This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Effect of Axial Load in the Tibia on the Response of the 90° Flexed Knee to Blunt Impacts with a Deformable Interface
Technical Paper
2004-22-0003
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Lower extremity injuries are a frequent outcome of automotive accidents. While the lower extremity injury criterion is based on fracture of bone, most injuries are of less severity. Recent studies suggest microscopic, occult fractures that have been shown to be precursors of gross bone fractures, may occur in the kneecap (patella) for impacts with rigid and deformable interfaces due to excessive levels of patello-femoral contact pressure. One method of reducing this contact pressure for a 90° flexed knee is to provide a parallel pathway for knee impact loads into the tibial tuberosity. Yet, blunt loads onto the tibial tuberosity can cause posterior drawer motion of the tibia, leading to injury or rupture of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). Recently studies have shown that axial loads in the tibia, which are measured during blunt loading on the knee in typical automobile crashes, can induce anterior drawer motion of the tibia and possibly help unload the PCL. The purpose of the current study was to explore the effect of combined anterior knee loading (AKL) and axial tibia loading (ATL), on response and injury for the 90° flexed human knee.
In repeated impacts with increasing ATL the stiffness of the knee to an AKL impact increased. For a 3 kN AKL, the stiffness of the knee increased approximately 26% when the ATL was increased from 0 kN to 2 kN. For 6 kN and 9 kN AKL, the stiffness was increased approximately 17% and 20%, respectively, when the ATL was increased from 0 kN (uniaxial) to 4 kN (biaxial). The effect, however, was not statistically significant at the 9 kN AKL level. The posterior tibial drawer was shown to increase with increased AKL and decrease with increased levels of ATL at an average of 0.3 mm per kN ATL for both the 3 kN and 6 kN ATL scenarios. For 9 kN AKL this drawer displacement was significantly reduced for biaxial versus uniaxial impacts, from 7.4±1.4 mm to 5.8±0.6 mm, respectively. Additionally, the percentage of the load carried by the tibial tuberosity increased with an ATL. For AKL impacts of 3, 6, and 9 kN, the percentage of load carried by the tibial tuberosity increased from 2.1% (range 0–19%) to 4.9% (0–36%), 2.1% (0–15%) to 6.9% (0–36%), and 8.7% (0–25%) to 12.7% (0–33%), respectively, between uniaxial and biaxial tests. The biaxial loading scenario also resulted in a reduction of the patello-femoral (PF) contact force as the ATL was increased. Ten knee impacts resulted in PCL tears at an average peak load of 12.7±2.4 kN in biaxial impacts (n=5) and 12.0±3.1 kN for uniaxial impacts (n=5). These PCL injured specimens had an average age of 62±11.3 years. The remaining specimens (n=11, 78±12.9 years of age) had bone fractures at approximately 8.9±3.1 kN.
This study showed that combinations of compressive ATL and AKL reduced the PF contact force and had a stiffening effect on the response of the knee impacting a stiff but deformable interface. Furthermore, ATL reduced the posterior drawer of the tibia, which is the current basis for PCL injury in the knee, although it did not reduce the incidence of PCL injury in this study. While the current injury tolerance criterion reflects the vulnerability of the PCL to injury by limiting tibial drawer to 15 mm, the current dummy design does not incorporate the stiffening effect of an ATL that may occur at the same time as knee contact with an instrument panel during a typical automotive crash.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Meyer, E., Sinnott, M., Haut, R., Jayaraman, G. et al., "The Effect of Axial Load in the Tibia on the Response of the 90° Flexed Knee to Blunt Impacts with a Deformable Interface," SAE Technical Paper 2004-22-0003, 2004, https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-22-0003.Also In
References
- Atkinson, P. Haut, R. 1995 Subfracture insult to the human cadaver patellofemoral joint produces occult injury J Orthop Res 13 936 944
- Atkinson, P. Garcia, J. Altiero, N. Haut, R 1997 The influence of impact interface on human knee injury: Implications for instrument panel design and the lower extremity injury criterion Stapp Conf Proc 41 167 180
- Atkinson, P. Newberry, W. Atkinson, T. Haut, R. 1998 A method to increase the sensitive range of pressure sensitive film J Biomech 31 855 859
- Atkinson, P. Benny, J. Sambatur, K. Gudipaty, K. Maripudi, V. Hill, T. 1999 A parametric study of vehicle interior geometry, delta-v, and instrument panel stiffness on knee injury and upper kinetic energy Stapp Conf Proc 43 203 215
- Atkinson, T. Atkinson, P. 2000 Knee injuries in motor vehicle collisions: A study of the National Accident Sampling System database for the years 1979–1995 Accid Anal Prev 32 6 786
- Atkinson, P. Haut, R. 2001 Impact responses of the flexed human knee using a deformable impact interface J Biomech Egr 123 3 205 211
- Banglmaier, R. Dvoracek-Driksna, D. Oniang’o, T. Haut, R. 1999 Axial compressive load response of the 90° flexed human tibiofemoral joint Stapp Conf Proc 43 127 139
- Bealle, D. Johnson, D. 2000 Subchondral contusion of the knee caused by axial loading from dashboard impact J Southern Orthop Assoc 9 1 13 18
- Bedewi PG, Diggs KH. 1999 Investigating ankle injury mechanisms in offset frontalcollisions utilizing computational modeling and case study data Stapp Car Crash Conf 42 217 242
- Blincoe, L. Seay, A. Zaloshnja, E. Miller, T. Romano, E. Luchter, S. Spicer, R 2002 The economic impact of motor vehicle crashes, 2000 NHTSA DOT HS 809 446
- Dejour, H. Bonnin, M 1994 Tibial translation after anterior cruciate ligament rupture. Two radiological tests compared J Bone Joint Surg Br. 76 5 745 749
- Fildes, B. Lane, L. Vulcan, P. Seyer, K. 1997 Lower limb injuries to passenger car occupants Accid Anal Prev 29 789 795
- Fleming, B. Renstrom, P. Beynnon, B. et al. 2001 The effect of weight-bearing and external loading on anterior cruciate ligament strain J Biomech 34 163 170
- Genin, P. Weill, G. Julliard, R 1993 The tibial slope. Proposal for a measurement method J Radiol. 74 27 33
- Giffin, J. Woo, S. Harner, C. 2004 Effects of increasing tibial slope on the biomechanics of the knee Am J Sports Med 32 2 376 382
- Grood, E. Noyes, F. Butler, D 1977 Age related changes in the mechanical properties of knee ligaments Biomechanics Symposium ASME 213 216
- Hering, W. Patrick, L. 1977 Response comparisons of the human cadaver knee and a Part 572 dummy knee to impacts by crushable materials Stapp Car Crash Conf 21 1017 1053
- Johnson, D. Bealle, D. Brand, J. Caborn, D. 2000 The effect of a geographic lateral bone bruise on knee inflammation after acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture J Orth Soc for Sports Med 28 152 154
- Johnson, D. Urban, W. Caborn, D. Vanarthos, W. Carlson, C. 1998 Articular cartilage changes seen with magnetic resonance imaging-detected bone bruises associated with acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture Am J Sports Med 26 3 409 414
- Kuppa, S. Fessahaie, O 2002 An overview of knee-thigh-hip injuries in frontal crashes in the United States 18th ESV
- Li, G. Rudy, T. Allen, C. 1998 Effect of combined axial compressive and anterior tibial loads on in situ forces in the anterior cruciate ligament: a porcine study J Orth Res 16 122 127
- Li, G. Gill, T. Defrate, L. Zarins, B. 2002 Biomechanical consequences of PCL deficiency in the knee under simulated muscle loads-an in vitro experimental study J Orth Res 20 887 892
- Markolf, K. Bargar, W. Shoemaker, S. Amstutz, H 1981 The role of joint load in knee stability J Bone Jt Surg. 63 570 585
- Melvin, J. Stalnaker, R. Alem, N. Benson, J. Mohan, D. 1975 Impact response and tolerance of the lower extremities Stapp Car Crash Conf Proc 19 543 559
- Mertz, H 1993 Anthropomorphic Test Devices Accidental Injury, Biomechanics and Prevention Nahum A Melvin J Springer-Verlag
- Meyer, E. Haut, R. 2003 The effect of impact angle on knee tolerance to rigid impacts Stapp Car Crash J 47 1 19
- Miller, M. Osborne, J. Gordon, W. Hinkin, D. Brinker, M. 1998 The natural history of bone bruises: A prospective study of magnetic resonance imaging: detected trabecular microfractures in patients with isolated medial collateral ligament injuries Am J Sports Med 26 15 19
- Morgan, R. Eppinger, R. Marcus, J. Nichols, H 1990 Human cadaver and hybrid III responses International Conference on the Biomechanics of Impacts
- Murphy, E. Bresnihan, B. FitzGerald, O. 2001 Validated measurement of periarticular bone mineral density at the knee joint by dual energy x ray absorptiometry Ann Rheum Dis 60 8 13
- Patrick, L. Kroell, C. Mertz, H. 1965 Forces on the human body in simulated crashes Stapp Car Crash Conf Proc 9 237 259
- Powell, W. Ojala, S. Advani, S. Martin, R. 1975 Cadaver femur responses to longitudinal impacts Stapp Car Crash Conf Proc 19 561 579
- Rangger, C. Kreczy, A 1998 Bone bruise of the knee Acta Orthop Scand 69 3 291 294
- Rupp, J. Reed, M. Jeffreys, T. Schneider, L. 2003 Effects of hip posture on the frontal impact tolerance of the human hip joint Stapp Car Crash J 47 20 34
- Sanders, T. Lawthorn, K. 2000 Bone contusion patterns of the knee at MR imaging: Footprint of the mechanism of injury J Radiographics 20 S135 S151
- Torzilli, P. Deng, X. Warren, R 1994 The effect of joint-compression load and quadriceps muscle force on knee motion in the intact and the anterior cruciate ligament-sectioned knee Am J Sports Med. 22 105 112
- Vellet, A. Marks, P. Fowler, P. Munro, T. 1991 Occult posttraumatic osteochondral lesions of the knee: Prevalence, classification, and short-term sequelae evaluated with MR imaging J Radiology 178 271 276
- Viano, D. Culver, C. Haut, R. Melvin, J. Bender, M. Culver, R. Levine, R. 1978 Bolster impacts to the knee and tibia of human cadavers and an anthropomorphic dummy Stapp Car Crash Conf Proc 22 403 428