This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Highly Efficient Civil Aviation, Now via Operations - AAR and Challenges
Technical Paper
2018-01-1925
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
This content contains downloadable datasets
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Global civil aviation growth at 5+% yearly poses extreme environmental challenges. Advances have appeared gradually through improved aerodynamic shapes, using carbon fibres, and enhanced engines; however, as these technologies mature, direct efficiency advances require increasing effort. Often Passenger convenience is forgotten e.g. the long-range air traffic has developed on hub-spoke basis implying extra feeder flights, transit passenger inconveniences, capacity issues.
Efficiency metrics emphasize “Why, How & What”, with an understanding of the range sensitivities, operational concepts and performance goals via the important “X-factor”. For given range, current aircraft are “greener” than previous generations. Medium range aircraft s are always greener than those for short or long ranges. However, currently, the major trend is for the latter: twin-aisle A350, A380, B787, B777X (10+% payload, 40+% fuel to MTOW). Shorter range single-aisle aircraft are “feeders” or newer derivatives: A320, B737 class (20+% payload, 20+% fuel to MTOW).
New technologies could feature in future e.g. Natural Laminar flow, riblets, enhanced loads allevation, composite tailoring, morphing structures, distributed propulsion, bio-fuels etc. These may make significant improvements and lead to unconventional layouts e.g. blended wing bodies, high aspect ratio wings, oblique wings, and joined wings. Additionally, significant environmental gains can be made via operations e.g. AAR and Formation flying.
Air-to-air refuelling (AAR) has been practised and perfected by the Military for 80+ years. Tankers are sky “gas- stations”. The Military objective is for mission success rather than fuel economy. Tankers accompany and refuel short- range aircraft over longer missions. AAR can be a strong enabler for the civil aviation. Small dedicated tankers (A320 size) can operate over short radii, refuelling longer range cruisers. AAR will always retain top hierarchy over any technological advances, offering step change towards highly efficient aviation. We discuss the pros and cons of operational issues, routing and constraints, turbulence, air navigation and environmental impact.
Replacing today´s inter-continental system with AAR gives fuel and CO2 reductions of 15-30% depending on range. Additionally, 30-40% weight savings lead manufacturers focus on smaller aircraft. Major COC and DOC reductions of a similar order occur. Noise, emissions, wake effects are favourable, meeting ACARE/NASA goals. A by-product is that laminar-flow aircraft introduction can be eased.
Increasing AAR benefits occur as Point A to B system replaces the hub--spoke system. The smaller AAR-cruisers imply ground-based opportunities: smaller airports and new connections, easing the transit passenger handling and reducing travel time. For sustainable aviation growth and future urbanisation, short flights are replaced by other means. The capacity relief becomes available for long flights (only aviation is suitable). Maintaining transport capacity, less AAR enabled cruisers are needed; these operate at 20+% payload to MTOW. More likely is that the total airborne mass is lower.
Certification and Operational rules will need revision. New tankers or other types modified from civil aircraft respect most CS-25 regulations. We aim for automatic refuelling (as demonstrated by A330 tanker recently and as in US-UCAV programme). We allude to newer versatile twin-aisle cruisers with differing capacities operating world-wide ranges with AAR, blending with formation flying. All this should “spur/re-vitalise” Aviation. We propose practical demonstrations. A game changer in sight!
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Nangia, R., "Highly Efficient Civil Aviation, Now via Operations - AAR and Challenges," SAE Technical Paper 2018-01-1925, 2018, https://doi.org/10.4271/2018-01-1925.Data Sets - Support Documents
Title | Description | Download |
---|---|---|
Unnamed Dataset 1 |
Also In
References
- IPCC (Inter-Governmental Panel on Climate Change) 2014
- EEC FP7, RECREATE Programme (2011-15) Advanced Aero Concepts, Design & Operations RAeS Applied Aerodynamics Conference Bristol, UK July 22-24 2014
- Warwick , G. Fuel for Thought Aviation Week 2015 38 43
- Nangia , R.K. Efficiency Parameters for Modern Commercial Aircraft RAeS Aeronautical Journal 110 1110 495 510 2006
- Nangia , R.K. Operations and Aircraft Design towards “Greener” Civil Aviation Using Air-to-Air Refuelling The RAeS Aeronautical Journal 2006
- Nangia , R.K. ‘Greener’ Civil Aviation Using Air-to-Air Refuelling - Relating Aircraft Design Efficiency & Tanker Offload Efficiency The RAeS Aeronautical Journal 2007
- Nangia , R.K. and Martensson , T. Towards Design of Efficient Concepts for Civil Air to Air Refuelling (AAR) RAeS Applied Aero. Conference Advanced Aero Concepts, Design & Operations Bristol, UK July 22-24 2014
- Nangia , R.K. Efficient Tankers & Logistics for Introducing Air to Air Refuelling (AAR) Civil Aviation CATO/IMAPP Conference Delft, the Netherlands July 20-23 2015
- Jupp , J.A. The Design of Future Passenger Aircraft - The Environmental and Fuel Price Challenges The RAeS Aeronautical Journal 120 37 60 2016
- Nickol , C.L. and McCullers , L.A. Hybrid Wing Body Configuration System Studies AIAA Paper
- Nickol , C.L. Hybrid Wing Body Configuration Scaling Study AIAA 2012-0337 2012
- Nickol , C.L. and Haller , W.J. Assessment of the Performance Potential of Advanced Subsonic Transport Concepts for NASA’s Environmentally Responsible Aviation Project AIAA-2016-7652 2016
- Reist , T.A. and Zingg , D.W. Aerodynamic Design of Blended Wing-Body and Lifting-Fuselage Aircraft AIAA-2016
- Nangia , R.K. , Palmer , M. , Hyde , L. , and Cooper , J.E. Aerodynamic Efficient Configurations & Structural Design Challenges Arising - Joined Wings & Oblique Wings CEAS European Air and Space Conference Manchester 2009
- Lambert , L.A. , Cooper , J.E. , and Nangia , R.K. Bucking Alleviation for Joined-Wing Aircraft Journal of Aircraft 53 3 2016
- Drela , M. Development of the D8 Transport Configuration AIAA-2011-3970 2011
- Drela , M. 2010
- Nangia , R.K. Highly Efficient Civil Aviation, Now via Operations - AAR & Challenges AIAA 2018-3591
- Li , M Conceptual Design of Joint-Wing Tanker for Civil Operations RAeS Applied Aerodynamics Conference Bristol, UK July 22-24 2014
- Lee , D. et al. Aviation and Global Climate Change in the 21st Century Atmospheric Environment 2009
- Spencer , R.J. Predicting the Certification Basis for Airliner Air-to-Air Refuelling RAeS Applied Aerodynamics Conference Bristol, UK July 22-24 2014 RAeS Aeronautical Journal 2015
- Birgelen , T. and Zajac , S. Air-to-Air Refuelling of Civil Air Transport Aircraft - A Certification Approach RAeS Applied Aerodynamics Conference Bristol, UK July 22-24 2014