This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Computational Cost and Accuracy of Spray Droplet Collision Models
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 02, 2019 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
This study focuses on Lagrangian spray models that are commonly used in engine CFD simulations. In modeling sprays, droplet collision is one of the physical phenomena that must be accounted for. There are two main parts of droplet collision models for sprays - detecting colliding pairs of droplets and predicting the outcomes of these collisions. For the first part, we focus on the efficiency of the algorithm. We present an implementation of the arbitrary adaptive collision mesh model of Hou and Schmidt , and examine its efficiency in dealing with large simulations. Through theoretical analysis and numerical tests, we show that the computational cost of this model scales pseudo-linearly with respect to the number of parcels in the sprays. Regarding the second part, we examine the variations in existing phenomenological models used for predicting binary droplet collision outcomes. A quantitative accuracy metric is used to evaluate the models with respect to the experimental data set. To provide a holistic perspective, three different experimental datasets that contain over 2000 data points are collated, and used in the evaluation. These analyses show that the accuracy of the collision outcome prediction is between 65% to 70%, which indicates a need for future improvement.
CitationAgarwal, A., Wang, Y., Liang, L., Naik, C. et al., "The Computational Cost and Accuracy of Spray Droplet Collision Models," SAE Technical Paper 2019-01-0279, 2019, https://doi.org/10.4271/2019-01-0279.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
- Hou, S. and Schmidt, D.P., “Adaptive Collision Meshing and Satellite Droplet Formation in Spray Simulations,” Int. J. Multiph. Flow 32(8):935-956, Aug. 2006.
- MacInness, J.M. and Bracco, F.V., “Comparisons of Deterministic and Stochastic Computations of Drop Collisions in Dense Sprays,” Prog. Astronaut. Aeronaut., 1991.
- Amsden, T.D., O’Rourke, A.A., and Butler, P.J., “KIVA-II: A Computer Program for Chemically Reactive Flows with Sprays,” 1989.
- Hou, S., Are, S., and Schmidt, D.P., “A Generalized Adaptative Collision Mesh for Multiple Injector Orifices in 13th Int. Multidimens. Engine Model. User’s Gr. Meet. SAE Congr, 2003.
- Schmidt, D.P. and Rutland, C.J., “A New Droplet Collision Algorithm,” J. Comput. Phys. 164(1):62-80, Oct. 2000.
- Sun, R.D. and Reitz, Y., “Modeling Low-Pressure Injections in Diesel HCCI Engines,” in ILASS Americas, 20th Annual Conference on Liquid Atomization and Spray Systems, Chicago, 2007.
- Munnannur, A., Droplet Collision Modeling in Multi-Dimensional Engine Spray Computations (University of Wisconsin--Madison, 2007).
- Brazier-Smith, P.R., Jennings, S.G., and Latham, J., “The Interaction of Falling Water Drops: Coalescence,” Proc. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 326(1566):393-408, 1972.
- Qian, J. and Law, C.K., “Regimes of Coalescence and Separation in Droplet Collision,” J. Fluid Mech. 331, Jan. 1997.
- Ko, G.H. and Ryou, H.S., “Modeling of Droplet Collision-Induced Breakup Process,” Int. J. Multiph. Flow 31(6):723-738, Jun. 2005.
- Estrade, J.-P., Carentz, H., Lavergne, G., and Biscos, Y., “Experimental Investigation of Dynamic Binary Collision of Ethanol Droplets - A Model for Droplet Coalescence and Bouncing,” Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow 20(5):486-491, Oct. 1999.
- Brenn, G., Valkovska, D., and Danov, K.D., “The Formation of Satellite Droplets by Unstable Binary Drop Collisions,” Phys. Fluids 13(9):2463-2477, Sep. 2001.
- Ashgriz, N. and Poo, J.Y., “Coalescence and Separation in Binary Collisions of Liquid Drops,” J. Fluid Mech. 221(1):183, Dec. 1990.
- Sommerfeld, M. and Kuschel, M., “Modelling Droplet Collision Outcomes for Different Substances and Viscosities,” Exp. Fluids 57(12):187, Dec. 2016.
- Munnannur, A. and Reitz, R.D., “A New Predictive Model for Fragmenting and Non-Fragmenting Binary Droplet Collisions,” Int. J. Multiph. Flow 33(8):873-896, Aug. 2007.
- Jiang, Y.J., Umemura, A., and Law, C.K., “An Experimental Investigation on the Behavior of Hydrocarbon Droplets,” J. Fluid Mech. 234:171-190, 1992.
- Georjon, T.L. and Reitz, R.D., “A Drop-Shattering Collision Model for Multidimensional Spray Computations,” At. Sprays 9(3):231-254, 1999.
- ANSYS Inc., “ANSYS Forte (Version 2019 R2), Computer Software, San Diego, CA, 2019.”
- Reitz, R.D., “Modeling Atomization Processes in High-Pressure Vaporizing Sprays,” At. Sprays 3:309-337, 1987.
- Reitz, R.D. and Beale, J.C., “Modeling Spray Atomization with the Kelvin-Helmholtz/Rayleigh-Taylor Hybrid Model,” At. Sprays 9(6):623-650, 1999.
- Willis, K. and Orme, M., “Binary Droplet Collisions in a Vacuum Environment: An Experimental Investigation of the Role of Viscosity,” Exp. Fluids 34(1):28-41, Jan. 2003.