This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Quantifying the Fuel Consumption Penalties for an Operational Contrail Avoidance System
Technical Paper
2009-01-3151
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Recent work has shown that when an aircraft encounters ambient ice-supersaturated conditions (where contrails may form and persist), it may be possible to avoid contrail formation by shifting cruise altitude up or down 2000 feet. If an aircraft's cruise altitude is shifted from the optimal profile during a portion of the mission, fuel consumption increases. Because on average approximately 20% of distance flown by commercial airliners is through ice-supersaturated regions, this study quantifies the fuel burn penalties for the notional scenario of flying the same fraction of cruise at altitude displacements of +2000, -2000, and -4000 ft. Present aircraft performance data was used to generate accurate fuel burn penalty estimates.
This study finds that the net penalties for existing aircraft to fly contrail avoidance shifts vary between 0.2% and 0.7% increase in block fuel consumption. The magnitude of the fuel penalty can be reduced by approximately 0.25% by slowing down during the shifted segment. Further reductions are attainable for future aircraft with application of engine and aerodynamic technology intended to improve off-design performance. This suggests that if contrail regions could be predicted prior to flight planning, the fuel burn penalties for avoiding contrails over a single mission may be relatively small. However, implementation of this type of contrail avoidance system requires considerable advancements in the prediction of ice-supersaturated regions. Moreover, the fuel burn penalties realized in practical application of this system are likely to be larger than the single flight results presented in this study because the altitude shifts and routing approved by air traffic control will not be ideal.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Profan Propulsion for Commercial Air Transports |
Technical Paper | Trajectory Optimization of Airliners to Minimize Environmental Impact |
Aerospace Standard | Aerospace Rod Scraper Gland Design Standard |
Authors
Citation
Schwartz, E., Baughcum, S., and Daggett, D., "Quantifying the Fuel Consumption Penalties for an Operational Contrail Avoidance System," SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-3151, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-01-3151.Also In
References
- Penner J. Aviation and the Global Atmosphere Cambridge University Press
- Lee D. S. Fahey D. W. Forster P. M. Newton P. J. Wit R. C. Lim L. L. Owen B. Sausen R. “Aviation and global climate change in the 21st century,” Atmospheric Environment 43 2009
- The Boeing Company Current Market Outlook 2008-2027 www.boeing.com
- Schumann U. “Formation, properties, and climatic effects of contrails,” C.R. Physique 6 2005
- Gierens K. Lim L. Elefheratos K. “A review of the various strategies for contrail avoidance,” The Open Atmospheric Science Journal 2 2008
- Williams V. Noland R. Toumi R. “Reducing the climate change impacts of aviation by restricting cruise altitudes,” Transportation Research Part D 7 2002
- Garrison M. J. DuBois D. P. Baughcum S. L. “The effect of constrained cruise altitudes on fuel usage, NOx production, and flight time for commercial airplanes,” NASA/CR-2004-213305 2004
- Malwitz A. Balasubramanian S. Fleming G. Yoder T. Waitz I. “Impact of the reduced vertical separation minimum on the domestic United States,” Journal of Aircraft 46 January-February 2009
- Spichtinger P. Gierens K. Lieterer U. Dier H. “Ice supersaturation in the tropopause region over Lindenberg, Germany,” Meteorologische Zeitschrift 12 3 2003
- Mannstein H. Spichtinger P. Gierens K. “A note on how to avoid contrail cirrus,” Transportation Research Part D 10 2005
- Gierens K. Spichtinger P. “On the size distribution of ice-supersaturated regions in the upper troposphere,” Annales Geophysicae 18 2000
- Radel G. Shine K. P. “Radiative Forcing by Persistent Contrails and its Dependence on Cruise Altitudes,” Journal of Geophysical Research 113 2008