This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Correlation of “Non-Zero” Speedometer Readings with EDR Data
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 03, 2018 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
Observations made during forensic automotive crash investigations have identified instances of non-zero, post-crash speedometer readings and created questions as to the validity of the indicated speed relative to the vehicle speed at impact. Previously published work has addressed many issues related to the reliability of non-zero, post-crash speedometer readings identified in vehicles as well as motorcycles. Much of this work established criteria that related the reliability of the post-crash needle position to the design of the stepper motor that controls the needle. Part of this criteria is related to the static torque associated with the speedometer needle shaft rotation due to outside (crash) forces. The published criteria were evaluated in staged crash tests which investigated the ability to maintain needle position under longitudinal and lateral forces after an electrical power loss. In an effort to extend the science, this paper compares non-zero, post-crash speedometer readings with event data recorder (EDR) data from twenty-one real-world crashes where both non-zero, post-crash speedometer readings and EDR data were available. Results from this study suggest a positive correlation between non-zero speedometer readings and vehicles experiencing both an electrical power loss and a single impact. However, this study also shows a negative correlation between non-zero speedometer readings and vehicles experiencing an electrical power loss and multiple impacts. Eighteen of the twenty-one vehicles had valid pre-crash EDR speeds. Of those eighteen vehicles, the speedometer position and EDR speed were within ±15% for fourteen of the vehicles. The current study also demonstrates that non-zero tachometer readings do not always improve confidence levels of non-zero speedometer readings. While the post-crash needle position may provide a good estimate of the travel speed of the vehicle at the time of power loss, there are numerous other factors which must be considered prior to accepting these readings.
CitationYannaccone, J. and Kinder, R., "Correlation of “Non-Zero” Speedometer Readings with EDR Data," SAE Technical Paper 2018-01-0522, 2018, https://doi.org/10.4271/2018-01-0522.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 2]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 3]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 4]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 5]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 6]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 7]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 8]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 9]|
- Goddard, C. and Price, D., “An Assessment of Speedometers Using Stepper Motors to Hold Their Position During High Speed Impact Testing,” Proceedings of the 11th ITAI International Conference, Birmingham, 2014.
- Goddard, C. and Price, D., “A Review of Speedometers and the Criteria to Be Considered before Accepting “Frozen” Readings and Other Marks,” Proceedings of the 10th ITAI International Conference, Leeds, 2011.
- Goddard, C. and Price, D., "Speedometers and Collision Reconstruction," SAE Technical Paper 2017-01-1412, 2017, doi:10.4271/2017-01-1412. Anderson, R.D., Post Collision Speedometer Readings and Vehicle Impact Speeds, Collision, Vol 5 Issue 2, p32-41, 2010.
- Goddard, C. and Price, D., “The Behaviour of Instrument Clusters during High-Speed Crash Testing,” EVU, 2015.
- Stoner, D. and Zeldes, I., “Speedometer Examination an Aid in Accident Investigation,” FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, Investigative Aids 65920.
- Kuranowski, A., “Reliable Determination of Impact Velocity on the Basis of Indications of the Speedometer Stopped After the Collision,” Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific Conference, Transbaltica, 2009.
- Yuan, Q., Li, Y., Xing, S., and Lv, Y., “Correlation between Residual Speedometer Needle Reading and Impact Speed of Vehicles in Traffic Accidents,” International Journal of Automotive Technology 16(6):1057-1063, 2015.
- Goddard, C.H., “Crash Testing Stepper Motors & Speedometers,” Impact: The Journal of the Institute of Traffic Accident Investigators’ 21(3), 2013.
- Montalbano, P., Melcher, D., Keller, R., Rush, T. et al., “Testing Methodology to Evaluate Reliability of a “Frozen” Speedometer Reading in Motorcycle / Scooter Impacts with Pre-Impact Braking,” SAE Technical Paper 2016-01-1482, 2016, doi:10.4271/2016-01-1482.
- Anderson, R.D., “Post-Collision Speedometer Readings and Vehicle Impact Speeds,” Collision: The International Compendium for Crash Research 5(2):32-41, 2010.
- American National Standards Institute, “Electric Speedometer Specification, on Road: SAE J1226 FEB83,” Society of Automotive Engineers, 1984.
- Hague, D., “Accuracy of Retained Speedometer Readings,” Proceedings of the 11th Institute of Traffic Accident Investigators International Conference, Birmingham, 2014.
- 49 CFR Part 563, “Event Data Recorders,” 1 Oct 2016.