This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Natural Gas and Biogas Use in Transit Bus Fleets - A Technical, Operational and Environmental Approach
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 30, 2014 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
From the nineties there was a great interest in the use of compressed natural gas - CNG (predominantly composed of methane) on transit bus fleets around the globe. In a first moment, developed countries (US, EU and Japan) have focused their efforts to address serious urban air pollution problems caused by heavy duty diesel engines - since PM and NOx emissions were initially easier to control from natural gas engines than from conventional diesel engines - and also to offset growing oil imports. As such, for many years, dedicated methane fuelled city buses meeting emission requirements (Euro IV, V and EEV, US Federal and California, and Japan) either in a lean burn or stoichiometric technology, have been offered to the market. At the same time, stringent emission standards developed for new engines has stimulated industry in developed world to develop new diesel engine, aftertreatment and fuel (with low sulphur content) technologies, which has made modern electronic diesel competitive with CNG engines from an emission perspective. This, in some way, has waned the initial impetus for widespread adoption of CNG in transit markets. CNG transit strategy was also adopted by some developing countries, like India, due the impossibility to reach emissions limits already established (Euro III) with engines operated with diesel fuel with high sulphur content. Currently, with the advent of even stricter emissions targets - notably US 2010 and Euro VI limits - and the technical barriers to comply with their extremely low NOx limits with a diesel engine/aftertreatment approach - natural & biogas engines have been seen as a promising tool to reduce toxic emissions and mitigate CO2 emissions, specially when methane origins from biomass (sewage or landfill gas). Moreover, the current high availability and low cost of natural gas in US and some European countries as well as the perspective of near future increase of natural gas offer in developing countries, like Brazil, have fostered the interest of government and industry into methane powered heavy duty engines for transit service. This work is supposed to present an overview of technological approaches for Natural & Biogas (methane) heavy duty engines, their operational features and environmental performance, as well as a snapshot of current natural and biogas transit bus programs explored in some world cities.
CitationBarbosa, F., "Natural Gas and Biogas Use in Transit Bus Fleets - A Technical, Operational and Environmental Approach," SAE Technical Paper 2014-36-0194, 2014, https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-36-0194.
- Nylund, N. O. et al - “Transit Bus Emission Study: Comparison of Emission from Diesel and Natural Gas Buses”. VTT Research Report. Finland, 2004;
- Persson, M. and Wellinger A. - “Biogas Upgrading and Utilisation”. IEA Bioenergy, 2006;
- Nerheim, L. M., et al - “Technical Requirements for a Biogas Fueled Bus Design”. Baltic Biogas Bus, WP 6.7. Bergen, 2012;
- Ghazali, N. et al - “Biogas Bus Use and Operational Experiences”. Baltic Biogas Bus Project. Royal Institute of Technology. Stockholm, 2011;
- Broman, R. et al - “Enhanced Emission Performance and Fuel Efficiency for HD Methane Engines”. Literature Study. Final Report. A Report for International Agency - Advanced Fuel Motors. Haninge, Sweden, 2010;
- Kaiadi, M., 2011 - “Diluted Operation of a Heavy-duty Natural Gas Engine Aiming at Improved Efficiency, Emissions and Maximum Load”. Doctoral Thesis. Faculty of Engineering, Lund University, Lund, Sweden, 2011;”
- Saanumm I., Bysveen, M., Tunestål, P., and Johansson, B., “Lean Burn Versus Stoichiometric Operation with EGR and 3-Way Catalyst of an Engine Fueled with Natural Gas and Hydrogen Enriched Natural Gas,” SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0015, 2007, doi:10.4271/2007-01-0015.
- Packham, K. - “Lean-burn engine technology increases efficiency, reduces NOx emissions”. Cummns White Paper Number 7009. 2007;
- Posada, F. - “CNG Bus Emissions Roadmap: from Euro III to Euro VI”. International Council on Clean Transportation - ICCT, 2009;
- Kojima, M. - “Breathing Clean - Considering the Switch to Natural Gas Buses”. World Bank Report n°. 516. Washington DC;
- MAN - MAN CNG Buses Presentation. MAN Nutzfahrzeuge AG. May, 2009;
- NGVA Europe - “Natural Gas and C02 Natural Gas is a Champion in Road Transport and also Saving CO2 emissions”. Position Paper. Madrid, Spain, 2009;
- Adams, R. and Home, D.B - “Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) Transit Bus Experience Survey”. National Renewable Energy Laboratory. Subcontract Report NREL/SR-7A2-48814. US, 2010;
- Fevre, C.CL - “The Prospects for Natural Gas in Europe”. The Oxford nstitute for Energy Studies. OEIS Paper: NG 84. Oxford University. Oxford, 2014;
- TCRP - “Guidebook for Evaluating Fuel Choices for Post- 2010 Transit Bus Procurements”. Transportation Reserach Board Report n°. 146. Sponsored by Federal Transit Administration. Washington D.C.. United States, 2011;
- Riesel, D. - “Investigate Standards of High Pressure Vessels for Biogas in Buses”. Final Report WP 6.3. Baltic Biogas Bus Project. Hydrogen and Informatics Institute of Applied Technologies, 2011;
- Staimer, R. - “Clean Air Bus Transport. Future Proof and Sustainable Technology”. MAN Presentation. January, 2013;
- AFDC - “Compressed Natural Gas Fueling Stations”. Available at:http://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/natural_gas_cng_stations.html. Accessed on 04 30 2014;
- CLEAN FLEETS - Clean Buses - “Experiences with Fuel and Technology Options”. Clean Fleet Project, 2014;
- APTA - “Transit on the Cutting Edge of Clean Technology”. American Public Association Transportation. Policy Development and Research Report, 2012;
- ANGA - “Cleaner Transportation, Powered with Natural Gas”. Available at: http://anga.us/blog/2013/5/16/cleanertransportation-powered-with-natural-gas. Accessed on 04 28 2014;
- Barbosa, F.C. Photos from the Author, 2014;
- Chandler, K. et al - “Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority: Compressed Natural Gas Transit Bus Evaluation”. Technical Report. NREL/TP-540-37626, 2006;
- Kyto, M., et al - “Gas Bus Technology and Operational Experiences in Helsinki Area”. Baltic Biogas Bus Project. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2012;
- Rare Consulting PTY - “Bus technologies in Australia to 2020 and Beyond. A discussion of the Opportunity for new Technology Adoption for the Australian Bus Industry”. Sydney, 2010;
- Fact Sheet Series. Centre for Science and Environment, 2010;
- Oliveira Filho A.D. - “Substituição de Diesel por Gás Natural em Ônibus do Transporte Público Urbano”. Dissertação de Mestrado. Programa Interunidades de Pós-Graduação em Energia. Universidade de São Paulo, 2006;
- Agência Nacional de Petróleo, Gás Natural e Biocombustíveis. “Principais Gasodutos Instalados na América do Sul”. 2010.
- Lowell, D. - “Clean Diesel versus CNG Buses: Cost, Air Quality, & Climate Impacts”. MJB & A, Washington DC, 2012;
- FCH JU - “Urban buses: alternative powertrains for Europe. A fact-based analysis of the role of diesel hybrid, hydrogen fuel cell, trolley and battery electric powertrains”. Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking - FCH JU, 2012.