This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Fatal and Severe Injuries in Rear Impact; Seat Stiffness in Recent Field Accident Data
Technical Paper
2008-01-0193
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A decade ago, James, et.al. published a detailed study of the available NASS data on severe rear impacts, with findings that “… stiffened or rigid seat backs will not substantially mitigate severe and fatal injuries in rear impacts.” No field accident study has since been advanced which refutes this finding. Advocates of rigidized seat backs often point to specific cases of severe rear impacts in which MAIS 4+ injuries are associated with seat back deformation, coupled with arguments supporting stiffer seatback designs. These arguments are generally based upon laboratory experiments with dummies in normal seating positions. Recent field accident data shows that generally, in collisions where the majority of societal harm is created, yielding seats continue to provide benefits, including those associated with whiplash associated disorders (WAD).
This paper reviews the field accident data to identify from actual accident situations the degree to which rigidified or stiffer seats might affect the injury level of real people in severe and extremely severe rear-end crashes. Harm distributions by injury source, damage extent, and velocity change are presented. Individual case studies are reviewed for accident years between 1979 and 2002. Hard copy cases were analyzed to support the findings from the databases. Individual severe injuries were compared with respect to body region and injury contact source. Harm distributions with severity (delta-V) were presented [8]. Pre-impact out-of-position effects are significant in rear crash injury. The majority of Harm still resides in the lower-severity crashes. Cautions about possible negative net societal effects of stiffer seatbacks remain valid. Recent broad-scale field studies have proven an increased incidence of whiplash injuries related to stiffer seatbacks. Earlier findings are not substantially changed by the more recent data: stiffer seats per se do not reduce the overall incidence of harm due to injury in severe rear crashes.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Safety Performance of Motor Vehicle Seats |
| Technical Paper | Front-Seat Occupant Injuries in Rear Impacts: Analysis of the Seatback Incline Variable in NASS-CDS |
| Technical Paper | Severe Head and Neck Injuries in NASS Rear Impacts |
Authors
Citation
Warner, M. and Warner, C., "Fatal and Severe Injuries in Rear Impact; Seat Stiffness in Recent Field Accident Data," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-0193, 2008, https://doi.org/10.4271/2008-01-0193.Also In
References
- Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine “2000 NASS Injury Coding Manual” NHTSA 2000
- Bortenschlager K. Hartlieb M. Barnsteiner K. Ferdinand L. Kramberger D. Siems S. Muser M. Schmitt K. “Review of Existing Injury Criteria and Their Tolerance Limits for Whiplash Injuries with Respect to Testing Experience and Rating Systems” Paper No. 07-0486 2007
- Burnett R. Carter J. Roberts V. Myers B. “The Influence of Seatback Characteristics on Cervical Injury Risk in Severe Rear Impacts” Accident Analysis and Prevention 36 591 601 2004
- Highway Safety Act of 1966, 80 Stat. 731, Title 23, USC, Chapter 4 and subsequent laws and regulations under Part 571
- Data Link Inc “Current Issues of Occupant Protection in Car Rear Impacts” Office of Crashworthiness, Rulemaking, NHTSA Washington, DC February 1990
- Decker, Robin W. Decker Information Services 2005
- Decker, Robin W. Decker Information Services 2006
- James M. Decker R. Warner C. “Severe & Fatal Injuries in Rear Impacts” 41 st Annual Proceedings AAAM Orlando, Florida November 10 -11 1997
- James M. Strother C. Perl T. Smith G. Warner C. “Preliminary Assessment of NASS CDS Data Related to Rearward Seat Collapse and Occupant Injury” Collision Safety Engineering Orem, UT June 11 2001
- Krafft M. Kullgren A. Lie A. Tingvall C. “The Risk of Whiplash Injury in the Rear Seat Compared to the Front Seat in Rear Impacts” Traffic Injury Prevention 4 136 140 2003
- Kullgren A. Krafft M. Lie A. Tingvall C. “The Effect of Whiplash Protection Systems in Real-Life Crashes and Their Correlation to Consumer Crash Test Programmes” Paper No. 07-0468 2007 NHTSA
- Malliaris A.C. Hitchcock R. Hansen M. “Harm Causation and Ranking in Car Crashes” SAE # 850090 , International Congress and Exposition Detroit, MI 25 February 1 March 1985
- Molino L. “Preliminary Assessment of NASS CDS Data Related to Rearward Seat Collapse and Occupant Injury” NHTSA May 1997
- Molino L. “Determination of Moment-Deflection Characteristics of Automobile Seat Backs” NHTSA 25 November 1998
- NHTSA, Department of Transportation ‘Termination of Rulemaking’, FMVSS207, Federal Register 69 220 67068 16 November 2004
- The National Analysis Sampling System NHTSA Washington, DC
- Prasad P. Kim A. Weerappuli D. Roberts V. Schneider D. “Relationships Between Passenger Car Seat Back Strength and Occupant Injury Severity in Rear End Collisions: Field and Laboratory Studies” SAE # 973343 , 41 st Stapp Car Crash Conference Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA, November 1997
- Saczalski K. Syson S. Hille R. Pozzi M. Field Accident Evaluations and Experimental Study of Seat Back Performance Relative to Rear-Impact Occupant Protection Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA 1993
- Strother C. James M. Gordon J. “Response of Out-of-Position Dummies in Rear Impact” SAE # 941055 , SAE International Congress and Exposition Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA 1994
- Viano D. C. “Role of the Seat in Rear Crash Safety” Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA 2002
- Viano D. C. Parenteau C.S. Prasad P. Burnett R. “Stiff versus Yielding Seats: Analysis of Matched Rear Impact Tests” Society of Automotive Engineers, Paper # 2007-01-0708 April 2007
- Warner C. Y. Strother C. E. James M. B. Decker R. L. “Occupant Protection in Rear-end Collisions: II. The Role of Seat Back Deformation in Injury Reduction” SAE # 912914 Society of Automotive Engineers 1991
- Watanabe Y. Ito S. “Influence of Vehicle Properties and Human Attributes on Neck Injuries in Rear-End Collisions” Paper No. 07-0160 2007
- Kent R. W. James M. B. Nordhagen R. P. “Seat Design and Occupant Protection in Rear Impacted Vehicles. 98SAF033 (ISATA Conference)