This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Description of Knock Limit in a CFR Engine: Effects of Engine Settings and Gas Quality
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 02, 2009 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Knock is a major technological constriction of natural gas spark ignition engines. Nowadays, it is widely accepted that knock is due to auto-ignition in the end gas region. Knock can occur for different reasons, which could be related to the engine itself (design and settings) or to the gas composition (or the gas quality). In a previous study the effect of engine settings on knock in a C.F.R. SI engine fuelled by pure methane was established by using a knock indicator, based on the evaluation of the energy of end gases.
The paper deals with knock limit prediction from natural gas quality in a C.F.R. engine. A 2-zone thermodynamic model was developed in order to predict knocking conditions by evaluating a knock indicator.
The model relies on some standard assumptions. Ignition delay was expressed as a function of engine settings, and a physical correlation for the heat release rate model was used. Effect of gas quality is integrated to the correlation of the laminar flame speed by considering an original assumption adopted by the authors “two gases having the same knock tendency (i.e. same gas quality) are expected to have the same combustion behaviour (Laminar flame speed)”. Chemical scheme is the well known GRI-3.0, involving 325 equations and 53 species.
First simulations with pure methane show good agreement with literature. In a second step, a natural gas database is used to evaluate the knock criterion, showing linearity with gas quality. Finally, a preventive technique is described, resulting in a correction of knocking conditions (caused by a low grade gas) through an optimal control of engine settings.
CitationKhalil, S., Camal, R., Olivier, L., and Laurent, T., "Description of Knock Limit in a CFR Engine: Effects of Engine Settings and Gas Quality," SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-2620, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-01-2620.
- Heywood J.B. Internal combustion engine fundamentals McGraw-Hill Book Compagny Simgapore 1988
- Takagi Y. Itoh T. Iijima, T. An analytical study on knocking heat release and its control in a spark ignition engine SAE Paper No. 880196 1988
- Blundson C.A. Dent, J.C. The simulation of autoignition and knock in a spark ignition engine with disk geometry SAE paper No. 940524 1994
- Nakajima Y. Nagai, T. Iijima, T. Yokoyama J. Nakamura, K. Analysis of combustion patterns effective in improving anti-knock performance of a spark ignition engine JSAE Paper NO. 845502 13 1984
- Essig G. ‘Piston loading at knocking combustion (Detonation)’ International symposium Wolfsburg, Germany November 1981
- Faure E. Montagne X ORI: Assessment methodology and influence of engine running parameters SAE technical paper, (972933) 1997
- Ho S. Amlee D. Johns R. A comprehensive knock model for application in gas engines SAE Technical paper (961938) 1997
- Westin F. Grandin, B. Angstrom. H.E. The influence of the residual gases on knock in turbocharged SI-engines SAE Technical paper (2000-01-2840) 2000
- Schiffgens H.J. Endres H. Wackertapp H. Shrey E Concepts for the adaptation of SI engines to changing methane number Transactions of the ASME, Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power 116 733 739 1994
- Russ S. A review of the effect of engine operating conditions on borderline knock SAE Technical Paper No. 960497 1996
- Ferguson C. R Internal combustion engines Applied thermosciences John Wylely & Sons 1986
- Karim GA Gao, J. A predictive model of knock in spark ignition engines SAE Technical Paper No. 922366 1992
- Alizadeh Attar A Karim G A An analytical approach for optimization gas fueled SI engine performance including consideration of knock Spring Technical conference ASME 28-2 1997
- Saikaly K Rousseau S Rahmouni C Le Corre O Truffet L Safe operating conditions determination for stationary SI gas engines Fuel Processing Technology 1169 1179 2008
- Livengood JC Wu PC Correlation of autoignition phenomena in internal combustion engines and rapid compression machines 5 th International Symposium on Combustion 347 356 September 1954
- Bilcan A. Contribution to the study of the thermodynamic cycle of dual-fuel engines PhD University of Nantes 2003
- Draper C.S. The physicals effects of detonation in a closed cylindrical chamber NACA 1935
- Draper C.S. Pressures waves accompanying detonation in the thermal combustion Journal of the aeronautcal sciences 5 6 1938
- Brecq G. Le Corre, O. Modeling of In-cylinder pressure oscillations under knocking conditions: introduction to pressure envelope curve Modeling of SI and Disel engines, SP-1969, ISBN 0-7680-1614-2 33 2005
- Lee W. Schaefer, H. J. Analysis of local pressure, surface temperatures and engine damagesunder knock conditions SAE Paper No. 830508 1983
- Blumberg P.N. Kummer, J.T. Prediction of NO formation in spark ignition engines: an analysis of methods of control Combustion Sci and tech 4 73 95 1992
- Chmela F Engelmayer M Beran R Ludu A Prediction of heat release rate and NOx emission for large open chamber gas engines with spark ignition 3rd Dessau Gas Engine Conference Dessau, Saxony-anhalt, Germany May 22–23 2003
- Hohenberg GF. Advanced approaches for heat transfer calculations SAE Technical Paper No. 790825 1979
- Rousseau S Lemoult B Tazerout M Combustion characterization of natural gas in a lean burn spark-ignition engine Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs 32 Part D 481 489 1999
- Al-Janabi H Al-Baghdadi M A prediction study of the effect of hydrogen blending on the performance and pollutants emission of a four stroke spark ignition engine International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 24 363 375 1999
- Yu G Law CK Wu CK Laminar flame speeds of hydrocarbon + air mixtures with hydrogen addition Combustion and Flame 63 339 347 1986
- Smith G, Franklach M, Bowman T Gardinr B. Chemical Program GRI-Mech 3.0 www.me.berkeley.edu/gri-mech/releases.html
- Saikaly K. Le Corre, O. Rahmouni C. Truffet, L. Preventive knock protection technique for stationary SI engines fuelled by natural gas Fuel Processing Technology 2009
- Konig G Sheppard C G W End gas autoignition and knock in a spark ignition engine SAE Technical paper no (902135) 1990
- Rahmouni C Tazerout M Le Corre O Determination of the combustion properties of natural gases by pseudo-constituents Fuel 2003 82 1399 1409
- Loubar K Rahmouni C Le Corre O Tazerout M A combustionless determination method for combustion properties of natural gases Fuel 86 16 2535 2544 November 2007