API CI-4: The First Oil Category for Diesel Engines Using Cooled Exhaust Gas Recirculation
Published May 6, 2002 by SAE International in United States
Annotation of this paper is available
This oil category was driven by two new cooled exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) engine tests operating with 15% EGR, with used oil soot levels at the end of the test ranging from 6 to 9%. These tests are the Mack T-10 and Cummins M11 EGR, which address ring, cylinder liner, bearing, and valve train wear; filter plugging, and sludge. In addition to these two new EGR tests, there is a Caterpillar single-cylinder test without EGR which measures piston deposits and oil consumption control using an articulated piston. This test is called the Caterpillar 1R and is included in the existing Global DHD-1 specification.
In total, the API CI-4 category includes eight fired-engine tests and seven bench tests covering all the engine oil parameters. The new bench tests include a seal compatibility test for fresh oils and a low temperature pumpability test for used oils containing 5% soot.
This paper provides a review of the all the tests, matrix results, and limits for this new oil category. This work was completed by the ASTM Heavy Duty Engine Oil Classification Panel (HDEOCP) in October 2001, at a cost of $5.71 million (6.28 million Euro). This was followed by a successful ASTM D.02.B ballot in December 2001. API-licensed products designated API CI-4 will become available in August 2002.
API CI-4 oils are pivotal components in maintaining diesel engine durability using cooled EGR. API CI-4 is a higher quality oil than the previous diesel oil categories, so it will provide engine protection for both existing and new EGR engines.
- J. A. Mc Geehan - ChevronTexaco Company
- J. Wells - Southwest Research Institute
- S. Kennedy - ExxonMobil
- A. Huang - Equilon Enterprises
- G. Shank - Mack Trucks
- D. Stehouwer - Cummins Inc.
- D. Larkin - Detroit Diesel Corporation
- B. Mesfin - Detroit Diesel Corporation
- D. Tharp - Caterpillar Inc.
- F. Bondarowicz - International Truck and Engine Corporation
- K. Chao - John Deere
- R. T. Stockwell - GM Powertrain Engineering Center
- C. Passut - Ethyl Corporation
- W. Kleiser - Chevron Oronite Company LLC
- L. Williams - Lubrizol Corporation
- P. Fetterman - Infineum USA
- J. Zalar - Test Monitoring Center
- J. Rutherford - Oronite
- P. Scinto - Lubrizol
- D. Malandro - Infineum
CitationMc Geehan, J., Wells, J., Kennedy, S., Huang, A. et al., "API CI-4: The First Oil Category for Diesel Engines Using Cooled Exhaust Gas Recirculation," SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-1673, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-1673.
SAE 2002 Transactions Journal of Fuels and Lubricants
Number: V111-4; Published: 2003-09-15
Number: V111-4; Published: 2003-09-15
- Caterpillar Tractor Company, Wall Street Journal, November 22, 1999.
- Office of Advance Automotive Technologies, “Multiyear Program Plan, Advanced Petroleum-Base Fuels (APBF) RD & T for Compression-Ignition, DI Engines and Emission Controls,” November 1, 2000.
- EPA, “Control of Air Pollution From New Motor Vehicles: Heavy-Duty Engines and Vehicle Standards and Highway Fuel Sulfur Control Requirements,” Federal Register, Vol. 66, No. 12, January 18, 2001, Rules and Regulations.
- Summer J. C., Skowron J. F., Williamson W. B., and Mitchell K. I., “Fuel Sulfur Effects on Automotive Catalyst Performance,” SAE Paper 920558 (1992).
- Mc Geehan J. A., “Effect of Piston Deposits, Fuel Sulfur, and Lubricant Viscosity on Diesel Engine Oil Consumption and Cylinder Bore Polishing,” SAE Paper 831721 (1983).
- Mc Geehan J. A., Flanklin T., Bondarowicz F., Bowen T., Cave W., Cuano C., Farnsworth G., Quinn M. J., Juett R. L., Larkin D., Lee R., Lohuis J. R., Marn D., Nann N., Olree B., Passut C., Shank G., and Zalar J., “The World's First Diesel Engine Oil Category for Use With Low Sulfur Fuel: API CG-4,” SAE Paper 941939 (1994).
- Wall J. C., “Impact of U.S. Emission Regulations on Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine Development in the 1990's,” Congress International, “Moteurs Diesel” Perspective 1990-2000, Societe des Ingenieurs de Automobiles, Lyon, France, July 12-13, 1990.
- Needham J. R., Doyle D. M., and Nicol A. J., “The Low NOx Truck Engine,” SAE Paper 910731 (1991).
- Mc Geehan J. A., Shamah E., Couch M. C., and Parker R. A., “Selecting Diesel Crankcase Oils for Use With Low Sulfur Fuel,” SAE Paper 932845 (1993).
- Munro R., “Emissions Impossible - The Piston and Ring Support,” SAE Paper 900590 (1990).
- Richards R. R. and Sibley J. E., “Diesel Engine Emission Control for the 1990's,” SAE Paper 880346 (1988).
- Wall J. C. and Hoekman S. K., “Fuel Composition Effects on Heavy-Duty Diesel Particulate Emissions,” SAE Paper 841364 (1984).
- Hiden D. L. and Mayer W. J., “The Contribution of Engine Oil to Particulate Emissions From Light-Duty Diesel Powered Vehicles,” SAE Paper 841395 (1984).
- Essig G., Kramp H., and Wacker E., “Diesel Engine Emission Reduction - The Benefits of Low Oil Consumption Design,” SAE Paper 900591 (1990).
- Mc Geehan J. A., Chairman; Franklin T. M., Secretary; Bondarowicz F.; Bowen T.; Wang J.; Graham J. P.; Fetterman G.; Quinn M. J.; Juett R. L.; Larkin D.; Lee R.; Kennedy S.; Marn D.; Buscher W.; Passut C.; Shank G.; and Lawrence B., “New Diesel Engine Oil Category for 1998: API CH-4,” SAE Paper 981371 (1998).
- Ward's Engine and Vehicle Technology, “EPA Truck Diesel Action Raises Questions,” Vol. 24, No. 22, November 15, 1998.
- Heywood J. B., “Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals,” McGraw-Hill, New York (1988).
- Ached N., and Sugar H., “Combined Effects of EGR and Supercharing on Diesel Combustion and Emissions,” SAE Paper 930601 (1993).
- Pierpont D. A., Montgomery D. T., and Reitz R. D., “Reducing Particulate and NOx Using Multiple Injections and EGR in a DI Diesel,” SAE Paper 950217 (1995).
- Yu R. C. and Shahed S. M., “Effects of Injection Timing and Exhaust Gas Recirculation on Emissions From a DI Diesel Engine,” SAE Paper 811234 (1981).
- Litzinger T. A., Pinson J. A., Clark D. O., and Mitchell D. L., “The Effect of Intake Charge Dilution With CO2 on Diesel Soot Evolution,” Combustion Science and Technology Book Series, Vol. 4, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers.
- Wall John, “Playing It Cool On Emissions,” North American Edition Diesel Progress, August 2001 (reported by Mike Brezonick).
- Barry E. G., McCabe L. J., Gerke D. H., and Perez J. M., “Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine-Fuel Combustion Performance and Emissions - A Cooperative Research Program,” SAE Paper 852078 (1985).
- Wall J. C., Shimpi S. A., and Yu M. L., “Fuel Sulfur Reduction for Control of Diesel Particulate Emissions,” SAE Paper 872139 (1987).
- Mc Geehan J. A. and Kulkarni A. V., “Mechanism of Corrosive Wear Control by Lubricant in Diesel Engines,” SAE Paper 872029 (1987).
- Stevens M. G., “Lubricant Appetites of HDD Engine Equipped With Exhaust Gas Recirculation,” Independent Lubricant Manufacturers Association Annual Meeting, October 23, 2000.
- Loftis T. S. and Lanius M. B., “A New Method for Combination Full-Flow and Bypass Filtration: Venturi Combo,” SAE Paper 972957 (1997).
- Mc Geehan J. A., Alexander W. III, Ziemer J. N., and Roby S. H., “The Pivotal Role of Crankcase Oil in Preventing Soot Wear and Extending Filter Life in Low Emission Diesel Engines,” SAE Paper 1999-01-1525 (1999).
- Mc Geehan J. A. and Eiden K. L., “Low Temperature Pumpability in Emission Controlled Diesel Engines,” SAE Paper 2000-01-198 (2000).
- Neveu C. D., Renner G., and Herzog S., “Engine Oil Pumpability Study in a Heavy Duty Diesel Truck Engine,” SAE Paper 2000-01-1988 (2000).
- Davises R. E., Draper M. R., Lawrence B. J., Parker D., Seeney A. M., and Smith G. C., “Lubricant Formulations Effects on Oil Seal Degradation,” SAE Paper 952340 (1995).
- van Dam W., Shank G., Richards S. M., and Cooper M., “A New Engine Test for the Development of Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine Oils for Engines With Exhaust Gas Recirculation: The Mack T-10 Test,” SAE Paper 2000-01-1985 (2000).
- Glassey S. F., Stockner A. R., and Flinn M. A., “HEUI-New Direction for Diesel Engine Fuel System,” SAE Paper 930270 (1993).
- Scheider E. W., Blossfield D. H., and Bainaves M. A., “Effects of Speed and Power Output on Piston Ring Wear in a Diesel Engine,” SAE Paper 880672 (1988).