This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Non-Esterified Plant Oils as Fuel -Engine Characteristics, Emissions and Mutagenic effects of PM-
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 13, 2009 by Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche in Italy
Annotation ability available
Plant oils may be used as a sustainable, nearly CO2 neutral fuel for diesel engines. This work investigates experimentally the particulate and gaseous emissions of diesel engines fuelled with non-esterified, pure plant oils with the quality standard of DIN V 51605 (Weihen-stephan RK-Qualitätsstandard 05/2000). The data are collected from three engines:
Common rail passenger car engine from OPEL AG
Truck engine from VOLVO
Truck engine from MAN AG
All engines have been correctly adjusted to plant oil operation.
The OPEL and VOLVO engines served for the basic investigations. The emissions of the MAN engine have been used to perform AMES tests to analyze possible health impacts of plant oil operation.
The experimental data show a reduction of particulate matter compared to traditional gasoil which may yield up to 50 % for. The particulate matter shows same primary particle sizes but the agglomerates as collected on TEM grids are different - the plant oil soot particles tend to form larger aggregates . The gaseous emissions of CO and hydrocarbons HC are generally lower compared to the operation with gasoil. However, the NOX emissions are slightly higher. This may be contributed to the measured higher combustion chamber pressures and temperatures when fuelled by plant oils.
Emission samples have been extracted from ESC cycles of 13 step tests to perform the AMES test which give indication on carcinogen substances. The AMES test results gave no indication of mutagenic effects exceeding the detection limits. No significant differences could be found comparing the emissions of plant oil and gasoil operation. Thus, it can be stated that the emission from plant oil operation does not have a health impact different to traditional gas oil. This is in contrast to some other publications — a deeper insight shows that these investigations did not properly modify the engine for plant oils. It is mandatory to make the engine modification to pre-warm the plant oils to approx. 90°C prior to injection. The engine's warm-up phase needs special care to avoid any coking at the injection system and combustion chamber surfaces. The publications where a higher health risk was claimed to be found in the exhaust of plant oil fuels, did not pre-warm the plant oils — cold plant oils have been injected in the combustion chamber instead. This results in incomplete atomization and incomplete combustion with a lot of hazardous emission species (see also [4,11]. Such an operation will damage the engine after relatively short times and is, therefore, not realistic.
The investigated fuels had some influence on the engine characteristics. Higher temperatures and pressures in the cylinder have been detected for some plant oils compared to gasoil. This increase is explained by the higher oxygen content within the plant oils.
CitationDorn, B. and Zahoransky, R., "Non-Esterified Plant Oils as Fuel -Engine Characteristics, Emissions and Mutagenic effects of PM-," SAE Technical Paper 2009-24-0097, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-24-0097.
- Energy Watch Group, WEO World Energy Outlook, 2008
- Wehmann, C. Diploma Thesis, University of Applied Sciences Offenburg, D-77654 Offenburg, 2006
- Website POELTEC www.poeltec.de and
- Dorn, B.Wehmann, C.Winterhalter, R.Za-horansky, R. Particle and Gaseous Emissions of Diesel Engines Fuelled by Different Non-Esterified Plant Oils, SAE-NA Techn. Papers Series 2007-24-0127, 2007
- Laile, E. Zahoransky, R.A. Mohr, M. Claussen, M. Optical on-line time resolved particle measurements in the exhaust gas of diesel engines for different test cycles, SAE_NA Techn. Papers Series 2003-01-56, 2003
- WIZARD DQL, company leaflet, WIZARD Za-horansky KG, D-79674 Todtnau, 2000
- Company leaflet, Xenometrics, AMES II Mutagenic-ity Assay Technical Documentation
- ARGUK Umweltlabor GmbH; http://arguk.de/images/BaP.gif, 2008
- Bünger, J.Krahl J. et al.; Strong mutagenic effects of diesel engine emissions using vegetable oil as fuel; Archives of Toxicology, 2007
- Thuneke K. et al., Mutagenität der Partikelemissio-nen eines mit Rapsöl- und Dieselkraftstoff betriebenen Traktors, Berichte aus dem TFZ 14, Technologie- und Förderzentrum Bayern, ISSN 1614-1008, Straubing, 2007
- Zahoransky, R.A. Dorn; B. Influence of different biological fuels on particle emissions of diesel engine; 9th ETH-Conference “Combustion Generated Na-noparticles” (Conference CD), Zürich, Aug. 2005
- Dorn B. et al., Pflanzenöle als Kraftstoff und deren Abgas- und Partikelemissionen beim PKW und LKW, Abschlussbericht Projekt UPAK, University of Applied Sciences Offenburg, www.biokraftstoffforschung.de, 2007
- Krist H. et al., Prüfung der Mutagenität von Inhaltsstoffen partikulärer Abgasbestandteile im AMES-Test, Bericht des BIFA Umweltinstituts, 2007