This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Integration of Multiple Active Safety Systems using STPA
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 14, 2015 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Automobiles are becoming ever more complex as advanced safety features are integrated into the vehicle platform. As the pace of integration and complexity of new features rises, it is becoming increasingly difficult for system engineers to assess the impact of new additions on vehicle safety and performance. In response to this challenge, a new approach for analyzing multiple control systems as an extension to the Systems Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) framework has been developed. The new approach meets the growing need of system engineers to analyze integrated control systems, that may or may not have been developed in a coordinated manner, and assess them for safety and performance.
The new approach identifies unsafe combinations of control actions, from one or more control systems, that could lead to an accident. For example, independent controllers for Auto Hold, Engine Idle Stop, and Adaptive Cruise Control may interfere with each other in certain situations. This paper demonstrates a method to efficiently identify potential unsafe scenarios without requiring a complete enumeration or individual analysis of all possible scenarios. As a result, the approach is scalable to large systems with many controllers. In this paper, the method is demonstrated through a case study involving several driver assistance systems including advanced brake controls, advanced engine control, and advanced adaptive cruise control. Potential conflicts that would prohibit safe and successful operation are also efficiently identified, allowing engineers to develop suitable controls that prevent these conflicts.
|Technical Paper||Advanced Collision Avoidance Demonstration for Heavy-Duty Vehicles|
|Technical Paper||Developing Safe Software Solutions for X-By-Wire Applications|
|Technical Paper||Direct Yaw-Moment Control Based on Lane Marker Detection|
CitationPlacke, S., Thomas, J., and Suo, D., "Integration of Multiple Active Safety Systems using STPA," SAE Technical Paper 2015-01-0277, 2015, https://doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-0277.
- Alladi , V. , Wei , J. , and Ganesan , S. Writing Better Real-Time System Requirements with Use Cases and Services SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-1315 2005 10.4271/2005-01-1315
- Leveson N. Applying Systems Thinking to Analyze and Learn from Events Safety Science 49 1 55 64 2010
- Leveson N. A New Accident Model for Engineering Safer Systems Safety Science 42 4 237 270 2004
- Tsui , F. , Karam , O. , Bernal , B. Essentials of Software Engineering Jones & Bartlett Learning LLC 2014
- Hayes , I. J. VDM and Z: a comparative case study Formal Aspects of Computing 4 1 76 99 1992
- Zave P. A practical comparison of Alloy and Spin Formal Aspects of Computing 2014 Springer http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00165-014-0302-2
- Leavens Gary T. and Baker Albert L. Enhancing the pre-and postcondition technique for more expressive specifications FM'99 - Formal Methods Springer Berlin Heidelber 1999 1087 1106
- Frola , F. R. , Miller , C. O. System safety in aircraft acquisition. Logistics Management Institute Bethesda, MD 1984
- Leveson , N. Engineering a Safer World MIT Press 2012
- Balgos V. H. A systems theoretic application to design for the safety of medical diagnostic devices Master's thesis MIT Cambridge 2012
- Torok , R. , Geddes , B. Systems Theoretic Process Analysis(STPA) Applied to a Nuclear Power Plant Control System MIT STAMP Workshop March 2013
- Leveson , N. , Wilkinson , C. , Fleming , C. , Thomas , J. , Tracy , I. A Comparison of STPA and the ARP 4761 Safety Assessment Process MIT PSAS Technical Report 2014
- Placke , S. Application of STPA to the Integration of Multiple Control Systems: A Case Study and New Approach Master's thesis Engineering Systems Division, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 2014
- Ishimatsu , T. , Leveson , N. , Fleming , C. , Katahira , M. , Miyamoto , Y. , and Nakao , H. Multiple Controller Contributions to Hazards 5th IAASS Conference Versailles, France October 2011
- Ishimatsu T. , Leveson N. , Thomas J. , Fleming C. , Katahira M. , Miyamoto Y. , Ujiie R. , Nakao H. and Hoshino N. Hazard Analysis of Complex Spacecraft using Systems-Theoretic Process Analysis Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets 51 2 509 522 2014
- Thomas J. Extending and Automating a Systems-Theoretic Hazard Analysis for Requirements Generation and Analysis Ph.D. Dissertation Engineering Systems Division, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 2013
- Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Transmission Shift Position Sequence, Starter Interlock, and Transmission Braking Effect 49 CFR Part 571 2005
- Thomas , J. and Suo , D. An STPA Tool 3 rd STAMP/STPA Conference. MIT Cambridge, MA 2014