This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Trends in Technical Efficiency Trade-Offs for the U.S. Light Vehicle Fleet
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 16, 2007 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Technology change can yield some combination of changes in fuel economy, performance, size, or other characteristics that influence the fleetwide fuel consumption. Thus, engineering progress can be manifest in multiple ways, reflected in the view that technical efficiency may improve even when fuel economy does not. This analysis quantifies underlying technical efficiency gains that reflect trade-offs between fuel economy and other attributes of light vehicles.
Prior analyses yielded estimates of technical efficiency trends ranging from 1% per year to nearly 4% per year. Few analyses revealed consistent trends; most identify periods when progress was made at different rates. Using fleetwide (aggregate) data for U.S. light vehicles, exploratory data analysis and correlation techniques were applied to examine trends in energy-related variables. Individual trends for all variables are uneven over time. A ton-mile per gallon metric shows some consistency, but still leaves significant variation unexplained.
Good correlations were found using a Performance Size-Fuel economy Index (PSFI), defined as a product of these three factors. PSFI appears quite linear over 1977-2005, with a straight line explaining 99% of the variation for cars and 97% of the variation for light trucks. The resulting correlations yield estimates for trade-offs among fleetwide fuel economy, performance, and size. The results show generally stronger technical efficiency improvement rates over the past 25 years than previous analyses. The results also suggest diminishing growth rates for fuel economy at higher absolute levels of size and performance. Relative to a 1977 baseline, technical efficiency as measured by PSFI shows an average gain of 5.3% per year for cars and 3.1% per year for light trucks. Linear PSFI trends are found to be consistent with engine specific power trends observed over the period of analysis.
CitationAn, F. and DeCicco, J., "Trends in Technical Efficiency Trade-Offs for the U.S. Light Vehicle Fleet," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-1325, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-1325.
- EIA 1995 Measuring Energy Efficiency in the United States: A Beginning Washington, DC U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration October
- NRC 2002 Effectiveness and Impact of Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) Standards National Research Council Washington, DC National Academy Press
- Heavenrich, R.M. 2005 Light-Duty Automotive Technology and Fuel Economy Trends 1975 through 2005 Ann Arbor, MI U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Transportation and Air Quality, Advanced Technology Division July
- DOE 1989 Energy Conservation Trends: Understanding the Factors that Affect Conservation Gains in the U.S. Economy U.S. Department of Energy Washington, DC September
- DOE 1995 Energy Conservation Trends: Understanding the Factors Affecting Conservation Gains and Their Implications for Policy Development Washington, DC U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Policy April
- Greene, D.L. Fan Y. 1994 Transportation Energy Efficiency Trends 1972-1992 Oak Ridge, TN Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Center for Transportation Analysis December
- Lutsey, N. Sperling D. 2005 Energy Efficiency, Fuel Economy, and Policy Implications TRB Paper No. 05-0234 Washington, DC Transportation Research Board
- IEEP 2005 Service contract to carry out economic analysis and business impact assessment of CO 2 emissions reduction measures in the automotive sector Brussels Institute for European Environmental Policy June
- Davis S. Diegel S. 2004 Transportation Energy Data Book 24 Oak Ridge, TN Oak Ridge National Laboratory December