This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Impact of Ester Structures on the Soot Characteristics and Soot Oxidative Reactivity of Biodiesel
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 14, 2015 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A study and analysis of the relation of biodiesel chemical structures to the resulting soot characteristics and soot oxidative reactivity is presented. Soot samples generated from combustion of various methyl esters, alkanes, biodiesel and diesel fuels in laminar co-flow diffusion flames are analyzed to evaluate the impact of fuel-bound oxygen in fatty acid esters on soot oxidation behavior.
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of soot samples collected from diffusion flames show that chemical variations in biodiesel ester compounds have an impact on soot oxidative reactivity and soot characteristics in contrast to findings reported previously in the literature. Soot derived from methyl esters with shorter alkyl chains, such as methyl butyrate and methyl hexanoate, exhibit higher reactivity than those with longer carbon chain lengths, such as methyl oleate, which are more representative of biodiesel fuels. Structural analysis is performed via Raman spectroscopy on methyl esters derived soot samples and compared with n-dodecane derived soot. These data are consistent with literature reports that lower structural order enhances reactivity. Soot reactivity analysis of methyl esters with different types of carbon-carbon bonds (single versus double), but with the same carbon number, suggests that carbon-carbon bond types and locations also affect soot reactivity. In addition, reactivity of soot from a high-cetane, low-aromatic diesel fuel is assessed and is found to exhibit lower reactivity than soot from a conventional diesel fuel.
CitationBarrientos, E., Maricq, M., Boehman, A., and Anderson, J., "Impact of Ester Structures on the Soot Characteristics and Soot Oxidative Reactivity of Biodiesel," SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-1080, 2015, https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-1080.
- Yamane, K., Asakawa, T., Numao, H., and Komori, M., “Characteristics of DPF for Diesel Engine Fueled With Biodiesel Fuel - First Report: Self-Regeneration Behavior on Vehicle Road Test and Engine Bench Rig Test,” SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1883, 2004, doi:10.4271/2004-01-1883.
- Boehman, A., Song, J., and Alam, M. “Impact of Biodiesel Blending on Diesel Soot and the Regeneration of Particulate Filters,” Energy & Fuels 19: 1857-1864, 2005.
- Williams, A., McCormick, R., Hayes, R., Ireland, J. et al., “Effect of Biodiesel Blends on Diesel Particulate Filter Performance,” SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-3280, 2006, doi:10.4271/2006-01-3280.
- Williams, A., McCormick, R., Hayes, R., Ireland, J., and Fang, H., “Effect of Biodiesel Blends on Diesel Particulate Filter Performance,” SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-3280, 2006.
- Jung, H., Kittelson, D. B., and Zachariah, M. R. “Characteristics of SME Biodiesel-Fueled Diesel Particulate Emissions and the Kinetics of Oxidation,” Environmental Science and Technology 40: 4949-4955, 2006.
- Vander Wal, R., and Mueller, C. “Initial Investigation of Effects of Fuel Oxygenation on Nanostructure of Soot from a Direct-Injection Diesel Engine,” Energy & Fuels 20: 2364-2369, 2006.
- Song, J., Alam, M., and Boehman, A., “Impact of Alternative Fuels on Soot Properties and DPF Regeneration,” Combustion Science and Technology 179(9): 1991-2037, 2007.
- Strzelec, A., “Kinetic Model Development for the Combustion of Particulate Matter from Conventional and Soy Methyl Ester Diesel Fuels,” Ph.D. Thesis, Combustion Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison, 2009.
- Williams, A., Black, S., and McCormick, R., “Biodiesel Fuel Property Effects on Particulate Matter Reactivity,” presented at the 6th International Exhaust Gas and Particulate Emissions Forum, March 9-10, 2010, Ludwigsburg, Germany.
- Stamatelos, A., “A Review of the Effect of Particulate Traps on the Efficiency of Vehicle Diesel Engines,” Energy Conversion & Management 38(1): 83-99, 1997.
- Stratakis, G., “Experimental Investigation of Catalytic Soot Oxidation and Pressure Drop Characteristics in Wall-Flow Diesel Particulate Filters,” Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, University of Thessaly, 2004.
- Neeft, J., Makkee, M., and Moulijn, J., “Diesel Particulate Emission Control,” Fuel Processing Technology 47(1): 1-69, 1996.
- Song, J., “Effect of Fuel Formulation on Soot Properties and Regeneration of Diesel Particulat Filters,” Ph.D. Thesis, Fuel Science. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University, 2005.
- Seong, J., and Boehman, A., “Studies of Soot Oxidative Reactivity using a Diffusion Flame Burner,” Combustion and Flame 159: 1864-1875, 2012.
- Zhang, Y., and Boehman, A., “Oxidation Behavior of Soot Generated from the Combustion of Methyl 2-butenoate in a Co-flow Diffusion Flame,” Combustion and Flame 160: 112-119, 2013.
- Vander Wal, R.; and Tomasek, A. “Soot Oxidation: Dependence upon Initial Nanostructure,” Combustion and Flame 134: 1-9, 2003.
- Radovic, L., Walker, P., and Jenkins, R., “Importance of Carbon Active Sites in the Gasification of Coal Chars,” Fuel 62(7): 849-856, 1983.
- Vander Wal, R., and Tomasek, A. “Soot Nanostructure: Dependence upon Synthesis Conditions,” Combustion and Flame 136: 129-140, 2004.
- Yehliu, K., Vander Wal, R., Armas, O., and Boehman, A. “Impacts of Fuel Formulation on the Nanostructure and Reactivity of Diesel Soot,” Combustion and Flame 159: 3597-3606, 2012.
- Yuan, W., Hansen, A. C., and Zhang, Q., “Vapor Pressure and Normal Boiling Point Predictions for Pure Methyl Esters and Biodiesel Fuels,” Fuel 84: 943-950, 2005.
- Maricq, M., “Soot Formation in Ethanol/Gasoline Fuel Blend Diffusion Flames,” Combustion and Flame 159: 170-180, 2012.
- Maricq, M., “Physical and Chemical Comparison of Soot in Hydrocarbon and Biodiesel Fuel Diffusion Flames: A Study of Model and Commercial Fuels,” Combustion and Flame 158:105-116, 2011.
- Dobbins, R., Fletcher, R., and Chang, H., “The Evolution of Soot Precursor Particles in a Diffusion Flame,” Combustion and Flame 115: 285-298, 1998.
- Puri, R., “The Interaction of Soot Particles with Carbon Monoxide in Laminar Diffusion Flames,” Ph.D. Thesis, Mechanical Engineering, University Park: The Pennsylvania State University, 1992.
- Gupta, S., “Chemical Mechanistic Approaches to Soot Control in Laminar Diffusion Flames,” Ph.D. Thesis, Mechanical Engineering, University Park: The Pennsylvania State University, 1996.
- Yehliu, K., “Impacts of Fuel Formulation and Engine Operating Parameters on the Nanostructure and Reactivity of Diesel Soot,” Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, 2010.
- Barrientos, E., “Impact of Oxygenated Fuels on the Sooting Tendency and Soot Oxidative Reactivity with Application to Biofuels,” Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, 2014.
- Johnson, T., “Review of Diesel Emissions and Control,” International Journal of Engine Research 10(5): 275-285, 2009.
- ASTM D 1322-08. Standard Test Method for Smoke Point of Kerosine and Aviation Turbine Fuel. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, United States, 2008.
- Minchin, S. T. “Luminous Stationary Flames: The Quantitative Relationship between Flame Dimensions at the Sooting Point and Chemical Composition, with Special Reference to Petroleum Hydrocarbons,” Journal of the Institute of Petroleum Technology 17: 102-120, 1931.
- Clarke, A. E., Hunter, T. G., and Garner, F. H. “The Tendency to Smoke of Organic Substances on Burning. Part I.,” Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 32: 627-642, 1946.
- Hunt, R. A. “Relation of Smoke Point to Molecular Structure,” Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 45: 602-606, 1953.
- Schalla, R. L. and McDonald, G. E. “Variation in Smoking Tendency,” Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 45: 1497-1500, 1953.
- Van Treuren, K. W. “Sooting Characteristics of Liquid Pool Diffusion Flames,” M.S. Thesis, Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 1978.
- Schug, K. P., Manheimer-Timnat, Y., Yaccarino, P., and Glassman, I. “Sooting Behavior of Gaseous Hydrocarbon Diffusion Flames and the Influence of Additives,” Combustion Science and Technology 22: 235-250, 1980.
- Kewley, J., and Jackson, S., “The Burning of Mineral Oil in Wick Fed Lamps,” Journal of the Institute of Petroleum 13:364-397, 1927.
- Moffat, R. J. “Describing the Uncertainties in Experimental Results,” Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science 1: 3-17, 1988.
- Calcote, H. F., and Manos, D. M. “Effect of Molecular Structure on Incipient Soot Formation” Combustion and Flame 49: 289-304, 1983.
- Lemaire, R., Therssen, E., and Desgroux, P., “Effect of Ethanol Addition in Gasoline and Gasoline-Surrogate on Soot Formation in Turbulent Spray Flames,” Fuel 89: 3952-3959, 2010.
- Ladommatos, N., Rubenstein, P., and Bennett, P., “Some Effects of Molecular Structure of Single Hydrocarbons on Sooting Tendency,” Fuel 75(2): 114-124, 1996.
- Allan, K. M., Kaminski, J. R., Bertrand, J. C., Head, J., and Sunderland, P. B. “Laminar Smoke Points of Wax Candles,” Combustion Science and Technology 181(5): 800-811, 2009.
- Tran, M. K., Dunn-Rankin, D., and Pham, T. K. “Characterizing Sooting Propensity in Bio-Fuel-Diesel Flames,” Combustion and Flame 159(6): 2181-2191, 2012.
- Pepiot-Desjardins, P., Pitsch, H., Malhotra, R, Kirby, S. R., and Boehman, A. L. “Structural Group Analysis for Soot Reduction Tendency of Oxygenated Fuels,” Combustion and Flame 154(1): 191-205, 2008.
- Barrientos, E., Lapuerta, M., and Boehman, A., “Group Additivity in Soot Formation for the Example of C-5 Oxygenated Hydrocarbon Fuels,” Combustion & Flame 160:1484-1498, 2013.
- Jenkins, R., Nandi, S., and Walker, P., “Reactivity of Heat-Treated Coals in Air at 500 Degrees C,” Fuel 52(4): 288-293, 1973.
- Collura, S., Chaoui, N., Azambre, B., Finqueneisel, G., Heintz, O., Krzton, A., Koch, A., and Weber, J. V. “Influence of the Soluble Organic Fraction on the Thermal Behavior, Texture and Surface Chemistry of Diesel Exhaust Soot,” Carbon 43: 605-613, 2005.
- Knothe, G., “Designer Biodiesel: Optimizing Fatty Ester Composition to Improve Fuel Properties,” Energy & Fuels 22(2): 1358-1364, 2008.
- Santoro R. J., and Semerjian H. G. “Soot Formation in Diffusion Flames: Flow Rate, Fuel Species and Temperature Effects,” Twentieth Symposium (International) on Combustion/ The Combustion Institute: 997-1006, 1984.
- Santoro R. J., Semerjian H. G., and Dobbins R. A. “Soot Particle Measurements in Diffusion Flames,” Combustion and Flame 51:203-218, 1983.
- Santoro R. J., Yeh T., Horvath J., and Semerjian H. G. “The Transport and Growth of Soot Particles in Laminar Diffusion Flames,” Combustion Science and Technology 53(2-3): 89-115, 1987.
- Kent J. H., and Wagner H. G. “Why do Diffusion Flames Emit Smoke?,” Combustion Science and Technology 41: 245-269, 1984.
- Kent J. H., and Wagner H. G. “Temperature and Fuel Effects in Sooting Diffusion Flames,” Proceedings of the Twentieth Symposium (International) on Combustion: 1007-1015, 1984.
- Dec, J., “A Conceptual Model of DI Diesel Combustion Based on Laser-Sheet Imaging*,” SAE Technical Paper 970873, 1997, doi:10.4271/970873.
- Chen, H., and Dobbins, R., “Crystallogenesis of Particles Formed in Hydrocarbon Combustion,” Combustion Science and Technology 159:109-128, 2000.
- Al-Qurashi, K., Lueking, A. D., and Boehman, A. L. “The Deconvolution of the Thermal, Dilution, and Chemical Effects of Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) on the Reactivity of Engine and Flame Soot,” Combustion and Flame 158(9): 1696-1704, 2011.
- Al-Qurashi, K., Zhang Y., and Boehman, A. L. “Impact of Intake CO2 Addition and Exhaust Gas Recirculation on NOx Emissions and Soot Reactivity in a Common Rail Diesel Engine,” Energy & Fuels 26(10): 6098-6105, 2012.
- Allansson, R., Blakeman, P., Cooper, B., Hess, H. et al., “Optimising the Low Temperature Performance and Regeneration Efficiency of the Continuously Regenerating Diesel Particulate Filter (CR-DPF) System,” SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0428, 2002, doi:10.4271/2002-01-0428.
- Hurt, R., Crawford, G., and Shim, H., “Equilibrium Nanostructure of Primary Soot Particles,” Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 28: 2539-2546, 2000.
- Hanfland, M., Beister A., and Syassen, K. “Graphite under Pressure-Equation of State and 1st-Order Raman Modes,” Physical Review B 39: 12598-12603, 1989.
- Nikiel, L., and Jagodzinski, P., “Raman Spectroscopic Characterization of Graphites - A Revaluation of Spectra/Structure Correlation,” Carbon 31: 1313-1317, 1993.
- Menargh, T., Cooney, R., and Johnson, R., “Raman-Spectra of Graphon Carbon-Black,” Carbon 22: 39-42, 1984.
- Zerda, T., John, A., and Chmura, K., “Raman Studies of Coals,” Fuel 60: 375-378, 1981.
- Fang, H. and Lance, M., “Influence of Soot Surface Changes on DPF Regeneration,” SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-3043, 2004, doi:10.4271/2004-01-3043.
- Sadezky, A., Muckenhuber, H., Grothe, H., Niesser, R., and Poschl, U., “Raman Microscopy of Soot and Related Carbonaceous Materials: Spectral Analysis and Structural Information,” Carbon 43: 1731-1742, 2005.