This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Modeling of Fuel Consumption for Heavy-Duty Trucks and the Impact of Tire Rolling Resistance
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 01, 2005 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The cost of fuel for commercial trucks is second only to labor in the total vehicle operating costs. Therefore, technologies that reduce fuel consumption can have a significant impact on the bottom line for both trucking fleets and owner/operators. Quantifying the fuel savings associated with different technologies, however, is complicated by many factors, and short-term testing often cannot adequately quantify small changes in fuel consumption that, over time, can add up to substantial cost savings on a vehicle. For example, fuel economy gains of less than one percent may not be reliably measurable using fuel tests, and variable environmental and use factors can cast some doubt on the appropriateness of short-term testing. Nonetheless, with today's fuel prices, each percent improvement in fuel economy for heavy duty trucks results in annual savings of about $335 per vehicle in fuel costs, based on 100,000 miles (160,000 km) annual vehicle mileage, 6.5 mpg (36.2 L/100km) fuel economy and a fuel price of $2.20/gallon. It is therefore quite worthwhile to identify technologies that can provide even modest fuel savings and to quantify the gains.
As an alternative to conducting fuel tests, fuel savings can be quantified through detailed simulation of a vehicle's performance using a physics-based model that incorporates performance maps of the drivetrain components and all other elements of the vehicle responsible for energy losses. This paper describes the development of a model for heavy-duty trucks using AVL-CRUISE software. This model can be used to predict fuel consumption when a vehicle is operated following any specified driving cycle, and the fuel savings potential of specific technologies can be evaluated when the energy loss characteristics of the technology are available. Results of testing are presented that were used to validate the model results. Instantaneous fuel flow measurements during various driving cycles show excellent agreement with the model predictions.
The effect of tire rolling resistance on vehicle fuel consumption was investigated using the model developed. Based on these results, fuel savings of 1.40 to 1.62 L/100km can be expected per kg/T reduction in the average rolling resistance coefficient for this vehicle, depending on the cycle evaluated. This equates to fuel savings of 600 to 690 gallons of diesel for each 100,000 miles driven, times the reduction in the coefficient of rolling resistance expressed in kg/ton.
CitationLaClair, T. and Truemner, R., "Modeling of Fuel Consumption for Heavy-Duty Trucks and the Impact of Tire Rolling Resistance," SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-3550, 2005, https://doi.org/10.4271/2005-01-3550.
Heavy Vehicle Drag Reduction-Overviews, Multiple Trailer-Mounted Devices; Tires, Splash and Spray and Emissions; Full Scale Assessments
Number: SP-1985 ; Published: 2005-11-01
Number: SP-1985 ; Published: 2005-11-01
- Sovran G., Bohn M., Formulae for the Tractive Energy Requirements of Vehicles Driving the EPA Schedules, SAE Technical Paper Series 810184, 1981.
- Feng A., Ross M., “A Model of Fuel Economy and Driving Patterns,” SAE Technical Paper Series 930328, 1993.
- Zub R., Colello R., “Effect of Vehicle Design Parameters on top speed, performance and fuel economy,” SAE Technical Paper Series 800215, 1980.
- Thomas, M., Ross, M., “Development of Second-by-Second Fuel Use and Emissions Models Based on an Early 1990s Composite Car,” SAE Technical Paper Series 971010, 1997.
- An, F., Barth, M. Scora, G., “Impacts of Diverse Driving Cycles on Electric and Hybrid Electric Vehicle Performance,” SAE Technical Paper Series 972646, 1997.
- Conley, J., Taylor, S., “Technological Evaluation of Fuel Efficiency Improvement Concepts to Meet Future Regulatory Requirements in the North American Market,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2002-01-2809, 2002.
- MacBain, J.A., Conover, J.J., Brooker, A.D., “Full Vehicle Simulation for Series Hybrid Vehicles,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2003-01-2301, 2003.
- Cooper C., Meszler D., Brueckner S., “Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Light-Duty Motor Vehicles,” Northeast States Center for a Clean Air Future, 2004.
- Phillips A., Assanis D., Badgley P., “Development and Use of a Vehicle Powertrain Simulation for Fuel Economy and Performance Studies,” SAE Technical Paper Series 900619, 1990.
- Ghojel J., “Development of a Computer Program for the Prediction of Haul Truck Performance,” SAE Technical Paper Series 921745, 1992.
- Olikara C., Steiber J., Shahed S., “Analysis of a Hybrid Powertrain for Heavy Trucks,” SAE Technical Paper Series 952585, 1995.
- Matheson P., Stecki J., “Development and Simulation of a Hydraulic-Hybrid Powertrain for Use in Commercial heavy Vehicles,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2003-01-3370, 2003.
- Zeng X., Qingnian W., Weihua W., Liang C., Analysis and Simulation of Conventional Transit Bus Energy Loss and Hybrid Transit Bus Energy Saving, SAE Technical Paper Series 2005-01-1173, 2005.
- Lax D., Rucker E., Medium and Heavy Duty Truck Fuel Economy and Consumption Trends, SAE Technical Paper Series 810023, 1981.
- Bureau of Transportation Statistics, National Transportation Statistics 2003, March 2004.
- Ehlbeck J., von Mayenberg M., “Increasing Heavy-Duty Truck Fuel Economy,” SAE Technical Paper Series 912662, 1991.
- Schuring, D.J. and Futamura, S., “Rolling Loss of Pneumatic Highway Tires in the Eighties,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, v. 63(3), 315-367, 1990.
- Schuring, D.J., “The Rolling Loss of Pneumatic Tires,” Rubber Chemistry and Technology, v. 53(3), 600-727, 1980.
- Knight R. E., Correlation of Truck Tire Rolling Resistance as Derived from Fuel Economy and Laboratory Tests, SAE Technical Paper Series 821266, 1982.
- Luchini, J.R., “Rolling Resistance Test Methods,” Tire Rolling Resistance, Rubber Division Symposia Vol. 1, Edited by Schuring D.J., Rubber Division, American Chemical Society, Akron, Ohio, 1983.
- Cuddy M., Wipke K., “Analysis of the Fuel Economy Benefit of Drivetrain Hybridization,” SAE Technical Paper Series 970289, 1997.
- Lin, C., Wang, Y., Filipi, Z.S., Louca, L., Peng, H., Assanis, D.N., Stein, J., “Integrated, Feed-Forward Hybrid Electric Vehicle Simulation in Simulink and Its Use for Power Management Studies,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2001-01-1334, 2001.
- Hojo Y., Iwatsuki K., Oba H., Ishikawa K., “Toyota Five-Speed Automatic Transmission with Application of Modern Control Theory,” SAE Technical Paper Series 920610, 1992.
- Samhaber C., Wimmer A., Loibner E., “Modeling of Engine Warm-Up with Integration of Vehicle and Engine Cycle Simulation,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2001-01-1697, 2001.
- Regner G., Loibner E., Krammer J., Walter L., Truemner R., “Analysis of Transient Drive Cycles using CRUISE-BOOST Co-Simulation Techniques,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2002-01-0267, 2002.
- Samhaber C., Wimmer A., Loibner E., Mahmoud K., Regner G., “Analysis of the Vehicle Performance Using Transient Co-simulation Techniques,” JSAE Technical Paper Series 20025354, 2002.
- MacBain J., Conover J., Johnson V., “Co-Simulation of Electrical and Propulsion Systems,” SAE Technical Paper Series 2001-01-2533, 2001.
- ISO International Standard, “Truck and Bus Tyres-Methods of Measuring Rolling Resistance,” ISO 9948, Geneva, 1992.
- Clark, S.K., “Rolling Resistance Forces in Pneumatic Tires,” U.S. Dept. of Transportation, TSC Rep. No. DOT-TSC-76-1, 1976.
- Luchini, J., “Test Surface Curvature Reduction Factor for Truck Tire Rolling Resistance,” SAE Technical Paper Series 821264, 1982.
- Lechner G., Naunheimer H., Automotive Transmissions: Fundamentals, Selection, Design and Application, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1999.
- Kluger M., Long D., “An Overview of Current Automatic, Manual and Continuously Variable Transmission Efficiencies and Their Projected Future Improvements,” SAE Technical Paper Series 1999-01-1259, 1999.
- Greenbaum J., Kluger M., Westmoreland B., “Manual Transmission Efficiency Trends and Characteristics,” SAE Technical Paper Series 942274, 1994.
- AVL CRUISE v2.2 User's Guide
- AVL CRUISE v2.2 Theory Manual
- LaClair, T. “Tire Rolling Resistance” in The Pneumatic Tire, Edited by Walter J. and Gant A., University of Akron. To be published.