This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Effect of Switch-Loading Fuels on Fuel-Wetted Elastomers
Technical Paper
2007-01-1453
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The Office of the Secretary of the Defense (OSD), Advanced Systems and Concepts, established the OSD Assured Fuels Initiative, which aims to spark commercial production of clean fuels made from U.S. energy sources for use by the U.S. Military. The Department of Defense (DoD) will provide the “spark” by developing the fuel specifications needed, demonstrating and qualifying the use of these fuels in tactical ground vehicles, aircraft, and ships, and transitioning to the full-time use of these fuels in their fleets operating in the U.S. One such clean fuel, Fischer-Tropsch (FT) synthetic fuel, made using low-temperature FT technology, contains no aromatic compounds. This lack of aromatics, along with the lack of sulfur, are the key differences between a FT kerosene-based fuel and the petroleum-derived JP-8/JP-5 kerosene-based fuel that is the predominate bulk fuel used by the military's air, ground, and marine fleets. [1, 2]1 A series of experiments were done to determine effects to the fuel-wetted elastomers typically found in sealing applications throughout various fuel distribution systems of DoD equipment, to switching between fuel containing aromatics to fuel with no aromatics, a.k.a. “switch-loading”. One grade of nitrile studied exhibited large dimensional swings, as much as 8% volume change, upon fuel switch-loading. Such dimensional change presents potential for fuel leakage around the seals; this is especially true for older O-rings or gaskets that have taken a compression set. When transitioning to the use of FT fuels in DoD fleets, this risk of fuel leakage can be mitigated through the use of blends of FT kerosene with JP-8 or through identifying susceptible sealing applications and replacing the elastomer components therein with new components and/or components made of less affected, more suitable elastomers.
Recommended Content
Authors
- Patsy A. Muzzell - U.S. Army RDECOM - Tank Automotive Research, Development, and Engineering Center
- Brian J. McKay - U.S. Army RDECOM - Tank Automotive Research, Development, and Engineering Center
- Eric R. Sattler - U.S. Army RDECOM - Tank Automotive Research, Development, and Engineering Center
- Leo L. Stavinoha - Stavinoha Enterprises
- Ruben A. Alvarez - Southwest Research Institute™
Topic
Citation
Muzzell, P., McKay, B., Sattler, E., Stavinoha, L. et al., "The Effect of Switch-Loading Fuels on Fuel-Wetted Elastomers," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-1453, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-1453.Also In
References
- Lamprecht, D. Roets, P. “Sasol Slurry Phase Distillate™ Semi-Synthetic Aviation Turbine Fuel” Prepr. Pap.-Am. Chem. Soc., Div. Pet. Chem. 2004 49 4 426 430
- Muzzell, P. Freerks, R. Baltrus, J. Link, D. “Composition of Syntroleum S-5 and Conformance to JP-5 Specification” Prepr. Pap.-Am. Chem. Soc., Div. Pet. Chem. 2004 49 4 411 413
- DoD Management Policy for Energy Commodities and Related Services 04 12 2004
- Russell, J. Cuellar J. Jr. Tyler, J. Erwin, J. Knutson, W. Alvarez, R. et al. “Development of Accelerated Fuel-Engines Qualification Procedures Methodology, Volume I” U.S. Army Fuels and Lubricants Research Laboratory (Southwest Research Institute) December 1981
- Moses, C. Callahan, J. Cuellar J. Jr. Dodge, L. Likos, W. Naegeli, D. Valtierra, M. “An Alternate Test Procedure to Qualify Fuels for Navy Aircraft-Phase II” Southwest Research Institute Southwest Research Institute for Naval Air Propulsion Center August 1984
- Muzzell, P. Stavinoha, L. Chapin, R. Villahermosa, L. McKay, B. “Synthetic JP-5 Aviation Turbine Fuel Elastomer Compatibility” TARDEC Report No. 13978 November 2003
- Military Specification “Turbine Fuel, Aviation, Grades JP-4, JP-5, and JP-5/JP-8 ST” January 2004
- Military Specification “Turbine Fuels, Aviation, Kerosene Types, NATO F-34 (JP-8), NATO F-35, and JP-8+100” 1 April 1999
- Walls, M. Montemayor, A. Stavinoha, L. Dobbs, H. Williams, J. “Fuel Cell Introduction into a Class 8 Truck” SAE Paper No. 2003-01-3410 October 2003
- ASTM International “Standard Specification for Diesel Fuel Oils” 06 01 2005 July 2005
- Frame, E.A. Marbach, H.W. Jr. Childress, K.H. Yost, D.M. Westbrook, S.R. “Operability and Compatibility Characteristics of Advanced Technology Diesel Fuels” SwRI Project No. 03-02476 Southwest Research Institute January 2002
- Muzzell, P. Stavinoha, L. Chapin, R. “Synthetic Fischer-Tropsch (FT) JP-5/JP-8 Aviation Turbine Fuel Elastomer Compatibility” TARDEC Report No. 15043 February 2005
- ASTM International Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Section Five, Petroleum Products, Lubricants, and Fossil Fuels 2003
- Graham, J. Striebich, R. Minus, D. Harrison W. III “The Swelling of Selected O-Ring Materials in Jet Propulsion and Fischer-Tropsch Fuels” Preprint Paper-American Chemical Society, Division of Petroleum Chemistry 2004 49 3&4
- Muzzell, P. Stavinoha, L. Sattler, E. Terry, A. Villahermosa, L. “Elastomer Impact When Switch-Loading Synthetic Fuel Blends and Petroleum Fuels” TARDEC Report No. 16028 July 2006
- AFM Incorporated www.afmusa.com
- Technical Report CRC Project No. AVFL-2a “Impact of Biodiesel on Fuel System Component Durability” Terry B. Research Council and National Renewable Energy Laboratory September 2005
- Early Warning “Lift Pump Leakage Due to Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel Cummins, Inc. August 2005
- Peckham, J. “Valero, Chevron Expanding CARB-like ULSD in Texas; New ‘Boutique’ Fuel - Ultra-Low Sulfur Diesel” Diesel Fuel News February 17 2003
- Technical Bulletin FTB-2-1 “Fuel Leaks from Seals of Vehicles Using Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel” Chevron Products Company August 2005
- Peckham, J. “BP Responds to ULSD Diesel Fuel Leak Claims in Australia” Diesel Fuel News February 5 2001
- Leisenring, R. “Past Experiences with Fuel Pump Failures” Philadelphia Diesel Difference Working Group 2 14 2005 www.cleanair.org
- DuPont Performance Elastomers www.dupontelastomers.com
- New Zealand Ministry of Economic Development Shell, Caltex, The New Zealand Refining Co., Motor Trade Association, Ministry of Transport, Association of Australasian Diesel Specialists, Mobil, and BP “Summary of the Technical Focus Group Meeting on Seal Failure Related to the Introduction of Lower Sulfur Diesel” April 29 2003 www.med.govt.nz
- Military Field Manual “Military Petroleum Pipeline Systems” Headquarters, Department of Army August 1994
- Military Technical Manual “Tactical Petroleum Terminal, Model TPT-1” Headquarters, Department of Army April 1995
- Military Technical Manual “Fuel Pumping Assembly, Diesel Engine Driven, Wheel Mounted, 350 Gallons Per Minute (GPM)” Headquarters, Department of Army August 1984
- Military Technical Manual “Pumping Assembly for Advanced Aviation Forward Area Refueling System (AAFARS)” Headquarters, Department of Army March 1999
- Military Technical Manual “Hoseline Outfit, Fuel Handling, 4-inch Diameter” Headquarters, Department of Army May 1995
- Military Field Manual “Concepts and Equipment of Petroleum Operations” Headquarters, Department of Army” April 1998
- Military Technical Manual “Filter/Separator Replacement” Department of Army December 2003
- Military Specification, Revision Level F “Filter/Separators, Liquid Fuel” 23 September 1998
- Military Specification, Revision Level C “Tank, Fuel Crash-Resistant, Ballistic-Tolerant, Aircraft” January 2002
- Cook, R. 1974 Washington, DC
- San Miguel, A. 1978 Washington, DC
- Muzzell, P. Sattler, E. Terry, R. McKay, B. Freerks, R. Stavinoha, L. “Properties of Fischer-Tropsch (FT) Blends for Use in Military Equipment” SAE Paper No. 2006-01-0702 April 2006