This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Interactive Approach to the Design of an Acoustically Balanced Vehicle Sound Package
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published May 15, 2007 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Each time a new vehicle is developed, engineers face the challenge to develop the ideal sound insulation package. The goal is to attenuate powertrain, wind and road/tire noise from entering the vehicle while complying with cost, weight and packaging constraints. The design process is greatly facilitated if the engineer has effective tools to rapidly quantify how various sound insulation components contribute to the overall NVH performance of the vehicle.
This paper discusses how an interactive vehicle acoustical design tool can be developed that assists the designer in making rapid decisions as to how to balance the performance of the various sound package components. The acoustical design tool is unique for each vehicle, and must take into account design decisions such as type of powertrain, body style, and numerous other factors in order to correctly predict the performance of the total package. Any good modeling tool must also take into account inputs from a reasonable range of operating conditions.
A very good model for the acoustical behavior of the vehicle can be developed using data from measurements made while operating a sample vehicle at the target operating conditions. The authors will present a method for utilizing measurements together with some simple equations to predict the result when components of different designs are exchanged. The process of generating the needed data for this method from experiments on a vehicle is admittedly time consuming, if all of the possible design variations are to be considered. An alternative that the authors present in this paper is for the case in which a correlated Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA) model exists for the vehicle being considered 1. A great time savings is realized when the same acoustical behavior information about the vehicle can be extracted by running analytical experiments in the SEA model. The authors assert that even if an SEA model must be developed from scratch and correlated, this approach is preferable over the experimental approach.
Once developed, an interactive design tool of the type being discussed has ongoing benefit to product development engineers by giving them a handy way to asses future design changes. If sound insulation components are later sacrificed in the interest of reducing vehicle costs or weight, the model can accurately portray the implication of the changes on sound levels in the vehicle. A case study is presented that demonstrates the use of this tool and its accuracy.
CitationWentzel, R. and Aubert, A., "An Interactive Approach to the Design of an Acoustically Balanced Vehicle Sound Package," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-2314, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-2314.
- Lyon, Richard H. DeJong, Richard G. Theory and Application of Statistical Energy Analysis 2nd RH Lyon Corp. 1998
- Ver, Istvan L. “Determination of Overall Levels from Band Levels” Noise and Vibration Control Engineering, Principles and Applications Baranek L. L. Ver I. L. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1992 22 24
- “Comet Trim” Comet Technology Corporation Raveendra Ravi
- Society of Automotive Engineers Recommended Practice J1400 “Laboratory Measurement of the Airborne- Sound Barrier Performance of Automotive Materials and Assemblies”
- Wentzel, R. E. Saha, P. “Empirically Predicting the Sound Transmission Loss of Double-Wall Sound Barrier Assemblies” SAE Noise and Vibration Conference Proceedings 1995
- Wentzel, R. E. Van Buskirk, J. “A Dissipative Approach to Vehicle Sound Abatement” SAE Noise and Vibration Conference Proceedings 1999
- DeJong, R. G. “A Study of Vehicle Interior Noise Using Statistical Energy Analysis” SAE Paper # 850960 1985
- Moeller, M. J. Powell, R. E. “Review of Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA) Applied to the Automotive Industry 1985 to 1997” Noise-Con 98
- Onsay, T. Akanda, A. Goetchius, G. “Transmission of Structure-Borne Tire/Road Noise in a Mid-Size Car: Statistical Energy Analysis” Noise-Con 1998
- Wang, D. Goetchius, G. Onsay, T. “Validation of SEA Model for a Minivan: Use of Ideal Air- and Structure-Borne Sources” SAE Paper # 1999-01-1697 1999