This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Development of Brain Injury Criteria (BrIC)
Published November 11, 2013 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
Rotational motion of the head as a mechanism for brain injury was proposed back in the 1940s. Since then a multitude of research studies by various institutions were conducted to confirm/reject this hypothesis. Most of the studies were conducted on animals and concluded that rotational kinematics experienced by the animal's head may cause axonal deformations large enough to induce their functional deficit. Other studies utilized physical and mathematical models of human and animal heads to derive brain injury criteria based on deformation/pressure histories computed from their models. This study differs from the previous research in the following ways: first, it uses two different detailed mathematical models of human head (SIMon and GHBMC), each validated against various human brain response datasets; then establishes physical (strain and stress based) injury criteria for various types of brain injury based on scaled animal injury data; and finally, uses Anthropomorphic Test Devices (ATDs) (Hybrid III 50th Male, Hybrid III 5th Female, THOR 50th Male, ES-2re, SID-IIs, WorldSID 50th Male, and WorldSID 5th Female) test data (NCAP, pendulum, and frontal offset tests) to establish a kinematically based brain injury criterion (BrIC) for all ATDs. Similar procedures were applied to college football data where thousands of head impacts were recorded using a six degrees of freedom (6 DOF) instrumented helmet system. Since animal injury data used in derivation of BrIC were predominantly for diffuse axonal injury (DAI) type, which is currently an AIS 4+ injury, cumulative strain damage measure (CSDM) and maximum principal strain (MPS) were used to derive risk curves for AIS 4+ anatomic brain injuries. The AIS 1+, 2+, 3+, and 5+ risk curves for CSDM and MPS were then computed using the ratios between corresponding risk curves for head injury criterion (HIC) at a 50% risk. The risk curves for BrIC were then obtained from CSDM and MPS risk curves using the linear relationship between CSDM - BrIC and MPS - BrIC respectively. AIS 3+, 4+ and 5+ field risk of anatomic brain injuries was also estimated using the National Automotive Sampling System - Crashworthiness Data System (NASS-CDS) database for crash conditions similar to the frontal NCAP and side impact conditions that the ATDs were tested in. This was done to assess the risk curve ratios derived from HIC risk curves. The results of the study indicated that: (1) the two available human head models - SIMon and GHBMC - were found to be highly correlated when CSDMs and max principal strains were compared; (2) BrIC correlates best to both - CSDM and MPS, and rotational velocity (not rotational acceleration) is the mechanism for brain injuries; and (3) the critical values for angular velocity are directionally dependent, and are independent of the ATD used for measuring them. The newly developed brain injury criterion is a complement to the existing HIC, which is based on translational accelerations. Together, the two criteria may be able to capture most brain injuries and skull fractures occurring in automotive or any other impact environment. One of the main limitations for any brain injury criterion, including BrIC, is the lack of human injury data to validate the criteria against, although some approximation for AIS 2+ injury is given based on the angular velocities calculated at 50% probability of concussion in college football players instrumented with 5 DOF helmet system. Despite the limitations, a new kinematic rotational brain injury criterion - BrIC - may offer a way to capture brain injuries in situations when using translational accelerations based HIC alone may not be sufficient.
- Erik G. Takhounts - National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Matthew J. Craig - National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Kevin Moorhouse - National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Joe McFadden - National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Vikas Hasija - Bowhead Systems Management, Inc.
CitationTakhounts, E., Craig, M., Moorhouse, K., McFadden, J. et al., "Development of Brain Injury Criteria (BrIC)," SAE Technical Paper 2013-22-0010, 2013, https://doi.org/10.4271/2013-22-0010.
- Allsop, D.L., Warner C.Y., Wille M.G., Scheider D.C., and Nahum A.M. (1988) Facial impact response - A comparison of the Hybrid III dummy and human cadaver. In Proc. 32nd Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE Paper No. 881719.
- Abbreviated Injury Scale 1990 Edition (1998 Update) Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Des Plaines, IL.
- Abbreviated Injury Scale 2005 (2008 Updated) Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Des Plaines, IL.
- Abel, J., Gennarelli, T.A., Seagawa, H. (1978) In cadence and severity of cerebral concussion in the rhesus monkey following sagittal plane angular acceleration. Proc. 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conference, pp. 33-53, Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, PA.
- Bandak, F.A., and Eppinger, R.H. (1995) A three-dimensional finite element analysis of the human brain under combined rotational and translational acceleration. Proc. 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference, pp. 145-163. Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, PA.
- Broglio, S.P., Schnebel, B., Sosnoff, J.J., Shin, S., Fend, X., He, X., and Zimmerman, J. (2010) Biomechanical properties of concussions in high school football. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 42(11): 2064-71.
- CDC, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (2003) Traumatic Brain Injury Facts, http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/factsheets/tbi.htm.
- Chu, J. J., Beckwith, J. G., Crisco, J. J., and Greenwald, R. (2006) A Novel Algorithm to Measure Linear and Rotational Head Acceleration Using Single-Axis Accelerometers. in World Congress of Biomechanics, Munich, Germany.
- Duma, S.M., Manoogian, S.J., Bussone, W.R., Brolinson, P.G., Goforth, M.W., Donnenwerth, J.J., Greenwald, R.M., Chu, J.J., and Crisco, J.J. (2005) Analysis of real-time head accelerations in collegiate football players. Clin J Sport Med, 15(1): 3-8.
- Duma, S.M. and Rowson, S. (2009) Every newton hertz: A macro to micro approach to investigating brain injury. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 1: 1123-6.
- Eigen, A. M. and Martin, P. G. (2005) Identification of real world injury patterns in aid of dummy development. 19th Enhanced Safety of Vehicles.
- Eisenhauer, J.G. (2003) Regression through the Origin, Teaching Statistics, 25(3): 76-80.
- Frieden, T.R., Ikeda, R., Hunt, R.C., Faul, M., Xu, L., Wald, M.M., Coronado, V. (2010) Traumatic Brain Injury in The United States: Emergency Department Visits, Hospitalizations and Deaths 2002 - 2006. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Desease Control and Prevention, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
- Gayzik FS, Hamilton CA, Tan JC, et al. (2009) A Multi-Modality Image Data Collection Protocol for Full Body Finite Element Analysis Model Development. SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-2261.
- Gayzik FS, Moreno DP, Danelson KA, McNally C, Klinich KD, Stitzel JD. (2012) External Landmark, Body Surface, and Volume Data of a Mid-Sized Male in Seated and Standing Postures. Annals of Biomedical Engineering, 40(9):2019-2032.
- Gennarelli, T.A., Thibault, L.E., and Ommaya, A.K. (1972) Pathophysiologic Responses to Rotational and Translational Accelerations of the Head. Stapp Car Crash Journal 16: 296-308.
- Gennarelli, T.A., Thibault, L.E., Adams, J.H., Graham, D.I., Thompson, C.J., and Marcincin, R.P. (1982) Diffuse axonal injury and traumatic coma in the primate. Annals of Neurology 12(6): 564-574.
- Gordon, C., et al. (1989) 1988 Anthropometric Survey of U.S. Army Personnel: Methods and Summary Statistics, D.a.E.C. Prepared for United States Army Natick Research, Editor.
- Guskiewicz, K.M., Mihalik, J.P., Shankar, V., Marshall, S.W., Crowell, D.H., Oliaro, S.M., Ciocca, M.F., and Hooker, D.N. (2007) Measurement of head impacts in collegiate football players: relationship between head impact biomechanics and acute clinical outcome after concussion. Neurosurgery, 61(6): 1244-53
- Hardy, W.N., Foster, C., Mason, M., Yang, K., King, A., Tashman, S. (2001) Investigation of head injury mechanisms using neutral density technology and high-speed biplanar X-ray. Stapp Car Crash Journal 45: 337-368.
- Hardy, W.N., Mason, M.J., Foster, C.D., Shah, C.S., Kopacz, J.M., Yang, K.H., King, A.L., Bishop, J., Bey, M., Anderst, W., Tashman, S. (2007) A Study of the Response of the Human Cadaver Head to Impact. Stapp Car Crash Journal, Vol. 51, pp. 17-80.
- Hodgson, V.R., Brinn J., Thomas L.M., and Greenberg S.W.. (1970). Fracture behavior of the skull frontal bone against cylindrical surfaces. In 14th Stapp Car Crash Conference.
- Holbourn, A.H.S. (1943) Mechanics of head injury. Lancet 2, October 9: 438-441.
- Hertz, E. (1993) A note on the head injury criterion (HIC) as a predictor of the risk of skull fracture. Proceedings of the 37th Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine: 303-10.
- Manoogian, S., McNeely, D., Duma, S., Brolinson, G., and Greenwald, R. (2006) Head acceleration is less than 10 percent of helmet acceleration in football impacts. Biomed Sci Instrum, vol. 42: 383-388.
- Mao H, Zhang L, Jiang B, et al. (2013) Development of a Finite Element Human Head Model Validated With Forty Nine Loading Cases From Experimental and Real World Impacts. J Biomech Eng.: 10.1115/1.4025101.
- Meaney, D.F, Smith, D., Ross, D.T., and Gennarelli, T.A. (1993) Diffuse axonal injury in the miniature pig: Biomechanical development and injury threshold. ASME Crashworthiness and occupant protection in transportation systems 25: 169-175.
- Nahum, A.M., Smith R., and Ward C.C.. (1977). Intracranial pressure dynamics during head impact. In Proc. 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE Paper No. 770922.
- NHTSA (1995) Final economic assessment, FMVSS No. 201, upper interior head protection. www.regulations.gov, NHTSA docket 1996-1762-0003.
- Nusholtz, G.S., Lux, P., Kaiker, P., and Janicki, M.A., (1984) Head impact response skull deformation and angular accelerations. Proc. 28th Stapp Car Crash Conference, pp. 41-74, Society of Automotive Engineers, Warrendale, PA.
- Nyquist, G.W., Cavanaugh J.M., Goldberg S.J., and King A.I.. (1986). Facial impact tolerance and response. In Proc. 30th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE Paper No. 861896.
- Ommaya A.K. (1985) Biomechanics of Head Injury: Experimental Aspects, in “The Biomechanics of Trauma” edited by Nahum A.M. and Melvin J.W., pp 245-269.
- Rowson, S., Brolinson, G., Goforth, M., Dietter, D., and Duma, S.M. (2009) Linear and angular head acceleration measurements in collegiate football. J Biomech Eng, 131(6): 061016.
- Rowson, S., Duma, S. M., Beckwith, J. G., Chu, J. J., Greenwald, R. M., Crisco, J. J., Brolinson, P. G., Duhaime, A-C., McAlister, T. W., Maerlender, A. C., (2011) Rotational Head Kinematics in Football Impacts: An Injury Risk Function for Concussion, Annals of Biomedical Eng.: 1-13.
- SAS, Version 9.3, Cary, NC.
- Stalnaker, R.L., Alem, N.M., Benson, J.B., Melvin, J.W. (1977) Validation studies for head impact injury model. Final report DOT HS-802 566, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, US, Department of Transportation, Washington, DC.
- Takhounts, E.G., Eppinger, R.H., Campbell, J.Q., Tannous, R.E., Power, E.D., Shook, L.S. (2003a) On the Development of the SIMon Finite Element Head Model. Stapp Car Crash Journal 47: 107-133.
- Takhounts, E.G., Crandall, J.R., Darvish, K.K. (2003b) On the importance of nonlinearity of brain tissue under large deformations. Stapp Car Crash Journal 47:79-92.
- Takhounts, E.G., Hasija, V., Ridella, S.A., Tannous, R.E., Campbell, J.Q., Malone, D., Danelson, K., Stitzel, J., Rowson, S., Duma, S, (2008) Investigation of Traumatic Brain Injuries Using the Next Generation of Simulated Injury Monitor (SIMon) Finite Element Head Model. Stapp Car Crash Journal 52: 1-32.
- Takhounts, E.G., Hasija, V., Ridella, S.A., Rowson, S, Duma, S.M. (2011) Kinematic Rotational Brain Injury Criterion (BRIC). Proc. 22nd ESV Conference.
- Trosseille, X., et al. (1992) Development of a F.E.M. of the Human Head According to a Specific Test Protocol, 36th Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, SAE Paper No.922527.
- Ueno, K., and Melvin, J.W. (1995) Finite element model study of head impact based on hybrid III head acceleration: The effects of rotational and translational accelerations. J. Biomech Eng. 117(3): 319-328.