This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Theoretical Analysis of a Method of Computing Dynamic Roof Crush During Rollovers
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 16, 2007 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A method of computing dynamic roof crush in rollover accidents has been proposed (Bidez, et al., 2005; Cochran et al., 2005). The method used data obtained from accelerometers mounted to the roof rails of sport utility vehicles, along with other measurements, to compute the instantaneous deformation of the roof rails during dolly rollover crash tests.
We examined the feasibility and practicality of this methodology in three ways. First, the theoretical derivation was examined. Errors appeared to have been made in deriving and/or interpreting the equations used to compute instantaneous roof crush. Next, a three-dimensional dynamic rollover simulation program was run to produce ideal acceleration data (Yamaguchi et al., 2006, 2005). Using these data, the equations in original, uncorrected form predicted dynamic roof deformations when none existed. When the equations were corrected, the simulation data yielded proper roof positions and no roof deformations. Finally, a dolly rollover test was conducted to generate real-world accelerometer data. The vehicle was heavily braced internally to avoid producing significant roof crush. Vibrational “noise” present in the real-world accelerometer data caused a large amount of calculational error in the dynamic roof crush calculations. Sensor positioning and angular alignment errors also may have contributed. These results indicate that the method of computing dynamic roof crush from accelerometer data is theoretically feasible when correct equations and ideal data are used, but is impractical using measured real world accelerometer and angular rate sensor data.
- Gary T. Yamaguchi - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
- Blake M. Ashby - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
- Peter A. Luepke - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
- Tara L.A. Moore - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
- Robert T. Bove - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
- Catherine Ford Corrigan - Exponent Failure Analysis Associates
CitationYamaguchi, G., Ashby, B., Luepke, P., Moore, T. et al., "Theoretical Analysis of a Method of Computing Dynamic Roof Crush During Rollovers," SAE Technical Paper 2007-01-0366, 2007, https://doi.org/10.4271/2007-01-0366.
Safety: Rear Impact, Rollover, Side Impact, Crashworthiness, Air Bags and Bumper Systems
Number: SP-2117; Published: 2007-04-16
Number: SP-2117; Published: 2007-04-16
- Bahling G.S. Bundorf R.T. Moffatt E.A. Orlowski K.F. Stocke J.E. 1990 “Rollover and drop tests – The influence of roof strength on injury mechanics using belted dummies,” SAE 902314
- Bidez M.W. Cochran J.E. King D. “Appendix”, in “Roof Crush as a Source of Injury in Rollover Crashes – - An Independent Analysis of Autoliv SUV Rollover Tests B190043, B190042, B180220, B180219,” March 30 2005 www.citizen.org/autosafety/rollover/crashwrth_/
- Bidez M.W. Cochran J.E. King D. 2005 Letter to NHTSA Re: Supplemental Comments to NHTSA Request for Comments, December 31
- Cochran J.E. Bidez M.W. King D. 2005 “A Method to Evaluate Dynamic vs. Residual Roof Rail Deformation in Dolly Rollover Tests,” The 19 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV), Washington, DC June 6-9
- Department of Transportation Docket No. NHTSA-1999-5572; Notice 2, Request for Comments 1999
- Department of Transportation Docket No. NHTSA-2005-22143; Notice of Proposed Rulemaking 2005.
- Digges K. Malliaris A.C. 1998 “Crashworthiness Safety Features in Rollover Crashes,” SAE 982296
- Kane T.R. Levinson D.A. 1985 Dynamics: Theory and Applications McGraw-Hill, New York, NY
- Moffatt E.A. Cooper E.R. Orlowski K.F. Marth D.R. Croteau J.J. Carter J.W. 2003 “Matched pair rollover impacts of rollcaged and production roof cars using the Controlled Rollover Impact System (CRIS),” SAE 2003-01-0172
- Moffatt E.A. Padmanban J. 1995 “The Relationship Between Vehicle Roof Strength and Occupant Injury in Rollover Crash Data, 39 th Annual Proceedings AAAM
- Orlowski K.F. Bundorf R.T. Moffatt E.A. 1985 “Rollover crash tests – The influence of roof strength on injury mechanics,” SAE 851734
- Padmanaban J. Moffatt E.A. Marth D.R. 2005 “Factors influencing the likelihood of fatality and serious/Fatal injury in single-vehicle rollover crashes,” SAE 2005-01-0944
- Parker D.D. Ray R.M. Moore T.L.A. Keefer R.E. 2007 “Rollover Severity and Occupant Protection—A Review of NASS/CDS Data,” SAE 2007-01-0676
- Vondale J.P. 2005 Letter to NHTSA Re: Ford Motor Company Supplemental Comments to NHTSA Request for Comments, October 19
- Yamaguchi G.T. 2006 Dynamic Modeling of Musculoskeletal Motion – A Vectorized Approach for Biomechanical Analysis in Three Dimensions. Springer, New York, NY
- Yamaguchi G.T. Richards D. Larson R.E. Carhart M.R. Cargill R.S. Lai W. Corrigan C.F. 2005 “Development of a Computational Method to Predict Occupant Motions during Steering-Induced Rollovers,” SAE 2005-01-0300
- Yamaguchi G.T. Ashby B. Lai W. Carhart M.R. Richards D. Corrigan C.F. 2006 “Occupant Mechanics in Rollover Simulations of High and Low Aspect Ratio Vehicles,” SAE 2006-01-0451