Safety Belt and Occupant Factors Influencing Thoracic & Upper Abdominal Injuries in Frontal Crashes
Published April 12, 2011 by SAE International in United States
Annotation of this paper is available
This paper reports on a study that examines the effect of shoulder belt load limiters and pretensioners as well as crash and occupant factors that influence upper torso harm in real-world frontal crashes. Cases from the University of Michigan International Center for Automotive Medicine (ICAM) database were analyzed. Additional information was used from other databases including the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) New Car Assessment Program (NCAP), the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), the National Automotive Sampling System - Crashworthiness Data System (NASS-CDS), and patient data available from the University of Michigan Trauma Center. The ICAM database is comprised of information from real-world crashes in which occupants were seriously injured and required treatment at a Level 1 Trauma Center. Cases from the database were included in this study if they met the following criteria: (a) the primary collision involved a frontal type crash and; (b) case occupants were seated in front outboard positions, restrained by 3-point safety belts and deployed frontal airbags.
One hundred thirty-three (133) case occupants who sustained nearly 1,800 injuries were selected for study from the ICAM database. The study included evaluations of skeletal, organ, and vessel injuries to the upper torso. Potential influencing factors were divided into three general categories: vehicle factors (i.e., seatbelt design); occupant factors; and crash related factors.
Considering the challenges and limitations for analysis of field accident data and within the scope of this study, data indicated that: case occupants without shoulder belt load limiters experienced a higher level of upper torso harm in lower severity frontal crashes. The average Delta V for case occupants with shoulder belt load limiters was significantly higher (7.1 km/h, 34% greater crash energy) than that for the case occupants without load limiters. Case occupants with shoulder belt load limiters had significantly fewer clavicle fractures in frontal crashes. For the 62 case occupants with load limiters, the presence or absence of pretensioners did not appear to substantially change the crash severity associated with AIS ≥2 upper torso harm. Lower bone mineral density of the L4 vertebra was indicative of susceptibility to upper torso skeletal injuries. Smaller psoas muscle cross section area was indicative of susceptibility to upper torso internal and skeletal injuries.
- Huizhen Lu - General Motors Company
- Margaret Andreen - General Motors Company
- Daniel Faust - Crash Safety Consulting
- Lisa Furton - General Motors Company
- Sven Holcombe - University of Michigan ICAM
- Carla Kohoyda-Inglis - University of Michigan ICAM
- Brian Putala - General Motors Company
- Jack Yee - University of Michigan ICAM
- Stewart Wang - University of Michigan ICAM
CitationLu, H., Andreen, M., Faust, D., Furton, L. et al., "Safety Belt and Occupant Factors Influencing Thoracic & Upper Abdominal Injuries in Frontal Crashes," SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-1129, 2011, https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-01-1129.
- National Center for Statistics and Analysis, (2008), “National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) Traffic Safety Facts 2008 Data”, NHTSA Report Number DOT HS 811 162
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), (2002), “CIREN Program Report”
- Flannagan, C. A., and Rupp, J.D., (2009) “Comparison of Distributions of Key Predictor Variables in CIREN and NASS- CDS Cases Meeting CIREN Inclusion Criteria” Traffic Injury Prevention, Volume 10, pages 451 - 457
- Walz, M.C., (2003) “NCAP Test Improvements with Pretensioners and Load Limiters”, NHTSA Report Number DOT HS 809 562
- Forman, J., Lopez-Valdes, F., Lessley, D., Kindig, M. et al., “Rear Seat Occupant Safety: An Investigation of a Progressive Force-Limiting, Pretensioning 3-Point Belt System Using Adult PMHS in Frontal Sled Tests,” SAE Technical Paper 2009-22-0002, 2009.
- Foret-Bruno, J.-Y., Trosseille, X., Page, Y., Huere, J.-F. et al., “Comparison of Thoracic Injury Risk in Frontal Car Crashes for Occupant Restrained without Belt Load Limiters and Those Restrained with 6 kN and 4 kN Belt Load Limiters,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-22-0009, 2001.
- O'Brien-Mitchell, B., Bailey, K., Faust, D., Jensen, J., Kleinert, J., Wodzinski, C., Wang, S., (2009) “Comparison of University of Michigan CIREN Cases to Existing Types of Crash Tests”, ESV Paper 09-0185
- The Abbreviated Injury Scale, 1990 Revision, Update 98 Barrington, USA: Association for the Advancement of Automatic Medicine 2001.
- Malliaris, A.C., Hitchcock, R., and Hedlund, J., “A Search for Priorities in Crash Protection,” SAE Technical Paper 820242, 1982, doi: 10.4271/820242.
- Fildes, B.N., Lane, J.C., Lenard, J., and Vulcan, A.P., (1994) “Passenger Cars and Occupant Injury: Side Impact Crashes. Report CR 134, Federal Office of Road Safety, Canberra, Australia
- Griffith, J.F., Engelke, K., and Genant, H.K., (2010) “Looking Beyond Bone Mineral Density: Imaging Assessment of Bone Quality”, ANN NY ACAD SCI, 2010, 1192: P45-56
- Holcombe, S.A., Ejima, S., Huhdanpaa, H., Wang, S.C., (2008) “Ribcage Characterization for FE Using Finite Element CT Processing”, Japan Society of Automotive Engineers, 2008
- Englesbe, M.J., Patel, S.P., He, K., Lynch, R.J., Schaubel, D.E., Harbaugh, C., Holcombe, S.A., Wang, S.C., Segev, D.L., Sonnenday, C.J., (2010) “Sarcopenia and Mortality After Liver Transplantation”. J Am Coll Surg, 2010. 211(2): p. 271-8
- Kalichman, L., Hodges, P., Li, L., Guermazi, A., Hunter, D.J., “Changes in Paraspinal Muscles and Their Association with Low Back Pain and Spinal Degeneration: CT Study”, Eur Spine J. 19(7): p. 1136-44
- Miller, I., Freund, J.E., (1985) “Probability and Statistics for Engineers”, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ
- International Obesity Task Force Press Release, London, 2003
- Obesity and Overweight Factsheet. World Health Organization, 2003
- Ogden, C.L., Carroll, M.D., (June, 2010) “Prevalence of Overweight, Obesity, and Extreme Obesity Among Adults: United States, Trends 1976-1980 Through 2007-2008”, National Center for Health Statistics