This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Effect of Friction Material on the Relative Contribution of Thin-Film Friction to Overall Friction in Clutches
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 25, 2004 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
In order to prevent shudder in automatic transmissions, friction must decrease as the sliding speed between the friction plates in clutches decreases. Theoretical studies have shown that friction in wet clutches is a combination of boundary friction and the friction due to flow of fluid through the friction materials (thin-film friction). Therefore, these physical properties of oils should control the anti-shudder performance of automatic transmission fluids. Recently, we demonstrated that boundary and thin-film friction contribute to friction measured at low speeds in JASO SAE No.2 and LVFA tests. Two different friction materials are used in these tests and the relative effect of thin-film friction on low speed friction is greater in the JASO SAE No. 2 test than in the JASO LVFA test. This difference in the relative effect of thin-film friction on overall friction could be due to the different speed conditions used to measure low speed friction in the SAE and LVFA tests or could be due to the difference in the friction materials used in these tests.
Therefore, we have expanded our research to determine the effect of sliding speed and friction material on the relative effect of thin-film and boundary friction on overall friction measured in friction material-steel contacts. As sliding speed increases, the relative contribution of thin-film friction to overall friction increases. The relative contribution of thin-film friction to overall friction at each speed depends upon the friction material used. The relative effect of thin-film friction to overall friction is greater for friction materials in which the rate of fluid flow into the material is slow. The relative effect of thin-film friction on overall friction is also greater for friction materials with lower surface roughnesses.
CitationDevlin, M., Tersigni, S., Senn, J., Turner, T. et al., "Effect of Friction Material on the Relative Contribution of Thin-Film Friction to Overall Friction in Clutches," SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-3025, 2004, https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-01-3025.
- Ohtani H., Hartley R. J., and Stinnett D. W., “Prediction of Anti-Shudder Properties of Automatic Transmission Fluids using a Modified SAE No. 2 Machine”, SAE 940821, (1994).
- Kugimiya T., Mitsui J., Yoshimura N., Kaneko H., Akamatsu H., Ueda F., Nakada T., and Akiyama S., “Development of Automatic Transmission Fluid for Slip-Controlled Lock-up Clutch Systems”, SAE 952348, (1995).
- Matsuo K., Saeki S., and Sakurai T., “Study on Anti-Shudder Durability of Automatic Transmission Fluids”, Proceedings of 1998 International Symposium of ‘Tribology of Vehicle Transmissions’, Yokohama, Japan, (1998).
- Matsuo K. and Saeki S., “Study on the Change of Friction Characteristics with Use in the Wet Clutch of Automatic Transmission”, SAE 972928, (1997).
- Ashikawa R., Naruse T., Kurashina H., Matsuoka T., Adachi T., and Nakayama T., “ATF Characteristics Required for the Latest Automatic Transmissions”, SAE 932849, (1993).
- Florkowski D. W., King T. E., Skrobul A. P., and Sumiejski J. L., “Development and Introduction of Chrysler's New Automatic Transmission Fluid”, SAE 982674, (1998).
- Srinivasan S., Sunne J. P., Smith D. W., and Stinnett D. W., “Prediction of Anti-Shudder Performance of ATFs in CSTCC - Equipped Vehicles Using the Low Speed SAE #2 Machine”, Paper Presented at the Esslingen Conference in 1998, pp 1657-1668.
- Tipton C. D. and Schiferl E. A., “Fundamental Studies on ATF Friction I.”, SAE 971621, (1997).
- Tipton C. D., Huston M. E., and Wetsel W. R., “Fundamental Studies on ATF Friction, Part II”, SAE 982670, (1998).
- Linden J. L., Stebar R. F., and Kemp S. P., “Friction Characteristics of DEXRON® - III Automatic Transmission Fluids”, SAE 941887, (1994).
- Matsuo K., Saeki S., and Ito F., “Friction Characteristics Compatibility of DEXRON® ATFs for Japanese Automatic Transmissions”, SAE 972929, (1997).
- Stebar R. F., Davison E. D. and Linden J. L., “Determining Frictional Performance of Automatic Transmission Fluids in a Band Clutch”, SAE 902146, (1990).
- Jones C. and Linden J. L., “Development of a Vehicle Test for Determining ATF Performance in an Electronically Controlled Capacity Clutch”, SAE 982667, (1998).
- Slough C. G., Ohtani H., Everson M. P., and Melotik D. J., “The Effect of Friction Modifiers on the Low-Speed Friction Characteristics of Automatic Transmission Fluids Observed with Scanned Force Microscopy”, SAE 981099, (1998).
- Cavdar B. and Lam R. C., “Wet Clutch Performance in a Mineral-Based, and in a Partial - Synthetic-Based Automatic Transmission Fluid”, SAE 970976, (1997).
- Nakagawa H., “The Influence of Fillers on Paper-Based Friction Materials Relative to Wet Clutch Slip Characteristics”, SAE 970975, (1997).
- Matsumoto T., “A Study of the Influence of Porosity and Resiliency of a Paper-Based Friction Material on the Friction Characteristics and Heat Resistance of the Material”, SAE 932924, (1993).
- Ward W. C., Sumiejski J. L., Castanien C. J., Tagliamonte T. A., Schiferl E. A., “Friction and Stick-Slip Durability Testing of ATF”, SAE 941883, (1994).
- Guan J. J., Willermet P. A., Carter R. O., and Melotik D. J., “Interaction Between ATFs and Friction Material for Modulated Torque Converter Clutches”, SAE 981098, (1998).
- Chrisope D. R., Stinnett D. W. and Hartley R. J., “Friction Retention and Thermal Decomposition of Fluid Additives in Wet Clutch Systems”, Paper Presented at the Esslingen Conference in January 1992.
- Watts R. F., Nibert R. K. and Tandon M., “Anti-Shudder Durability of Automatic Transmission Fluids: Mechanism of the Loss of Shudder Control”, in “Tribology - Solving Friction and Wear Problems” ed. by Bartz W. J., pp 1341-1358. Technische Akademie Esslingen, 10th International Colloquium, 09-11 January 1996.
- Maeda M., Murakami Y., “Testing Method and Effect of ATF Performance on Degradation of Wet Friction Materials”, JSAE 20030342 (SAE 2003-01-1982), (2003).
- Li S., Devlin M.T., Tersigni S.H., Jao T-C., Yatsunami K., Cameron T.M., “Fundamentals of Anti-Shudder Durability: Part I - Clutch Plate Study”, JSAE 20030109 (SAE 2003-01-1983), (2003).
- Sanda S., Nagasawa Y., Suzuki A., Hayashi K. and Itoh H., “Mechanism of Friction of Wet Clutch with Paper Based Facings”, Proceedings of International Tribology Conference Yokohama 1995, p. 1519.
- Yang, Y., Lam, R.C., Fuji, T., “Prediction of Torque Response During the Engagement of Wet Friction Clutch”, SAE 981097, (1998).
- Anderson, A.E., “Friction and Wear of Paper Type Wet Friction Elements”, SAE 720521, (1972).
- Anleitner, M.A., “Reconciling Empirical and Theoretical Views of Lubrication in Wet Friction Drives”, SAE 941102, (1994).
- Kugimiya, T., “Effects of Additives for ATF on -v Characteristics”, Proceedings of International Tribology Conference, October 30-November 2, 2000, Nagasaki, Japan.
- Cheng H.S.; “Lubrication Regimes”, ASM Handbook: Friction Lubrication and Wear Technology Vol. 18, 89, (1992).
- Spikes H.A, “Film-Forming Additives - Direct and Indirect Ways to Reduce Friction” 12th International Colloquium Tribology 2000, Technische Akademie Esslingen, (2000).
- Devlin M.T., Tersigni S. H., Li S., Turner T.L., Jao T-C,, Yatsunami K. and Cameron T.M., “Fundamentals of Anti-Shudder Durability: Part II - Fluid Effects”, SAE Technical Paper 2003-01-3254, (2003).
- Sarkar R., Devlin M. T., Li S., Glasgow M. B., and Jao T.C., “Low and High Temperature Non-Newtonian Behavior of Automatic Transmission Fluids”, SAE Paper No. 2002-01-1695, 2002.
- Johnston G.J., Wayte R., Spikes H.A., “The Measurement and Study of Very Thin Lubricant Films in Concentrated Contacts”, Tribology Transactions, 34, 187, (1991).
- Myers R.H. and Montgomery D.C., “Response Surface Methodology: Process and Product Optimization Using Designed Experiments”, John Wiley and Sons Inc., (1995).
- Moore, A.J.: Cooper, D.: Robinson, T.M.: “Rheological Properties of Engine Crankcase and Gear Oil Components in Elastohydrodynamic Oil Films.” SAE Paper 941977 (1994)
- Devlin M.T., Hammock T., and Jao T-C., “Effect of Mechanical Shear on the Thin Film Properties of Base Oil/Polymer Mixtures”, Lubrication Science Vol. 14 (2), 2002.
- Hu. Y. Z.: Granick, S.: “Microscopic Study of Thin Film Lubrication and its Contributions to Macroscopic Tribology.” Tribology Letters, 5 (1998), 81-88
- Gao J., Luedtke W.D., Landmann U., “Friction Control in Thin-Film Lubrication.” Journal of Physical Chemistry B, 102 (1998), 5033-5037
- Tohyama M., Ohmori T., Ueda F., “Anti-Shudder Mechanism of ATF Additives at Slip-Controlled Lock-UP Clutch”, SAE Paper No. 1999-01-3616.
- Hamrock B. J. and Dowson D., Trans. ASME, A99, 264, (1997).