This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Vehicle-Based Driver Interlocks: After 50 Years of Research, can we now Design an On-Board, Real-Time System to Detect Abnormal Driving Behavior?
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 01, 2014 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
In its simplest form, an interlock is a device, installed in a vehicle, that monitors the safety of the vehicle and its occupants, decides whether the vehicle or its occupants are in danger and warns the occupants, or influences the operation of the vehicle. The first interlocks were designed to detect alcohol intoxicated drivers. Three categories of performance interlocks can be identified:
- Type I interlocks sense physiological parameters of the driver (e.g. alcohol content of alveolar air) determine the driver's level of intoxication and, after comparing this level with a criterion level (e.g. the legal limit for driving), decide whether or not the vehicle should be operated.
- Type II interlocks measure the behaviour of the driver with cockpit-mounted equipment (e.g. eye movement monitors) or on driving-related tasks and compare this behaviour with established norms.
- Types III interlocks measure driving performance directly and compare the measured values with performance norms.
The purpose of this paper is to review the research, conducted on driver performance interlocks over the past 50 years, specifically on Type III devices. In addition, the review looks at recent advances in intelligent vehicle technologies that could lead to the development of a Type III device. Finally, a way forward is proposed for the development of an on-board system to detect and respond to abnormal driving behavior.
CitationAttwood, D., "Vehicle-Based Driver Interlocks: After 50 Years of Research, can we now Design an On-Board, Real-Time System to Detect Abnormal Driving Behavior?," SAE Technical Paper 2014-01-0275, 2014, https://doi.org/10.4271/2014-01-0275.
- Attwood , D.A. The potential of Using Driving Performance Measures in an Alcohol Interlock Transport Canada, Road Safety Unit, Tech. Memo 75/4 1975
- Ogden , E.J.D. and Moskowitz , H. Effects of alcohol and other drugs on driver performance Traffic Injury Prevention 2004 5 185 198
- Barr , L. , Popkin , S. , and Howarth , H. An evaluation of emerging driver fatigue detection measures and technologies: Final Report Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, FMCSA-RRR-09-005 2009
- Chittaro , L. , and DeMarco , L. Driver distraction caused by mobile devices: Studying and reducing safety risks 1 st International Workshop on Mobile Technologies 2004
- TIME Magazine Modern Living: Pushbuttons v, Drunks June 01 1970
- Sussman , D. , and Abernathy , C.N. Laboratory evaluation of Alcohol Safety Interlock Systems. Volume 1 - Summary Report U.S. Department of Transportation Report No. DOT HS 800 925 1973
- Tennant , J. and Thompson , R. A Critical Tracking Task as an Alcohol Interlock System SAE Technical Paper 730095 1973 10.4271/730095
- Pollard , J.K. , Nadler , E.D. , and Stearns , M.D. Review of technology to prevent alcohol-impaired crashes (TOPIC) NHTSA 2007
- TIRF Alcohol Interlocks: Taking Research to Practice Proceedings of the 10 th International Alcohol Interlock Symposium Melbourne Australia October 2009
- Greenshields , B.D. Driving behavior and related problems Highway Research Record No. 25 1963 14 32
- Greenshields , B.D. , and Platt , F.N. Development of a method of predicting high-accident and high-violation drivers J. Appl. Psych. 1967 51 3 205 210
- Platt , F.N. Heart rate measurements of drivers with the Highway Systems Research Car Industrial Medicine 1969 38 10 59 68
- Eatock , B.C. , Demmery , W.W. , Williams , R.D. , and Attwood , D.A. Portable interactive data acquisition and analysis system for driver behaviour research Transportation Research Record No. 672 1978 44 49
- Attwood , D.A. The effects of driving experience on objective measures of driving performance Proceedings, 23rd Annual Meeting of the Human Factors Society Boston October 1979
- Williams , R.D. , Attwood , D.A. , and Frecker , R.D. Effects of moderate levels of diazepam and alcohol on two-lane passing performance Proceedings 12th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors Association of Canada Bracebridge, Ontario September 1979
- Attwood , D.A. , Williams , R.D. , McBurney , LINDA J. , and Frecker , R.C. Cannabis, Alcohol and Driving: Effects on Selected Closed-Course Tasks Proceedings, 8th International Conference on Alcohol, Drugs and Traffic Safety Stockholm, Sweden 16 19 June 1980b
- Attwood , D.A. and Scott , P.L. The on-line use of performance measures to predict driving fatigue Proceedings, 1981 Annual Meeting Human Factors Society Rochester October 1981
- Attwood , D.A. , Williams , R.D. , and Madill , H.D. The effects of Moderate concentrations of blood Alcohol on closed-course driving performance J. Studies on Alc. 1980c 41 1 623 634
- Bishop , H. , Madnick , B. , Walter , R. , and Sussman , E.D. Potential for driver attention monitoring system development NHTSA 1985
- Hagen , R.E. Sex differences in driving performance Human Factors 1975 17 2 165 177
- Wilson , F. , and Greensmith , J. Multivariate analysis of the relationship between driveometer variable and drivers accident, sex, and exposure status Human Factors 1983 25 303 312
- Brookhuis , K. , De Waard , D. , and Fairclough , S. 2003 Criteria for Driver impairment Ergonomics 2003 46 5 433 445
- Volkerts , E.R. and O'Hanlon , J.F. Hypnotics' residual effects on driving performance 123 135 O'Hanlon J.F. and de Gier J.J. Drugs and Driving Taylor and Francis London 1986
- De Waard , D. , Brookhuis , K.A. Assessing driver status: a demonstration experiment on the road Accid. Anal and Prev. 23 4 297 307 1991
- Brookhuis , K. How to measure driving ability under the influence of alcohol and drugs and why? Human Psychopharmacology and Clinical Experimentation 13 S64 S69 1998
- Brookhuis , K.A. , DeWaard , D. , and Bekiaris , E. Development of a system for detection of driver impairment Alcohol, Drugs and Safety, T'97 Mercier-Guyon 581 586 1997
- Bekiaris , E. SAVE (System for effective Assessment of the driver state and Vehicle control in Emergency situations) TRANSPORT TELEMATICS PROJECT N°.: TR 1047 Final Report 1999
- Wierwille , W. , Wreggit , S. , Kirn , C. , Ellsworth , L. , and Fairbanks , R. Research on vehicle-based driver status/performance monitoring: Development, validation and refinement of algorithms for detection of driver drowsiness. Final Report NHTSA 1994
- Lee , J.D. , Fiorentina , D. , Reyes , M. , Brown , T.L. , Ahmad , O. , Fell J. , Ward , N. and Dufour , R. Assessing the feasibility of vehicle based sensors to detect alcohol impairment NHTSA 2010
- Devereux , R. , McGovern , J. , McCleaf , T. , and Pickeral , D. Systems Architecture of a Reconfigurable Field Research Vehicle for Human Factors Experiments SAE Technical Paper 951959 1995 10.4271/951959
- Carter , R.J. , Barickman , F.S. , Spelt , P.F. , Schmoyer , R.L. and Kirkpatrick , J.R. Feasibility of developing a portable driver performance data acquisition system for human factors research. Technical tasks Oak Ridge National Laboratory Report ORNL/TM-13540, Vol 1. Developed under contract from the US/DOT NHTSA
- Barickman , F. , and Goodman , M.J. 1999 MicroDAS: In vehicle portable data acquisition system Trans. Research Record, 1689, paper No. 99-0611 1 8
- Levick , N.R. , and Swanson , J. 2005 An optimal solution for enhancing ambulance safety: implementing a driver performance feedback and monitoring device in ground emergency medical service vehicles Annual Proceedings the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 2005 49 35 50
- European Parliament (minutes) Rear end traffic collisions in the European Union Parliamentary Question 7 December 2011
- Detroit News July 2 2009
- Haddon , W. Advances in the epidemiology of injuries as a basis for public policy Public Health Report 1980 95 411 421
- McCall , J. , and Trivedi , M. Driver behavior and situation aware brake assistance for intelligent vehicles Proc. IEEE 95 2 2007
- Brovold , S. , Ward , N. , Donath , M. , Simon , S. , Shakwitz , C. , and Creaser , J. The use of technology to address patterns of risk among teenage drivers J. Safety Research 38 2007 413 422
- McCall , J. , Achler , O. , and Trivedi , M. Design of an instrumented vehicle test bed for developing a human centered driver support system Proceedings, IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium Parma, Italy June 2004
- Farmer , C. , Kirley , B. , and McCartt , A. Effects of in-vehicle monitoring on the driving behaviour of teenagers J. Safety Res. 41 2010 39 45