This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Weldability Improvement Using Coated Electrodes for RSW of HDG Steel
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published April 03, 2006 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The increased use of zinc coatings on steels has led to a decrease in their weldability. Weld current and time need to be increased in order to achieve sound welds on these materials compared to uncoated steels, and electrode tip life suffers greatly due to rapid alloying and degradation. In this work, typical uncoated Class II electrodes were tested along with a TiC metal matrix composite (MMC) coated electrode. Tests were conducted to study the weldability and process of nugget formation for both electrodes on HDG (hot dipped galvanized) HSLA (high strength low alloys) steels. Current and time ranges were constructed for both types of electrodes by varying either the weld current or weld time while holding all other parameters constant. Analysis of weld microstructures was conducted on cross-sectioned welds using SEM (scanning electron microscopy). Using the coated electrodes reduced weld current and times needed to form MWS (minimum weld size) on the coated steels. Current and time ranges forming satisfactory nuggets were also increased, improving the weldability of the steels. A notable cooling effect was found at the EW (electrode workpiece) interface of the steel sheet and was confirmed by software modeling to be due to rapid cooling through the electrode. The coated electrode weld did not exhibit the cooling artifact, which was believed to be due to the thermal effects of the TiC MMC coating.
The lower weld current and time needed to form welds of MWS when using the coated electrodes as well as the increase in the usable current and time range indicate an increase in the weldability of the coated electrodes when welding HDG material. This notable improvement was caused by the presence of the TiC MMC electrode coating increasing the interfacial resistance as well as acting as a thermal barrier preventing the rapid extraction of heat from the faying interface through the electrodes leading to larger weld sizes at identical weld parameters than the uncoated electrodes.
CitationChan, K., Scotchmer, N., Zhao, J., and Zhou, Y., "Weldability Improvement Using Coated Electrodes for RSW of HDG Steel," SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-0092, 2006, https://doi.org/10.4271/2006-01-0092.
Welding & Joining & Fastening & Friction Stir Welding
Number: SP-2034; Published: 2006-04-03
Number: SP-2034; Published: 2006-04-03
- RWMA Handbook Fourth Edition 1989
- Howe, P. Kelly, S. C. “A Comparison of the Resistance Spot Weldability of Bare, Hot-Dipped, Galvannealed, and Electrogalvanized DQSK Sheet Steels” International Congress and Exposition, Detroit Michigan February 29–March 4 1988
- Parker, J. D. Williams, N. T. Holliday, R. J. “Mechanisms of electrode degradation when spot welding coated steels” Science and Technology of Welding and Joining 1998 3 No. 2 65 74
- Holliday R. Parker J. D. Williams N. T. “Relative contribution of electrode tip growth mechanism in spot welding zinc coated steels” Welding in the World 37 No. 4 186 193 1996
- Holliday R. Parker J. D. Williams N. T. “Electrode deformation when spot welding coated steels” Welding in the World 35 No. 3 160 164 1995
- Ikeda, R. Yasuda, K. Hashiguchi, K. Okita, T. Yahaba, T. “Effect of Electrode Configuration on Electrode Life in Resistance Spot Welding of Galvannealed Steel and Aluminum Alloy For Car Body Sheets” IBEC 1995, Advanced Technologies and Proceedings 144 151
- Saito T. Takahashi Y. Nishi T. “Electrode Tip Life in Resistance Spot Welding of Zinc and Zinc Alloy Coated Sheet Steels” April 1988 24 30
- Friedman L. M. McCauley, R. B. “Influence of Metallurgical Characteristics on Resistance welding of Galvanized steel” Welding Journal, Supplement Oct. 1969 454s 462s
- Tanaka, Y. Sakaguchi, M. Shirasawa, H. Miyahara M. Nomura, S. “Electrode Life in resistance spot welding of zinc plated sheets” Int. J. of Materials and Product Tech 2 no. 1 1987 64 74
- Natale, T.V. “A review of the resistance spot welding behaviour of galvanized steels” Sheet Metal Welding conference III 1988 Paper No. 1
- Howe, P. “Resistance Spot Weldability and Electrode Wear Mechanisms of ZnNi EGfi Sheet Steel” SAE Technical Paper Series, 910192 1991
- Lane, C. T. Sorensen, C. D. Hunter, G. B. Gedeon, S. A. Eagar, T. W. “Cinematography of Resistance Spot Welding of Galvanized Steel Sheet” Welding Journal, Supplement September 1987 260s 265s
- Holliday R. Parker J. D. Williams N. T. “Factors affecting deformation of electrodes when resistance spot welding coated steels” Key Engineering Materials 99–100 1995 95 102
- Dong, S. Zhou, Y. “Effects of TiC Composite Coating on Electrode Degradation in Microresistance Welding of Nickel-Plated Steel” Metal. And Materials Trans. A 34A July 2003 1501 1511
- Huys Industries Limited < http://www.huysindustries.com/ > 2004
- Gedeon S. A. Eagar, T. W. “Resistance Spot Welding of Galvanized Steel: Part I. Material Variations and Process Modifications” Metallurgical Transactions B 17B Dec. 1986 879 885
- Gedeon S. A. Eagar, T. W. “Resistance Spot Welding of Galvanized Steel: Part II. Mechanisms of Spot Weld Nugget Formation” Metallurgical Transactions B 17B Dec. 1986 887 901
- Babu, S.S. Santella, M. L. Peterson, W. “Modeling Resistance Spot Welding Electrode Life” Oak Ridge National Laboratory 2000
- Finlay, M. R. “Resistance Spot Welding of Metallic Coated Steels and PVD Coated Electrodes” CRC Australia and WTIA 1996
- “Recommended practices for test methods for evaluating the resistance spot welding behaviour of automotive sheet steel materials” AWS/SAE 1997
- Carslaw H.S. J.C. Jaeger “Conduction of Heat in Solids” Oxford University Press London second edition 1959
- Tslaf, A. “Combined Properties of Conductors” Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company New York 1981
- Chan, K. R. Ding, Y.