This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Exhaust Temperature Control Enhances Dual Stage Catalyst System Performance on Engines Fueled with Low-Pressure Natural Gas
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 10, 2012 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Controlling exhaust gas temperature in a dual-stage catalyst system improves by a factor of three (or more) its capability to tolerate air-fuel ratio (AFR) variability and maintain compliance with stationary engine emission standards enforced in CA. This system is ideally suited for combined heat and power (CHP) generating units, in which heat is intentionally extracted from the engine exhaust gases to improve overall system thermal efficiency.
Engines fueled with low-pressure natural gas typically employ fumigation fuel delivery systems. When operated at stoichiometric AFR using typical feedback fuel metering strategies and a three-way catalyst (TWC), these systems cannot reliably achieve the fuel control precision required to satisfy stringent emission requirements. Small rich or lean deviations in AFR result in large increases in tailpipe CO (rich) or NOx (lean).
In the 1980's, automobile OEMs employed dual-stage catalyst systems to address a similar issue. The dual-stage system employs a 3WC followed by an oxidation catalyst, with air injected between the two units. This system is very efficient at controlling CO emissions, but regenerates NOx in the oxidation section.
While evaluating a dual-stage catalyst concept for a CA CHP application, Tecogen discovered that NOx regeneration was minimal if temperature in the second stage was maintained below a threshold level . With support from the California Energy Commission, Tecogen contracted an independent evaluation of this phenomenon at AVL's test facility in Lake Forest, CA.
Tests were performed using a 2.5L “Atkinson-cycle” engine operating on natural gas fuel, with fuel delivery pressure of 1-2 inches of water (per typical indoor appliance practice). The exhaust system included a close-coupled TWC, followed by a liquid to air heat exchanger section that allowed controlled reduction of exhaust gas temperature. Secondary air was added to the exhaust downstream of the TWC using an electrically driven air pump. The temperature controlled exhaust gas with added air then entered the second stage catalyst.
The engine fuel control system permitted biasing of AFR to simulate AFR drift that had been experienced by Tecogen in production CHP units. Tests were performed over a range of speeds and loads typical of CHP duty cycle. Extensive measurements were collected to document engine operating parameters, exhaust temperatures, and exhaust emission levels. Results verified Tecogen's preliminary findings. Those results are presented in this paper.
CitationRoy, J., Panora, R., Gehret, J., Roser, R. et al., "Exhaust Temperature Control Enhances Dual Stage Catalyst System Performance on Engines Fueled with Low-Pressure Natural Gas," SAE Technical Paper 2012-01-1730, 2012, https://doi.org/10.4271/2012-01-1730.
- U.S. Patent Application No. 12/816,706, “Assembly and Method For Reducing Nitrogen Oxides, Carbon Monoxide And Hydrocarbons In Exhausts Of Internal Combustion Engines”, Gehret, Joseph B., Panora, Robert A., and Roser, Ranson
- Cottrill, Jerry, Miratech Corporation, “Evaluation of Automotive Oxygen Sensors for Steady-State Air/Fuel Ratio Control and its OBD Characteristics on Natural Gas Engines”, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Internal Combustion Engine Division Publication, 1999
- Toda, Takushi, Matsuki, Masato, Knight, Ben, “Development of a 1.7 liter CNG Engine for the 2001 Honda Civic GX”, Honda R&D Co., Ltd,.
- Hohn, Keith, Nuss-Warren Sarah, R., Kansas State University “Final Report: Cost-Effective Reciprocating Engine Emissions Control and Monitoring for E&P Field and Gathering Engines”, DOE DE-FC26-02NT15464, September 15, 2002 - August 31, 2011.
- South Coast Air Quality Management District, “Emissions from In-Use IC Engine DG and Lessons Learned”, presentation at First Electricity and Air Quality Conference, October 3-4 2006
- CEC Grant PNG-06-002 “Engine CHP Emission Control Technology”
- Heywood, John B., “Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals”, McGraw-Hill, New York, ISBN 0-07-028637-X, 1988.
- Defoort, Morgan, Olsen, Daniel PhD, Wilson, Brian PhD, “The Effect of Air/Fuel Ratio Control Strategies on Nitrogen Compound Formation in NCSR Catalysts”, International Journal of Engine Research, Vol. 5, No. 1, JER 03903 Published 2004 IMechE.
- Almega Environmental and Testing Services, Huntington Beach, CA, Source Test Report, “Emission Testing of the Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) For NOx, CO, SO2, O2, CO2, PM and VOC”, Test Date July 29, 2011, Report Date September 1, 2011.
- South Coast Air Quality Management District, “Source Test Protocol For The Measurement Of Nitrogen Oxides, Volatile Organic Compounds, Carbon Monoxide, and Oxygen From Stationary Engines Subject To South Coast Air Quality Management District Rule 1110.2”, November 21, 2008