This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A New Decoupled CFD and FEM Methodology for the Fatigue Strength Assessment of an Engine Head
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 14, 2008 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A 2200 cc engine head for marine applications has been analysed and optimized by means of decoupled CFD and FEM simulations in order to assess the fatigue strength of the component. The fluid distribution within the cooling jacket was extensively analysed and improved in previous works, in order to enhance the performance of the coolant galleries. A simplified methodology was then proposed in order to estimate the thermo-mechanical behaviour of the head under actual engine operation [1, 2].
As a consequence of the many complex phenomena involved, an improved approach is presented in this paper, capable of a better characterization of the fatigue strength of the engine head under both high-cycle and low-cycle fatigue loadings. The improved methodology is once again based on a decoupled CFD and FEM analysis, with relevant improvements added to both simulation realms.
From the CFD side, a new generation polyhedral grid is employed to combine high resolution surface spacing, computational demand, and numerical stability of the CFD simulations, with particular emphasis on the boundary layer representation. The local heat flux distribution is calculated by means of CFD analyses of the coolant galleries, now including the engine block portion, plus the engine head metal cast.
In order to tune and improve the accuracy of the numerical forecasts, comparisons are carried out with experiments in terms of local metal cast temperature distribution for steady operation of the cooling circuit. Once again, particular care is devoted to the CFD representation of the boundary layer, both fluid and thermal. At the same time, great attention is paid to the thermal boundary conditions, i.e. the distribution of the heat fluxes among the many components facing the combustion process. In order to improve the accuracy of the CFD forecasts, effects of coolant boiling on the heat transfer forecast are investigated and included in the procedure.
As a result, a pointwise heat transfer distribution on the fluid/solid interface is transferred as a boundary condition to a thermo-structural analysis for the evaluation of the fatigue strength of the component. An ad-hoc routine is used to map the CFD computed pointwise distribution of the heat flux on a FEM-optimized grid.
From the FEM side, an energy based fatigue strength criterion is now implemented in order to create a design tool capable of predicting the fatigue strength of automotive parts subjected to different thermo-mechanical loadings. Both high-cycle fatigue and low-cycle fatigue regions are analysed, and the proposed methodology is successfully applied to predict the site of crack nucleation on an actual engine head and to improve the cooling jacket behaviour.
CitationFontanesi, S., Carpentiero, D., Malaguti, S., Giacopini, M. et al., "A New Decoupled CFD and FEM Methodology for the Fatigue Strength Assessment of an Engine Head," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-0972, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-0972.
- Cantore, G. Fontanesi, S. Gagliardi, V. Malaguti, S. Baldini, A. Giacopini, M. Strozzi, A. Rosi, R. “Optimization of a cooling circuit in an internal combustion engine for marine applications” SAE Paper 2005-24-49
- Carpentiero, D. Fontanesi, S. Gagliardi, V. Malaguti, S. Margini, S. Giacopini, M. Strozzi, A. Arnone, L. Bonanni, M. Franceschini, D. “Thermomechanical analysis of an engine head by means of integrated CFD and FEM” SAE Paper 2007-24-0067
- Feltner, C.E. Morrow, J.D. “Microplastic Strain Hysteresis Energy as a Criterion for Fatigue Fracture” J. of Basic Engineering, Transactions of the ASME March 1961 15 22
- Skelton, R. P. “Energy criteria for high temperature low cycle fatigue.” 1991 Mat. Sci Tech. 7 427 439
- Charkaluk, E. Constantinescu, A. Bignonnet, A. Dang Van, K. “On a failure criterion for thermomechanical multiaxial low cycle fatigue and its industrial application” Proceedings of Low Cycle Fatigue and Elasto-Plastic Behaviour RIe, K.T. Portella D. 5-11 september 1998 Garmisch-Partenkirschen, Elsevier 815 821
- Charkaluk, E. Constantinescu, A. “Energetic approach in thermomechanical fatigue for silicon molybdenum cast-iron” 2000 Mater high Temp. 17 373 380
- Thomas, J.J. Verger, L Bignonnet, A. Charkaluk, E. “Thermomechanical design in the automotive industry” 2004 Fatigue Fract. Engng. Mater. Struct. 27 887 895
- Chaboche, J. L. “Time-Independent constitutive theories for cyclic plasticity” 1986 International Journal of Plasticity 2 2
- Chaboche, J. L. “Constitutive equations for cyclic plasticity and cyclic viscoplasticity” 1989 International Journal of Plasticity 5 247 302
- Bhowmick, S. Branchi, C. McAssey, E.V., Jr. Gollin, M. Cozzone, G. “Prediction of Heat Transfer in Engine Cooling Systems” Experimental Heat Transfer, Fluid Mechanics and Thermodynamics 1997 387 392
- Finlay, I.C. Gallacher, G.R. Biddulph, T.W. Marshall, R.A. “The Application of Precision Cooling to the Cylinder-Head of a Small Automotive, Petrol Engine” SAE 880263
- Norris, P. M. Wepfer, W. Hoag, K. L. Courtine-White, D. “Experimental and Analytical Studies of Cylinder Head Cooling” Georgia Institute of Technology Cummins Engine Co. Inc. SAE 931122
- Lee, H. S. O'Neill, A. T. “Comparison of Boiling Curves Between a Standard S.I. Engine and a Flow Loop for a Mixture of Ethylene Glycol and Water” SAE Paper 2006-01-1231
- ASM Handbook 1 Properties and Selection: Irons, Steels, and High-Performance Alloys ASM International 10 April 1 1990
- Gollin, M. McAssey, E. V. Stinson, C. “Comparative Performance of Ethylene Glycol/Water and Propylene Glycol/Water Coolants in the Convective and Forced Flow Boiling Regimes SAE Paper 950464
- Menter, F.R. 1993 ‘Zonal two equation k-ω turbulence models for aerodynamic flows’ Proc. 24th Fluid Dynamics Conf. Orlando, Florida, USA 6-9 July
- Le Feuvre, T. et al. “Experimental istantaneous heat fluxes in a Diesel engine and their correlation SAE Paper 690464 , SAE Transactions 78 1969
- Herdin, G. R. Tomsik, H. Katzmann, B. Gatterer, F. Traunbauer, J. “Analysis of low-cycle liner flange fatigue in locomotive engines” ASME Paper 2002-ICE-473
- Yoshida, M. Harigaya, Y. Sato, K. “Variation of heat flux through a combustion chamber wall of pre-chamber type Diesel engine” Bulletin of JSME 25 201 1982
- Ravi Kumar, P. Srinivas, P.N. Nelson, J. E. B. Rao, S. S. “Experimental studies on energy appropriation in a single cylinder Diesel engine”
- Rakopoulos, C. D. Giakoumis, E. G. “Development of cumulative and availability rate balances in a multi cylinder turbocharged indirect injection Diesel engine” Energy Convers. Mgmt. 38 4
- Borgnakke, C. et al. “A model for the istantaneous heat transfer and turbulence in a spark ignition engine” SAE Paper 800287 1980
- Fisher P. Dannbauer H. Unger B. “Fatigue analysis to accelerate design process of a diesel engine” Engineering/Technologie Zentrum Steyr Steyr Daimler Puch AG Steyr, Austria