This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Inertially-Induced Cervical Spine Injuries in the Pediatric Population
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 20, 2009 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This study integrates data from multiple sources to obtain a more complete understanding of inertially-induced pediatric cervical spine injury risk and the role of impact severity and restraint type. Data from previously conducted frontal crash and sled tests using a variety of anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) in various restraint configurations were compiled and compared to injury assessment reference values (IARVs). The data show that neck loads in frontal collisions increase with increasing delta-V. At high delta-Vs, the neck loads correspond to a relatively high risk of neck injury regardless of restraint configuration. Pediatric inertial cervical spine injury risk in frontal collisions is governed primarily by the energy involved in the collision.
CitationMoore, T., Prange, M., and Corrigan, C., "Inertially-Induced Cervical Spine Injuries in the Pediatric Population," SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0395, 2009, https://doi.org/10.4271/2009-01-0395.
- Givens, T., Polley, K., Smith, G., Hardin, W. (1996). “Pediatric cervical spine injury: a three-year experience.” J Trauma. 41: 310–314.
- Zuckerbraun, B., Morrison, K., Gaines, B., Ford, H., Hackam, D. (2004). “Effect of age on cervical spine injuries in children after motor vehicle collisions: effectiveness of restraint devices.” Journal of Pediatric Surgery. 39: 483–486.
- Patel, J., Tepas, J., Mollitt, D., Pieper, P. (2001). “Pediatric cervical spine injuries: defining the disease.” Journal of Pediatric Surgery. 36: 373–376.
- Brown, J., McCaskill, M., Henderson, M., Bilston, L. (2006). “Serious injury is associated with suboptimal restraint use in child motor vehicle occupants.” J Paediatr Child Health. 42: 345–349.
- Nance, M., Elliott, M., Arbogast, K., Winston, F., Durbin, D. (2006). “Delta V as a predictor of significant injury for children involved in frontal motor vehicle crashes.” Ann Surg. 243: 121–125.
- Arbogast, K., Durbin, D., Cornejo, R., Kallan, M., Winston, F. (2004). “An evaluation of the effectiveness of forward facing child restraint systems.” Accid Anal Prev. 36: 585–589.
- Durbin, D., Chen, I., Smith, R., Elliott, M., Winston, F. (2005). “Effects of seating position and appropriate restraint use on the risk of injury to children in motor vehicle crashes.” Pediatrics. 115: e305–309.
- Bull, M., Stroup, K., Gerhart, S. (1988). “Misuse of car safety seats.” Pediatrics. 81: 98–101.
- Winston, F., Chen, I., Elliott, M., Arbogast, K., Durbin, D. (2004). “Recent trends in child restraint practices in the United States.” Pediatrics. 113: e458–464.
- Hummel, T., Lanwieder, K., Finkbeiner, F., Hell, W. (1997). “Injury risks, misuse rates and the effect of misuse depending on the kind of child restraint system.” in Second Child Occupant Protection Symposium: Society of Automotive Engineering.
- Valent, F., McGwin, G., Hardin, W., Johnston, C., Rue, L. (2002). “Restraint use and injury patterns among children involved in motor vehicle collisions.” J Trauma. 52: 745–751.
- Huelke, D., Mackay, G., Morris, A., Bradford, M. (1992). “Non-head impact cervical spine injuries in frontal car crashes to lap-shoulder belted occupants.” SAE 920560.
- Huelke, D., Mackay, G., Morris, A., Bradford, M. (1992). “Car crashes and non-head impact cervical spine injuries in infants and children.” SAE Yes.
- Huelke, D., Mackay, G., Morris, A., Bradford, M. (1993). “A review of cervical fractures and fracture-dislocations without head impacts sustained by restrained occupants.” Accid Anal Prev. 25: 731–743.
- Newman, J., Dalmotas, D. (1993). “Atlanto-occipital fracture dislocation in lap-belt restrained children.” SAE 933099.
- Howard, A., McKeag, A., Rothman, L., Mills, D., Blazeski, S., Chapman, M., Hale, I. (2005). “Cervical spine injuryes in children restrained in forward-facing child restraints: a report of two cases.” Journal of Trauma. 59: 1504–1506.
- Fuchs, S., Barthel, M., Flannery, A., Christoffel, K. (1989). “Cervical spine fractures sustained by young children in forward-facing car seats.” Pediatrics. 84: 348–354.
- Stalnaker, R. (1993). “Spinal cord injuries to children in real world accidents.” SAE Skimmed.
- Trosseille, X., Tarriere, C. (1993). “Neck injury criteria for children from real crash reconstructions.” SAE 933103.
- Henderson, M., Brown, J., Paine, M. (1994). “Injuries to restrained children.” in 38th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine. Lyon, France
- Burdi, A., Huelke, D., Snyder, R., Lowrey, G. (1969). “Infants and children in the adult world of automobile safety design: pediatric and anatomical considerations for design of child restraints.” J Biomech. 2: 267–280.
- Huelke, D. (1998). “An overview of anatomical considerations of infants and children in the adult world of automobile safety design.” in Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, 42nd Annual Conference. Charlottesville, Virginia: AAAM.
- Van Arsdell, W. (2005). “The evolution of FMVSS 213: Child Restraint Systems.” Society of Automotive Engineers. SAE 2005-01-1840.
- Mertz, H., Irwin, A., Prasad, P. (2003). “Biomechanical and scaling bases for frontal and side impact Injury Assessment Reference Values.” Stapp Car Crash Journal. 47: 155–188.
- Prange, M., Newberry, W., Moore, T., Peterson, D., Smyth, B., Corrigan, C. (2007). “Inertial neck injuries in children involved in frontal collisions.” SAE 2007-01-1170.
- Moore, T., Prange, M., Newberry, W., Peterson, D., Smyth, B., Corrigan, C. (2007). “Inertial neck injuries in children involved in frontal collisions: sled testing using the 6-year-old ATD.” in Proceedings of the ASME 2007 Summer Bioengineering Conference Keystone, Colorado SBC2007-176671.
- Henderson, M., Brown, J., Griffiths, M. (1997). “Children in adult seat belts and child harnesses: crash sled comparisons of dummy responses.” SAE 973308.
- Janssen, E., Huijskens, C., Verschut, R., Twisk, D. (1993). “Cervical spine loads induced in restrained child dummies II.” SAE 933102.
- Janssen, E., Nieboer, J., Verschut, R., Huijskens, C. (1991). “Cervical spine loads induced in restrained child dummies.” SAE 912919.
- Legault, F., Gardner, B., Vincent, A. (1997). “The effect of top tether strap configurations on child restraint performance.” SAE 973304.
- Planeth, I., Rygaard, C., Nilsson, S. (1992). “Synthesis of data towards neck protection criteria for children.” in International Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact. Verona, Italy
- Czernakowski, W., Otte, D. (1993). “The effect of pre-impact braking on the performance of child restraint systems in real life accidents and under varying test conditions.” SAE 933097.
- Bohman, K., Bostrom, O., Olsson, J., Haland, Y. (2006). “The effect of a pretensioner and a load limiter on a HIII 6 Y, seated on four different types of booster cushions in frontal impacts.” in IRCOBI. Madrid, Spain.
- Ha, D., Bertocci, G. (2007). “Injury risk of a 6-year-old wheelchair-seated occupant in a frontal motor vehicle impact--’ANSI/RESNA WC-19’ sled testing analysis.” Med Eng Phys. 29: 729–738.
- Kapoor, T., Altenhof, W., Wang, Q., Howard, A. (2006). “Injury potential of a three-year-old Hybrid III dummy in forward and rearward facing positions under CMVSS 208 testing conditions.” Accident Analysis and Prevention. 38: 786–800.
- Menon, R., Ghati, Y. (2007). “Misuse study of latch attachment: a series of frontal sled tests.” Annu Proc Assoc Adv Automot Med. 51: 129–154.
- Sherwood, C., Shaw, C., Van Rooij, L., Kent, R., Crandall, J., Orzechowski, K., Eichelberger, M., Kallieris, D. (2003). “Prediction of cervical spine injury risk for the 6-year-old child in frontal crashes.” Traffic Inj Prev. 4: 206–213.
- Glaeser, K. (1992). “New test conditions for child restraint systems.” SAE 922516.
- Malott, A., Parenteau, C., Arbogast, K., Mari-Gowda, S. (2004). “Sled test results using the Hybrid III 6 year old: an evaluation of various restraints and crash configurations.” SAE 2004-01-0316.
- Menon, R., Ghati, Y., Ridella, S., Roberts, D., Winston, F. (2004). “Evaluation of restraint type and performance tested with 3- and 6-year-od Hybrid III dummies at a range of speeds.” SAE 2004-01-0319.
- Menon, R., Ghati, Y., Roberts, D. (2005). “Performance evaluation of various high-back booster seats tested at 56 kph using a 6-year-old Hybrid III dummy.” in ESV 05-0366.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. “Tables for CRS RFC.” (cited September 4, 2008). Available from: http://www.nhtsa.gov/Cars/rules/rulings/CRS-Rate/Tables3.htm.
- Whitman, G., Yannaccone, J., Bandak, F., Sicher, L., D’Aulerio, L., Shanahan, D., Cantor, A., Roberts, D., Moss, S. (1999). “A method for the assessment of tethered and untethered child restraint systems using the Hybrid III three year old dummy.” in 27th International Workshop on Injury Biomechanics Research. San Diego, California.
- Belcher, T., Newland, C. (2007). “Investigation of lower anchorage systems for child restraints in Australia.” in ESV.
- Brun Cassan, F., Page, M., Pincemaille, Y., Kallieris, D., Tarriere, C. (2993). “Comparative study of restrained child dummies and cadavers in experimental crashes.” SAE 933105.
- Weber, K., Dalmotas, D., Hendrick, B. (1993). “Investigation of dummy response and restraint configuration factors associated with upper spinal cord injury in a forward-facing child restraint.” SAE 933101.
- Tanner, C., Wiechel, J., Morr, D., Guenther, D. (2002). “Response of the 6-month-old CRABI in forward facing and rear facing child restraints to a simulated real world impact.” SAE 2002-01-0026.
- Oster, J., Trommier, B. (1996). “Comparison of the six-year-old Hybrid III, Part 572 and TNO P6 child dummies.” SAE 962437.
- Kuppa, S., Saunders, J., Fessahaie, O. (2005). “Rear seat occupant protection in frontal crashes.” in 19th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles. Washington, D.C. 05-0212.
- Charlton, J. L., Fildes, B., Laemmle, R., Koppel, S., Fechner, L., Moore, K., Smith, S., Douglas, F., Doktor, I. (2005). “Crash performance evaluation of booster seats for an Australian car.” in 19th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles. Washington, D.C. 05-0425.
- Saul, R. A., Pritz, H. B., McFadden, J., Backaitis, S. H., Hallenbeck, H., Rhule, D. (1998). “Description and performance of the Hybrid III three year old, six-year-old and small female test dummies in restraint system and out-of-position air bag environments.” in 16th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles. Windsor, Ontario, Canada 98-S7-O-01.
- Irwin, A., Mertz, H. (1997). “Biomechanical basis for the CRABI and Hybrid III child dummies.” SAE 973317.
- Bohman, K., Bostrom, O., Osvalder, A., Eriksson, M. (2007). “Rear seat frontal impact protection for children seated on booster cushions - an attitude, handling and safety approach.” in ESV.
- Durbin, D., Elliott, M., Winston, F. (2003). “Belt-positioning booster seats and reduction in risk of injury among children in vehicle crashes.” JAMA. 289: 2835–2840.
- Elliott, M., Kallan, M., Durbin, D., Winston, F. (2006). “Effectiveness of child safety seats vs seat belts in reducing risk for death in children in passenger vehicle crashes.” Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 160: 617–621.
- Miller, T., Zaloshnja, E., Hendrie, D. (2006). “Cost-outcome analysis of booster seats for auto occupants aged 4 to 7 years.” Pediatrics. 118: 1994–1998.
- Arbogast, K., Kent, R., Menon, R., Ghati, Y., Durbin, D., Rouhana, S. (2007). “Mechanisms of abdominal organ injury in seat belt-restrained children.” J Trauma. 62: 1473–1480.
- Shepherd, M., Hamill, J., Segedin, E. (2006). “Paediatric lap-belt injury: a 7 year experience.” Emerg Med Australas. 18: 57–63.
- Durbin, D., Arbogast, K., Moll, E. (2001). “Seat belt syndrome in children: a case report and review of the literature.” Pediatr Emerg Care. 17: 474–477.
- Edgerton, E., Orzechowski, K., Eichelberger, M. (2004). “Not all child safety seats are created equal: the potential dangers of shield booster seats.” Pediatrics. 113: e153–158.
- Lutz, N., Arbogast, K., Cornejo, R., Winston, F., Durbin, D., Nance, M. (2003). “Suboptimal restraint affects the pattern of abdominal injuries in children involved in motor vehicle crashes.” J Pediatr Surg. 38: 919–923.
- Nance, M., Lutz, N., Arbogast, K., Cornejo, R., Kallan, M., Winston, F., Durbin, D. (2004). “Optimal restraint reduces the risk of abdominal injury in children involved in motor vehicle crashes.” Ann Surg. 239: 127–131.