This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Investigation of Intake Concepts for a Formula SAE Four-Cylinder Engine Using 1D/3D (Ricardo WAVE-VECTIS) Coupled Modeling Techniques
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published December 05, 2006 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Many variations of intake designs currently exist in Formula SAE. This paper sets out to investigate if one intake design provides improved performance over another and to gain further insight into the nature of the airflow within a Formula SAE intake.
Intake designs are first classified by physical layout. Then Ricardo's software WAVE (1D) and VECTIS (3D) are used to investigate the performance of the three most common intake concepts as well as two variations of the base concepts for a naturally aspirated four-cylinder Formula SAE engine. Each intake concept is modeled across an RPM range using a WAVE simulation. Simulations are performed at three different RPM using WAVE and VECTIS coupled at the intake inlet and runner exits of each intake concept. A 3D simplified CAD geometry of each intake is used for the VECTIS part of the simulation. An unsteady flow analysis was used instead of a steady flow analysis due to the nature of the flow within an engine.
Simplifying assumptions and the use of computational grid convergence analysis and the comparison of 1D and 1D/3D simulations are described. Evaluations of intake performance are also discussed. Intake performance is determined by several factors: cylinder-to-cylinder volumetric efficiency, time of choked flow in the restrictor, total pressure loss along the restrictor, sound spectrum frequency content, and physical packaging characteristics. In addition, intake manifold and restrictor interaction is discussed as well as visualization of adverse flow conditions. Packaging considerations such as the location of flow bends for minimum pressure loss are also discussed.
The authors found that what they define as the Conical-Spline Intake Concept offers the best performance. This intake concept offers an order of magnitude improvement in the variation of cylinder-to-cylinder volumetric efficiency with consequent improvements in ease of tuning and acoustic noise emission control. In addition, it has the lowest total pressure drop along the diffuser of all the concepts evaluated.
CitationClaywell, M., Horkheimer, D., and Stockburger, G., "Investigation of Intake Concepts for a Formula SAE Four-Cylinder Engine Using 1D/3D (Ricardo WAVE-VECTIS) Coupled Modeling Techniques," SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-3652, 2006, https://doi.org/10.4271/2006-01-3652.
- Pogorevc, P. Kegl, B. “Intake System Design Procedures for Engines with Special Requirements” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering 220 2 2006 241 252
- Maynes, B. D. J. Kee, R. J. Kenny, R. G. Fleck, R. Mackey, D. O. Foley, L. “Prediction of Formula 1 Engine and Airbox Performance using Coupled Virtual 4-Stroke and CFD Simulations” SAE Paper 2002-01-3318
- Riegler, U. G. Bargende, M. “Direct Coupled 1D/3D-CFD-Computation (GT-Power/Star-CD) of the Flow in the Switch-Over Intake System of an 8-Cylinder SI Engine with External Exhaust Gas Recirculation” SAE Paper 2002-01-0901
- Strauss, S. T. Schindler, P. “Code Coupling, a New Approach to Enhance CFD Analysis of Engines” SAE Paper 2000-01-0660
- Borghi, M. Mattarelli, E. Montrosi, L. “Integration of 3D-CFD and Engine Cycle Simulation: Application to An Intake Plenum” SAE Paper 2001-01-2512
- Laimböck, F. J. Meister, G. Garlic, S. “CFD Application in Compact Engine Development” SAE Paper 982016
- Ling, J. Tun, L. T. Y. “CFD Analysis of Non-Symmetric Intake Manifold for Formula SAE Car” SAE Paper 2006-01-1976
- Jawad, B. A. Hoste, P. J. Johnson, B. E. “Formula SAE Dual Plenum Induction System Design” SAE Paper 2002-01-0457
- Society of Automotive Engineers “2006 Formula SAE Rules” http://www.sae.org/students/fsaerules.pdf 31 May 2006
- Blair, G. P. Mackey, D. O. “Racing Engine Design Options Investigated by Engine Simulation” SAE Paper 2000-01-3546
- Ioannou, M. Gurney, D. Downing, J. “The Application of Design of Experiments 1D Simulation to Create a Rapid Concept Optimization Tool for I4 Engines” SAE Paper 2005-01-0226
- Laney, B. C. Computational Gasdynamics Cambidge, UK Cambridge University Press 1998
- Ricardo Software “WAVE 7.1 User's Manual” 2006
- Ricardo Software “VECTIS 3.8 User's Manual” 2006
- Launder, B. E. Spalding, D. B. “The Numerical Computation of Turbulent Flow” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering 1974 3 269 289
- Casey, M. Wintergerste, T. ERCOFTAC Special Interest Group “Quality and Trust in Industrial CFD” Best Practice Guidelines Brussels, Belgium European Research Community on Flow, Turbulence and Combustion 2000
- Chen, A. Lee, K. C. Yianneskis, M. Ganti, G. “Velocity Characteristics of Steady Flow through a Straight Generic Inlet Port” International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids 21 571 590
- Guizzetti, M. Colombo, T. “Combined WAVE-VECTIS Simulation of an Intake Manifold of V6 PFI Gasoline Engine” http://www.ricardo.com/download/pdf/vectis_combined_wave_vectis.pdf 31 May 2006
- Roache, P. J. “Error Bars for CFD” AIAA 2003 408
- Roache, P. J. Verification and Validation in Computational Science and Engineering Albuquerque, NM Hermosa Publishers 1998
- Roy, C. J. “Grid Convergence Error Analysis For Mixed-Order Numerical Schemes” AIAA 2001 2606
- Stern, F. Wilson, R. V. Coleman, H. W. Paterson, E. G. “Verification and Validation of CFD Simulations” Iowa Institute of Hydraulic Research Report No. 407 1999
- Simpson, R. L. “Two-Dimensional Turbulent Separated Flow” AGARDograph 287 1 1985
- Miller, D. S. Internal Flow Systems: Design and Performance Prediction Houston, TX Gulf Publishing Company 1990
- Ward Smith, A. J. Pressure Losses in Ducted Flows Butterworth 1971
- Wyatt, D. D. “Analysis of Errors Introduced By Several Methods of Weighting Non-Uniform Duct Flow” 1955
- Pianko, M. Wazelt, F. Suitable Averaging Techniques in Non-Uniform Internal Flow Propulsion and Energetics Panel Working Group 14 1983
- Kobayashi, T. Arase, K. “Intake System Optimization by Intake Loss Coefficient Method” SAE Paper 1999-01-3337
- Taylor W. III, Leylek, J. H., Sommer, R. G. Jain, S. K. “IC Engine Intake Region Design Modification for Loss Reduction Based on CFD Methods” SAE Paper 981026
- Pan, W. Cui, Y. Leylek, J. H. Sommer, R. G. Jain, S. K. “A CFD Study of Losses in a Straight-Six Diesel Engine” SAE Paper 1999-01-0230