This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Field Effectiveness Calculation of Integrated Safety Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 12, 2011 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The potential of determining the change of injury severity in the accident event taking passive as well as active measures into account at the vehicle (integral systems) are at present limited to pedestrian protective systems. Therefore, an extension of the existing methods for the application with common integral systems (front protection, side protection, etc.) is suggested. Nowadays the effectiveness of passive safety systems is determined in crash tests with very high accident severities. However, approximately 90% of real-world accidents have a lower accident severity as the required crash tests. Thus, this paper will present a method calculating the effectiveness of such an integral system based on real-world accident data. For these reasons, this paper is presenting a method for a more valid prediction of injury severity.
The German In-Depth Database GIDAS allows clustering the accident event in relevant car-to-car scenarios. The vehicle dynamics of all scenarios from the database will be simulated in PC-Crash, an accident-reconstruction software. Since the brake assist is obligatory from 2012 on, the system and its effect on each single accident scenario will be modeled. The effect of the restraint system will be calculated with Finite Element Simulation PAM-Crash. The outcome of the occupant simulation, the FMVSS injury criteria (e.g., HIC₃₆), will be converted into the risk factor to suffer an AIS3+ injury for each body region. Finally, the sum of all the injury risks weighted with the relevance of each scenario determines the expected value of MAIS3+ injured persons. Consequently, the percentage of protected MAIS3+ occupants can be calculated and the real-world benefit of an integral safety system can be evaluated.
The method described above covers all requirements for calculating the effectiveness of an integral safety system. Therefore, systems influencing vehicle dynamics will be modeled. The effect of these systems on impact situation will be calculated and implemented in the occupant simulation. In combination, by the use of this method the effectiveness of an integral safety system is determined.
CitationRessle, A., Fuerst, F., Koelzow, T., Lienkamp, M. et al., "Field Effectiveness Calculation of Integrated Safety Systems," SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-1101, 2011, https://doi.org/10.4271/2011-01-1101.
Safety Test Methodology and Structural Crashworthiness and Occupant Safety, 2011
Number: SP-2304; Published: 2011-04-12
Number: SP-2304; Published: 2011-04-12
- Kommission der europäischen Gemeinschaften “Weissbuch - Die europäische Verkehrspolitik bis 2010: Weichenstellungen für die Zukunft,” Brussels 2001
- Gollewski, T. “Integrale Sicherheit - Herausforderungen, aktuelle Funktions- und Auslegungskonzepte aus Sicht eines OEMs,” Integrated Safety 2008 Germany July 2 3 2008
- Reßle, A. Schramm, S. Kölzow, T. “Generierung von Verletzungsrisikofunktionen für Fußgängerkollisionen,” 10 th Crash.Tech Germany April 13 14 2010
- Baumann, K. H. Schöneburg, R. “Fahrzeugsicherheit in der Vorunfallphase,” 24 th VDI/VW-Gemeinschaftstagung Integrierte Sicherheit und Fahrerassistenzsysteme Germany October 29 30 2008
- Busch, S. “Entwicklung einer Bewertungsmethodik zur Prognose des Sicherheitsgewinns ausgewählter Fahrerassistenzsysteme,” Ph.D. thesis Technical University of Dresden 2004
- German In-Depth-Accident-Study (GIDAS) “accident investigation on the spot - Dresden and Hanover,” http://www.gidas.org/files/GIDAS.pdf Jan. 2011
- Schramm, S. “Methode zur Berechnung der Feldeffektivität integraler Fußgängerschutzsysteme,” Ph.D. thesis Technical University of Munich 2011
- Liers, H. “Benefit Estimation of the Euro NCAP Pedestrian Rating Concerning Real World Pedestrian Safety,” ESV Technical Paper 09-0387 2009
- Axa-Winterthur “rear-end collision at the tail end of a traffic jam,” http://www.axa-winterthur.ch/De/ueberuns/engagement/unfallforschung/Seiten/crashtests-wildhaus-2006.aspx Jan. 2011
- Knoll, P. Langwieder, K. “Der Sicherheitseffekt von ESP in Realunfällen - Überlegungen zum volkswirtschaftlichen Nutzen von prädiktiven Fahrerassistenzsystemen,” Tagung aktive Sicherheit 2006 Germany 2006
- Kramer, F. “Passive Sicherheit von Kraftfahrzeugen,” Vieweg+Teubner 13 978-3528069155 2008
- International Standards Organization “Road Vehicles - Injury Risk Curves for Evaluation of Occupant Protection in Frontal Impact,” Technical Report, ISO/TR 7861: 2003 (E) 2003
- International Standards Organization “Road Vehicles - Injury Risk Curves for Evaluation of Occupant Protection in Side Impact,” Technical Report, ISO/TR 12350: 2004 2004
- Carhs.Training GmbH “Safety Companion 2010,” Alzenau 2010
- Digges, K. Dalmotas, D. “Benefits of a low severity frontal crash test,” 51 st AAAM Melbourne 2007
- Rupp, J.D. Miller, C.S. Reed, M.P. Madura, N.H. Klinich, K.D. Schneider, L.W. “Characterization of Knee-Thigh-Hip Response in Frontal Impacts Using Biomechanical Testing and Computational Simulations,” 52 nd Stapp Car Crash Conference Texas 2008