This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Validation of the SIMON Model for Vehicle Handling and Collision Simulation - Comparison of Results with Experiments and Other Models
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 08, 2004 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
SIMON is a new 3-dimensional vehicle dynamic simulation model. The capabilities of the model include non-linear handling maneuvers and collision simulation for one or more vehicles. As a new model, SIMON must be validated by comparison against actual handling and collision experiments. This paper provided that comparison. Included in the validation were lane-change maneuvers, alternate ramp traversals, limit maneuvers with combined braking and steering, vehicle-to-vehicle crash tests and articulated vehicle handling tests. Comparison against other models were included. No metric was provided for handling test comparisons. However, statistical analysis of the collision test results revealed the average path range error was 6.2 to 14.8 percent. The average heading error was -4.7 to 0.7 percent. Delta-V error was -1.6 to 7.5 percent.
VEHICLE SIMULATION has many uses in the vehicle design and safety industries. Applications include suspension modeling, vehicle-tire system modeling, brake system modeling, virtual prototyping and compliance testing (ISO braking and lane change maneuvers) and safety analysis (collision simulation and post-crash reconstruction of actual on-road events).
Advances in vehicle modeling and computer hardware and software technologies have made possible significant improvements in vehicle simulation, resulting in newer and more powerful modeling capability. For example, simulations in the 1980's and early 1990's typically used 2-dimensional models employing three degrees of freedom. More sophisticated models existed, but were seldom used because of their crude user interfaces.
In 1996, the HVE simulation environment was introduced [1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6]*. HVE (Human-Vehicle-Environment) was developed as a sophisticated, 3-dimensional user environment for setting up and executing simulations involving humans and vehicles interacting with their environment. HVE was designed to be a general purpose tool, making few assumptions about the details of the actual simulation. Those details were left up to the designer/programmer of the simulation model.
In 2001, a new HVE-compatible simulation model, called SIMON (SImulation MOdel Nonlinear), was introduced. SIMON provided the capability to simulate maneuvers involving 3-dimensional vehicle dynamics, such as driving on irregular terrain and vehicle rollover. With the addition of DyMESH , SIMON provided the capability to simulate collisions involving over-ride and other 3-dimensional collision issues. A report was published , providing the technical details and capabilities of the SIMON model. This is the second technical report on SIMON. This report presents the results of a detailed validation study of the SIMON model.
CitationDay, T., "Validation of the SIMON Model for Vehicle Handling and Collision Simulation - Comparison of Results with Experiments and Other Models," SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1207, 2004, https://doi.org/10.4271/2004-01-1207.
- Day, T.D. “A Computer Graphics Interface Specification for Studying Humans, Vehicles and their Environment,” SAE Paper No. 930903 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1993
- Day, T.D. “An Overview of the HVE Developer's Toolkit,” SAE Paper No. 940923 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1994
- Day, T.D. “An Overview of the HVE Vehicle Model,” SAE Paper No. 950308 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1995
- Day, T.D. “An Overview of the HVE Human Model,” SAE Paper No. 950659 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1995
- Day, T.D. “Validation of Several Reconstruction and Simulation Models in the HVE Scientific Visualization Environment,” SAE Paper No. 960891 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1996
- HVE User's Manual, Fifth Engineering Dynamics Corporation Beaverton, OR 2002
- York, A.R. Day, T.D. “The DyMESH Method for Three-Dimensional Multi-Vehicle Collision Simulation,” SAE Paper number 1999-01-0104 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1999
- Day, T.D. Roberts, S.G. York, A.R. “SIMON: A New Vehicle Simulation Model for Vehicle Design and Safety Research,” SAE Paper No. 2001-01-0503 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 2001
- SIMON Simulation vs. Experimental Results Engineering Dynamics Corporation Beaverton, OR 2003
- EDC Custom Vehicle Database Engineering Dynamics Corporation Beaverton, OR 2001
- FARO 3-D Mechanical Arm, Bronze Series, 1.5 m FARO Technologies, Inc. Lake Mary, FL
- Longacre Model 7258 Electronic Wheel Scales Longacre Racing Products Redmond, WA
- US Dept. Of Transportation NHTSA Vehicle Research and Test Center Crash Avoidance Research, Measured Vehicle Inertial Parameters November 1998 http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/vrtc/rollover.htm
- “Updating the Vehicle Class Categories,” SAE Paper No. 960897 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1996
- US Dept. Of Transportation NHTSA Research and Development NHTSA Vehicle Crash Test Database http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/database/nrd-11/veh_db.html
- Segal, D.J. Highway-Vehicle-Object Simulation Model - 1976, Volume 2: Validation Calspan Corporation Buffalo 1976
- Nalecz, A.G. et al Sensitivity Analysis of Vehicle Tripped Rollover Model, Washington, D.C. July 1988
- Tapia, G. Extended Tire Testing Calspan Corporation Buffalo 1983
- Bernard, J.E. Winkler, C.B. Fancher, P.S. A Computer-based Mathematical Method for Predicting the Directional Response of Trucks and Tractor-Trailers Phase II Technical Report, Motor Truck Braking and Handling Performance Study Highway Safety Research Institute, The University of Michigan Ann Arbor June 1973
- Shoemaker, N.E. Research Input for Computer Simulation of Automobile Collisions - Volumes II and III - Staged Collision Reconstructions Calspan Corporation Buffalo 1978
- Smith, R. Noga, T. “Accuracy and Sensitivity of CRASH,” March 1982
- McHenry, B.G. McHenry, R.R. RICSAC-97 - A Reevaluation of the Reference Set of Full Scale Crash Tests,” SAE Paper number 970961 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1997
- Brach, R.M. Smith, R.A. “Re-Analysis of the RICSAC Car Crash Accelerometer Data,” SAE Paper number 2002-01-1305 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 2002
- Day, T.D. Hargens, R.L. “Further Validation of EDSMAC Using the RICSAC Staged Collisions,” SAE Paper No. 900102 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1990
- Two-Moving Vehicle Crash Test, 1984 Ford F-150 Pickup into a 1992 Ford Explorer June 23 1999 Exponent Failure Analysis Test and Engineering Center Phoenix 1999
- Leonard, M.M. Werner, S.M. Croteau, J.J. Tuskan, S.M. Habberstad, J.L. “HVE EDSMAC4 Trailer Model Simulation Comparison with Crash Test Data,” SAE Paper number 2001-01-0468 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 2001