This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of the Rear Impact Biofidelity of BioRID II and RID2
Published November 11, 2002 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
Researchers worldwide try to define a unique test procedure for the assessment of whiplash protection of seats and restraint systems in low speed rear-end impact. Apart from valid injury criteria and uniform crash conditions, there is no clear answer to the question, which dummy to use. There are two impact dummies currently available, which have been designed for rear-end impact testing: BioRID and RID2. Both dummies have been evaluated in several test programs, however, both dummies have never been compared with each other in the test conditions, which form the basis of their design. BioRID was based on and validated against volunteer tests performed by Davidsson and Ono, while RID2 was designed with and validated against PMHS tests done by Bertholon and compared to volunteer tests reported by Van den Kroonenberg.
This paper compares the responses of both rear impact dummies and the Hybrid III for the test conditions mentioned above. The setup of Davidsson used a rigid seat with flexible back and head restraint panels, while the setups from Ono and Bertholon used a rigid seat without a head restraint, in spite of being not representative for real car seats. This configuration creates a well defined test environment which will not affect nor obscure the dummy response
Results of the performance of both rear impact dummies and the Hybrid III in comparison to the human responses will be presented in this paper. The results show that both rear impact dummies are capable of simulating rear impact responses, especially the head-neck kinematics. A difference in load pattern was found, which could be relevant when injury criteria will be based on neck forces and/or torques. Moreover, the dummies show a different interaction with the seat back, illustrated by the differences in T1 kinematics: BioRID shows larger T1 rotation and more ramping up than RID2, while spine straightening is comparable for both dummies. The current study showed good scores for both dummies in the setup on which they are based. The biofidelity score of BioRID is slightly better than for RID2, while the performance of the Hybrid III is relatively poor. However, repeatability, reproducibility and handling are not part of the evaluation, even though they are important for the practical use of the dummies.
- M. Philippens - TNO Automotive, Delft, The Netherlands
- H. Cappon - TNO Automotive, Delft, The Netherlands
- M. van Ratingen - TNO Automotive, Delft, The Netherlands
- J. Wismans - TNO Automotive, Delft, The Netherlands
- M. Svensson - Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden
- F. Sirey - Chalmers University of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden
- K. Ono - Japan Automobile Research Institute, Japan
- N. Nishimoto - Japan Automobile Research Institute, Japan
- F. Matsuoka
CitationPhilippens, M., Cappon, H., van Ratingen, M., Wismans, J. et al., "Comparison of the Rear Impact Biofidelity of BioRID II and RID2," SAE Technical Paper 2002-22-0023, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-22-0023.
- Bertholon N. Robin S. Le Coz J.Y. Potier P. Lassau J.P. Skalli W. 2000 Human Head and Cervical Spine Behaviour during Low-Speed Rear-End Impacts: PMHS Sled Tests with a Rigid Seat Proc. IRCOBI Conference 265 277
- Cappon H. Philippens M. van. Ratingen M. Wismans J. 2001 Development and Evaluation of a new Rear-Impact Crash Dummy: the RID2 Proc. 45th STAPP Car Crash Conference Paper no: 01S-20
- Davidsson J. Svensson M.Y. Flogård A. Håland Y. Jakobsson L. Linder A. Lövsund P. Wiklund K. 1998 BioRID I - A New Biofidelic Rear Impact Dummy Proc. IRCOBI Conference 1998 377 390
- Davidsson J. Flogård A. Lövsund P. Svensson M. 1999a BioRID P3- Design and Performance compared to Hybrid III and Volunteers in Rear Impacts at ΔV=7 km/h Proc. 43rd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1999 253 265
- Davidsson J. Lövsund P. Ono K. Svensson M.Y. Inami S. 1999b A Comparison between Volunteer, BioRID P3 and Hybrid III performance in Rear Impacts Proc. IRCOBI Conference 1999 165 178
- v Koch M. Kullgren A. Lie A. Nygren A. Tingvall C. 1995 Soft Tissue Injury of the Cervical Spine in Rear-End and Frontal Car Collisions Proc. IRCOBI Conference 1995 273 283
- van den Kroonenberg A. Philippens M. Cappon H. Wismans J. Hell W. Langwieder K. 1998 Human Head-Neck Response During Low-Speed Rear End Impacts Proc. 42nd STAPP Car Crash Conference SAE Paper 983158
- Linder A. Svensson M. Viano D. 2002 Evaluation of the BioRID P3 and the Hybrid III in Pendulum Impacts to the Back: A Comparison with Human Subject Test Data Traffic Injury Prevention 3 159 166
- Morgan M.R. Marcus J.H. Eppinger R.H. 1981 Correlation of Side Impact Dummy/Cadaver Tests Proc. 25nd STAPP Car Crash Conference SAE Paper 811008
- NHTS 2001 R&D website http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/include/summaries/B0127.htm
- Ono K. Kanno M. 1993 Influences of the Physical Parameters on the Risk to Neck Injuries in Low Speed Rear-end Collisions Proc. IRCOBI Conference 1993 201 212
- Ono K. Inami S. Kaneoka K. Gotou T. Kisanuki Y. Sakuma S. Miki K. 1999 Relationship between Localized Spine Deformation and Cervical Vertebral motions for Low Speed Rear Impacts using Human Volunteers Proc. IRCOBI Conference 1999 149 164
- Roberts A.K. Hynd D. Dixon P.R. Murphy O. Magnusson M. Pope M.H. 2002 Kinematics of the Human Spine in Rear Impact and the Biofidelity of Current Dummies Proc. Vehicle Safety 2002 ImechE Conference
- Schneider L.W. Robbins D.H. Pflüg Snyderr R.G. 1983 Development of Anthropometrically based Design Specifications for an Adult Anthropomorphic Dummy Family 2 UMTRI-83-53-2 The University of Michigan, Transport Research Institute 2901 Baxter Road, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109
- Temming J. Zobel R. 1998 Frequency and risk of cervical spine distortion injuries in passenger car accidents: Significance of human factors data Proc. IRCOBI Conference 219 234
- Temming J. Zobel R. 2000 Neck distortion injuries in road traffic crashes (Analyses of the Volkswagen database) “Frontiers in Whiplash Trauma” Yoganandan, IOS Press 118 133