This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Experience and Skill Predict Failure to Brake Errors: Further Validation of the Simulated Driving Assessment
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 01, 2014 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Driving simulators offer a safe alternative to on-road driving for the evaluation of performance. In addition, simulated drives allow for controlled manipulations of traffic situations producing a more consistent and objective assessment experience and outcome measure of crash risk. Yet, few simulator protocols have been validated for their ability to assess driving performance under conditions that result in actual collisions. This paper presents results from a new Simulated Driving Assessment (SDA), a 35- to-40-minute simulated assessment delivered on a Real-Time® simulator. The SDA was developed to represent typical scenarios in which teens crash, based on analyses from the National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey (NMVCCS). A new metric, failure to brake, was calculated for the 7 potential rear-end scenarios included in the SDA and examined according two constructs: experience and skill. The study included an inexperienced group (n=21): 16-17 year olds with 90 days or fewer of provisional licensure, and an experienced group (n=17): 25-50 year olds with at least 5 years of PA licensure, at least 100 miles driven per week and no self-reported collisions in the previous 3 years. Skill was rated by a driving evaluator based on video review of SDA performance. When compared to experienced drivers rated as “skilled,” inexperienced drivers rated also as “less skilled” had significantly more failure to brake errors. In addition, experience and skill independently predicted failure to brake errors. These results provide support for the construct validity of the SDA and suggest its potential role as part of new driver assessment tool.
CitationWinston, F., McDonald, C., Kandadai, V., Winston, Z. et al., "Experience and Skill Predict Failure to Brake Errors: Further Validation of the Simulated Driving Assessment," SAE Technical Paper 2014-01-0445, 2014, https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-01-0445.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Teen Driver Fact Sheet,” http://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/teen_drivers/index.html, October 13, 2013.
- Bingham, C.R. and Ehsani, J.P., “The Relative Odds of Involvement in Seven Crash Configurations by Driver Age and Sex,” Journal of Adolescent Health 51(5): 484-490, 2012.
- Foss, R.D., Martell, C.A., Goodwin, A.H., O'Brien, N.P., et al., “Measuring Changes in Teenage Driver Crash Characterisitics During the Early Months of Driving,” https://www.aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/2011MeasuringCharacteristicsOfTeenCrashes_0.pdf, July 21, 2013.
- Simons-Morton, B.G., Lerner, N.D., and Singer, J., “The Observed Effects of Teenage Passengers on the Risky Driving Behavior of Teenage Drivers,” Accident, Analysis, & Prevention 37(6): 973-982, 2005.
- Lenne, M.G., Liu, C.C., Salmon, P.M., Holden, M., et al., “Minimising Risks and Distractions for Young Drivers and Their Passengers: An Evaluation of a Novel Driver-Passenger Training Program,” Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour 14(6): 447-455, 2011.
- Lee, S.E., Simons-Morton, B.G., Klauer, S.E., Ouimet, M.C., et al., “Naturalistic Assessment of Novice Teenage Crash Experience,” Accident Analysis & Prevention 43(4): 1472-1479, 2011.
- Simons-Morton, B.G., Ouimet, M.C., Zhang, Z., Klauer, S.E., et al., “The Effect of Passengers and Risk-Taking Friends on Risky Driving and Crashes/Near Crashes Among Novice Teenagers,” Journal of Adolescent Health 49(6): 587-593, 2011.
- Simons-Morton, B.G., Zhang, Z., Jackson, J.C., and Albert, P.S., “Do Elevated Gravitational-Force Events While Driving Predict Crashes and Near Crashes?,” American Journal of Epidemiology 175(10): 1075-1079, 2012.
- Simons-Morton, B.G., Ouimet, M.C., Wang, J., Klauer, S.E., et al., “Hard Braking Events Among Novice Teenage Drivers By Passenger Characteristics,” Proceedings of the Fifth International Driving Symposium on Human Factors in Driver Assessment, Training and Vehicle Design: 236-242, 2009.
- Romoser, M., Deschamps, M., Wilson, H., and Fisher, D., “Investigating Differences Between Experienced Adult Drivers and Teen Drivers with Low-Cost Vehicle Data Recorder,” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2321(-1): 79-87, 2012.
- Endsley, M.R., “Toward a Theory of Situation Awareness in Dynamic Systems,” Human Factors 37(1): 32-64, 1995.
- Mirman, J., Lee, Y.-C., Kay, J., Durbin, D., et al., “Development of Web-Based Parent Support Program to Improve Quantity, Quality, and Diversity of Teens' Home-Based Practice Driving,” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2318(-1): 107-115, 2012.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, “National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey: Report to Congress,” http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/811059.PDF, July 21, 2013.
- McDonald, C., C., Tanenbaum, J.B., Lee, Y.-C., Fisher, D.L., et al., “Using Crash Data to Develop Simulator Scenarios for Assessing Young Novice Driver Performance” Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2321: 73-78, 2012.
- McDonald, C.C., Seacrist, T., Lee, Y.C., Loeb, H., et al., “Headway Time and Crashes Among Novice Teens and Experienced Adult Drivers in a Simulated Lead Truck Braking Scenario,” 7th International Driving Symposium on Human Factors in Driving Assessment, Training, and Vehicle Design. 2013. 439-445.
- Winston, F.K., McDonald, C.C., Kandadai, V., Loeb, H., et al., “Headway Time Errors, Safe Driving Skill, and Experience: An Initial Validation of the Simulated Driving Assessment,” Transportation Research Board. 2014. Paper 14-4867.
- New South Wales Government, A Guide to the Driving Test, Transport Road and Maritime Services, Editor 2010.
- Fisher, D.L., Rizzo, M., Caird, J., and Lee, J.D., “Handbook of Driving Simulation for Engineering, Medicine, and Psychology”, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group: Boca Raton, FL, 2011.
- Carney, C., McGehee, D.V., Lee, J.D., Reyes, M.L., et al., “Using an Event-Triggered Video Intervention System to Expand the Supervised Learning of Newly Licensed Adolescent Drivers,” American Journal of Public Health 100(6): 1101-1106, 2010.
- McGehee, D.V., Raby, M., Carney, C., Lee, J.D., et al., “Extending Parental Mentoring Using an Event-Triggered Video Intervention in Rural Teen Drivers,” Journal of Safety Research 38(2): 215-227, 2007.
- Toledo, T., Musicant, O., and Lotan, T., “In-vehicle Data Recorders for Monitoring and Feedback on Drivers' Behavior,” Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies 16(3): 320-331, 2008.
- Fisher, D.L., Pollatsek, A.P., and Pradhan, A., “Can Novice Drivers be Trained to Scan for Information That will Reduce Their Likelihood of a Crash?,” Injury Prevention 12(suppl 1): i25-i29, 2006.
- Horswill, M.S. and McKenna, F.P., “Drivers' Hazard Perception Ability: Situation Awareness on the Road,” in A Cognitive Approach to Situation Awareness: Theory and Application, Banbury S. and Tremblay S., Editors., Ashgate Publishing, Ltd.: United Kingdom, 2004.