Fuel Tank and Charcoal Canister Fire Hazards during EVAP System Leak Testing
Published April 16, 2007 by SAE International in United States
Annotation of this paper is available
The combination of on-board diagnostics and evaporative emission control (EVAP) systems has led to a growing need to identify and repair leaks in automotive EVAP systems. The normal leakfinding method involves purging the system with a smoke fluid, usually air or nitrogen containing an oil aerosol and then looking for a visual indication of the leak. The purge flow used to distribute smoke through the system displaces substantial amounts of fuel vapor from the tank vapor space and can also raise the oxygen level inside the fuel system. If any ignition source is present, the formation of flammable mixtures both inside and outside the vehicle systems can lead to a flash fire hazard associated with leak finding procedures. Currently available fire statistics (such as NFPA) are not sufficiently detailed to attribute service shop fires to specific testing procedures. However, concern over anecdotal reports of flash fires has led to a study of flammable mixture formation during evap system testing. This paper describes a set of experimental and modeling studies aimed at better understanding fuel vapor behavior and associated fire hazards of EVAP system leak testing.
The first phase of the project involved experimental measurement and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) modeling of fuel vapour / air mixture distribution in a tank vapour space with an imposed flow rate typical of leak testing equipment. Initial fuel vapor concentrations, (and thus the quantity of vapor expelled during the initial purge), depend strongly on fuel volatility and temperature. In addition, purge flow rates in the vicinity of 10 litres/minute can produce substantial quantities of flammable mixture inside the fuel system. The quantity of purged vapor available for an external flash fire is highest for high volatility gasoline while the quantity of flammable mixture formed inside the fuel system tends to be highest for low volatility gasoline.
The second phase of the project examined charcoal canister behavior with typical leak test flows imposed through the EVAP system. A basic model of canister behavior was established by measuring butane working capacity and gasoline working capacity under standard test conditions. Further experimental tests examined the fuel vapour concentrations leaving a pre-loaded charcoal canister with an imposed purge flow. Test results showed substantial release rates of fuel-rich gasoline vapor during early stages of testing and a long period of flammable vapor emission with prolonged testing. Ignition tests confirmed the flammability and flame characteristics of the mixture leaving the canister.
Recommended procedures to limit the flammable mixtures formed during leak-testing are discussed in the paper.
CitationFrank, K. and Checkel, D., "Fuel Tank and Charcoal Canister Fire Hazards during EVAP System Leak Testing," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-1235, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-1235.
- “Competitive product comparison. Retrieved June 15, 2006, from http://www.redlinedetection.com/DOCS - Competitive Product Comparison.pdf.
- Guide on federal and state summer R.V.P. standards for conventional gasoline only. Technical report, U. S. Environmental Protection Agency 420-B-05-012, 2005.
- Itakura H., Kato T., and Naoya K.. “Analysis of the HC behavior in the air intake system while vehicle is parked”. SAE Paper No. 2004-01-0141, 2004.
- Frank K. M.. Flammability hazards of fuel system leak testing. MSc Thesis, University of Alberta, 2006.
- Griffith J. R. Jr, Machado C. R., and Bendele B. B.. “Comparative evaluation of automotive fuel tanks in general accordance with ECE R34.01, annex 5 section 5.0 ‘resistance to fire’”. SAE Paper No. 2005-01-1561, 2005.
- Siegl W. O., Guenther M. T., and Henney T.. “Identifying sources of evaporative emissions - using hydrocarbon profiles to identify emission sources”. SAE Paper No. 2000-01-1139, 2000.
- Greenfield M. L. and Rossi Giuseppe. “Vapor and liquid composition differences resulting from fuel evaporation”. SAE Paper No. 1999-01-0377, 1999.
- Marshall W. F. and Schoonveld G. A.. “Vapor space flammability of automobile tanks containing low RVP gasolines”. SAE Paper No. 902096, 1990.
- Williams R. S. and Clontz C. R.. Impact and control of canister bleed emissions. SAE Paper No. 2001-01-0733, 2001.
- Johnson T. V.. Gasoline vehicle emissions - SAE 1999 in review. SAE Paper No. 2000-01-0855, 2000.
- Zabetakis M. G.. “Flammability characteristics of combustible gases and vapors”. U.S. Bureau of Mines Bulletin 627, 1965.