Control-Oriented Modeling of a Vehicle Drivetrain for Shuffle and Clunk Mitigation
Published April 2, 2019 by SAE International in United States
Downloadable datasets for this paper availableAnnotation of this paper is available
Flexibility and backlash of vehicle drivelines typically cause unwanted oscillations and noise, known as shuffle and clunk, during tip-in and tip-out events. Computationally efficient and accurate driveline models are necessary for the design and evaluation of torque shaping strategies to mitigate this shuffle and clunk. To accomplish these goals, this paper develops a full-order physics-based model and uses this model to develop a reduced-order model (ROM), which captures the main dynamics that influence the shuffle and clunk phenomena. The full-order model (FOM) comprises several components, including the engine as a torque generator, backlash elements as discontinuities, and propeller and axle shafts as compliant elements. This model is experimentally validated using the data collected from a Ford vehicle. The validation results indicate less than 1% error between the model and measured shuffle oscillation frequencies. The reduced-order model is derived by lumping 24 inertia elements into 2 elements, 3 stiffness and damping elements into 2 elements, and 2 backlashes into 1 element. As part of the reduced-order model development, the paper (i) investigates the effect of using a simplified tire model; (ii) investigates the effect of lumping transmission and final drive backlashes; and (iii) evaluates the ROM for shuffle and clunk control. Simulation results show that the ROM replicates the behavior of the FOM with less than 5% error in predicting shuffle frequency, thus making it suitable for the design of torque shaping controllers to mitigate shuffle and clunk.
- Prithvi Reddy - Michigan Technological University
- Kaushal Darokar - Michigan Technological University
- Darrell Robinette - Michigan Technological University
- Mahdi Shahbakhti - Michigan Technological University
- Jason Blough - Michigan Technological University
- Maruthi Ravichandran - Ford Research & Advanced Engineering
- Mary Farmer - Ford Research & Advanced Engineering
- Jeff Doering - Ford Research & Advanced Engineering
CitationReddy, P., Darokar, K., Robinette, D., Shahbakhti, M. et al., "Control-Oriented Modeling of a Vehicle Drivetrain for Shuffle and Clunk Mitigation," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-0345, 2019.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
- Griffin, M.J., Handbook of Human Vibration (Academic press, 2012).
- List, H.O. and Schoeggl, P., “Objective Evaluation of Vehicle Driveability,” SAE Technical Paper 980204, 1998, doi:10.4271/980204.
- Sorniotti, A., “Driveline Modeling, Experimental Validation and Evaluation of the Influence of the Different Parameters on the Overall System Dynamics,” SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-0632, 2008, doi:10.4271/2008-01-0632.
- Nordin, M., Galic’, J., and Gutman, P.O., “New Models for Backlash and Gear Play,” International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing 11(1):49-63, 1997.
- Schilders, W.H., Van der Vorst, H.A., and Rommes, J., Model Order Reduction: Theory, Research Aspects and Applications. Vol. 13 (Springer, 2008).
- Hayat, O., Lebrun, M., and Domingues, E., “Powertrain Driveability Evaluation: Analysis and Simplification of Dynamic Models,” SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-1328, 2003, doi:10.4271/2003-01-1328.
- Hrovat, D. and Tobler, W., “Bond Graph Modeling of Automotive Power Trains,” Journal of the Franklin Institute 328(5-6):623-662, 1991.
- Capitani, R., Delogu, M., and Pilo, L., “Analysis of the Influence of a Vehicle’s Driveline Dynamic Behaviour Regarding the Performance Perception at Low Frequencies,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-01-3333, 2001, doi:10.4271/2001-01-3333.
- Hao, D., Zhao, C., and Huang, Y., “A Reduced-Order Model for Active Suppression Control of Vehicle Longitudinal Low-Frequency Vibration,” Shock and Vibration, 2018.
- Lagerberg, A. and Egardt, B., “Evaluation of Control Strategies for Automotive Powertrains with Backlash,” in 6th International Symposium on Advanced Vehicle Control, Hiroshima, Japan, 2002.
- Lagerberg, A. and Egardt, B., “Estimation of Backlash with Application to Automotive Powertrains,” in Proceedings of 42nd IEEE International Conference on Decision and Control, Maui, HI, 2003.
- Lagerberg, A. and Egardt, B., “Model Predictive Control of Automotive Powertrains with Backlash,” in 16th IFAC World Congress, in Prague, Czech Republic, 2005, 4-8.
- Lagerberg, A. and Egardt, B., “Backlash Estimation with Application to Automotive Powertrains,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology 15(3):483-493, 2007.
- Templin, P., “Simultaneous Estimation of Driveline Dynamics and Backlash Size for Control Design,” in IEEE International conference on Control Applications, San Antonio, TX, 2008.
- Templin, P. and Egardt, B., “An LQR Torque Compensator for Driveline Oscillation Damping,” in IEEE Conference on Control Applications, St. Petersburg, Russia, 2009.
- Templin, P. and Egardt, B., “A Powertrain LQR-Torque Compensator with Backlash Handling,” Oil & Gas Science and Technology-Revue d’IFP Energies Nouvelles 66(4):645-654, 2011.
- Canova, M., Rostiti, C., D’Avico, L., Stockar, S. et al., “Model-Based Wheel Torque and Backlash Estimation for Drivability Control,” SAE Int. J. Engines 10:1318-1327, 2017, doi:10.4271/2017-01-1111.
- Guercioni, G.R., Galvagno, E., Tota, A., Vigliani, A. et al., “Driveline Backlash and Half-Shaft Torque Estimation for Electric Powertrains Control,” SAE Technical Paper 2018-01-1345, 2018, doi:10.4271/2018-01-1345.
- Di Cairano, S., Doering, J., Kolmanovsky, I.V., and Hrovat, D., “Model Predictive Control of Engine Speed during Vehicle Deceleration,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology 22(6):2205-2217, 2014.
- Alkeilani, A., Wang, L.Y., and Ying, H., “Direct Torque Feedback for Accurate Engine Torque Delivery and Improved Powertrain Performance,” Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power 138(11):112801, 2016.
- Pacejka, H.B., “The Tyre as a Vehicle Component,” in 26th FISITA Congress, Prague, Czechoslovakia, June 16-13, 1996.
- Siemens Industry Software NV, LMS Amehelp - User Manual for LMS.Amesim 15.2 (Plano, TX, 2017).
- Ogata, K., Modern Control Engineering. Vol. 5 (Pearson Inc., 2009).