0847.
- Society of Automotive Engineers, “Optical Warning Devices for Authorized Emergency, Maintenance, and Service Vehicles,” SAE Standard J845, 2019.
- Society of Automotive Engineers, “Directional Flashing Optical Warning Devices for Authorized Emergency, Maintenance, and Service Vehicles,” SAE Standard J595, 2014.
- Lighting Research Center, New Approaches in Warning Beacon Design to Improve Worker Safety (Troy, NY: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, 2016).
- Wyszecki, G. and Stiles, W.S., Color Science Second Edition (New York, NY: Wiley Interscience, 1982).
- Bullough, J.D., Yuan, Z., and Rea, M.S., “Perceived Brightness of Incandescent and LED Aviation Signal Lights,” Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine 78(9):893-900, 2007.
- Bullough, J.D., “Spectral Sensitivity for Extrafoveal Discomfort Glare,” Journal of Modern Optics 56(13):1518-1522, 2009.
- Kersavage, K., Skinner, N.P., Bullough, J.D., Garvey, P.M. et al., “Investigation of Flashing and Intensity Characteristics for Vehicle-Mounted Warning Beacons,” Accident Analysis and Prevention 119(1):23-28, 2018.
- Kersavage, K., Skinner, N.P., Bullough, J.D., Garvey, P.M., Donnell, E.T., and Rea, M.S., “Driver Behavior in Response to Flashing Lights,” Transportation Research Board 98th Annual Meeting, Washington, DC, January 13-17. 2019, Washington, DC: Transportation Research Board.
- Cantu, T., “Charges against Driver Who Struck Round Rock Officer Upgraded,” Round Rock Patch, May 19, 2018.
- Leblanc, M., “Driver Flees after Striking City Officer,” Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, May 22, 2018.
- Wilson, L., “Savannah Police Officer Killed in Line of Duty at Scene of Early Morning Crash on I-16,” Island Packet, May 25, 2018.
- Schneider, C., “Cops: Drunken Driver Hits Suffolk Police Vehicle, Injures Officer,” Newsday, May 12, 2018.
- Ryckaert, V., “Greenwood Police Officer Hit by 2 Cars While Directing Traffic at Center Grove High School,” Indianapolis Star, March 1, 2018.
- Anonymous, “Lake Delton Firefighter in Stable Condition after Being Struck on Interstate,” NBC 15 News, February3, 2018.
- MacLeod, K., “Sandwich Man Arrested in Hit-and-Run that Injured Firefighter,” CBS 4 Boston News, March 5, 2018.
- Anonymous, “NC Firefighter Struck, Killed; Driver Charged with DWI,” Winston-Salem Journal, October 9, 2017.
- Milldrum, G., “Firefighters Urge Caution Near Accident Scenes,” Effingham Daily News, May 29, 2018.
- Bullough, J.D., Donnell, E.T., and Rea, M.S., “To Illuminate or Not to Illuminate: Roadway Lighting as it Affects Traffic Safety at Intersections,” Accident Analysis and Prevention 53(1):65-77, 2013.
- Illuminating Engineering Society, Lighting Handbook: Reference Volume (New York, NY: Illuminating Engineering Society, 1981).
- Olson, P. L., Cleveland, D.E., Fancher, P.S., Kostyniuk, L.P., and Schneider, L.W., “Parameters Affecting Safe Stopping Distance,” NCHRP Report 270, Washington, DC, Transportation Research Board, 1984.
- Flannagan, M.J. and Devonshire, J.M., Effects of Warning Lamps on Pedestrian Visibility and Driver Behavior (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan, 2007).
- Rea, M.S. and Bullough, J.D., “Two Types of Glare: Two Visual Channels,” Scandinavian Journal of Optometry and Visual Science 11(2), 2018.
- Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage, Light as a True Visual Quantity: Principles of Measurement, CIE 41:1978 (Paris, France: Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage, 1978).
- Flannagan, M.J., Blower, D.F., and Devonshire, J.M., Effects of Warning Lamp Color and Intensity on Driver Vision (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan, 2008).
- Rea, M.S., Radetsky, L.C., and Bullough, J.D., “Toward a Model of Outdoor Lighting Scene Brightness,” Lighting Research and Technology 43(1):7-30, 2011.