This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Graphical Weather Information System Evaluation: Usability, Perceived Utility, and Preferences from General Aviation Pilots
Technical Paper
2002-01-1521
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Weather is a significant factor in General Aviation (GA) accidents and fatality rates. Graphical Weather Information Systems (GWISs) for the flight deck are appropriate technologies for mitigating the difficulties GA pilots have with current aviation weather information sources. This paper describes usability evaluations of a prototype GWIS by 12 GA pilots after using the system in flights towards convective weather. We provide design guidance for GWISs and discuss further research required to support weather situation awareness and in-flight decision making for GA pilots.
Recommended Content
Citation
Latorella, K. and Chamberlain, J., "Graphical Weather Information System Evaluation: Usability, Perceived Utility, and Preferences from General Aviation Pilots," SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-1521, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-1521.Also In
References
- Driskill W.E. Weissmuller J.J. Quebe J. Hand D.K. Dittmar M.J. Hunter D.R. 1997 The Use of Weather Information in Aeronautical Decision-Making Report No. DOT/FAA/AM-97/3 NTIS Springfield, VA
- O'Hare D. 1990 Pilots perception of risk and hazards in general aviation. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 61 599 603
- Layton C.F. McCoy E. 1989 General aviation pilot perceptions of deteriorating weather conditions The Fifth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology Columbus, Ohio
- Potter S.S. Rockwell T.H. McCoy C.E. 1989 General aviation pilot error in computer simulated adverse weather scenarios The Fifth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology Columbus, Ohio
- Beck G.A. 1987 A Protocol Analysis of General Aviation Pilots' Subjective Weather Forecasting Procedure Ohio State University Masters Thesis Columbus, Ohio
- Giffin W.C. Rockwell T.H. 1982 A methodology for research on VFR into IMC The Fourth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology 278 285
- AOPA Air Safety Foundation 1996 Safety Review: General Aviation Weather Accidents - An Analysis & Preventive Strategies Frederick, MD AOPA Air Safety Foundation
- Sireli Y. Ozan E. Kauffmann P. 2001 A market research study for future weather information systems in general aviation American Society for Engineering Management (ASEM) National Conference Huntsville, AL
- Bussolari S.R. 1994 Mode S data-link applications for general aviation The Lincoln Laboratory Journal 7 (2) 313 328
- Kelly W. 2000 EWxR, An enhanced on-board weather information system NASA Weather Accident Prevention Project Annual Review Proceedings Hampton, VA
- Bernays D.J. Dershowitz A. Lind A.T. Bussolari S.R. 1993 The development of a data link-compatible graphical weather service at MIT Lincoln Laboratory The Symposium on Worldwide Communications, Navigation, and Surveillance Reston, VA
- Wickens C.D. 1984 Engineering Psychology and Human Performance Boston Scott, Foresman & Co.
- Lind A.T. Dershowitz A. Chandra D. Bussolari S.R. 1997 The Effects of Compression-Induced Distortion of Graphical Weather Images on Pilot Perception, Acceptance, and Performance. Lincoln Laboratory Report ATC-243, MIT Lexington, MA
- Lind A.T. Dershowitz A. Bussolari S.R. 1994 The Influence of Data Link-Provided Graphical Weather on Pilot Decision-Making Report No. DOT/FAA/RD-94/9 NTIS Springfield, VA
- Wanke C. Chandra D. Hansman R.J. Bussolari S.R. 1990 A comparison of voice and datalink for ATC amendments and hazardous windshear alerts The Fourth International Symposium on Aviation Safety Toulouse, France
- Wanke C. Hansman R.J. 1992 Hazard evaluation and operational cockpit display of ground-measured windshear data Journal of Aircraft 29 319 325
- Scanlon C.H. 1994 Cockpit graphical weather information shown to enhance efficiency, safety, and situation awareness Flight Safety Foundation's 39th Annual Corporate Aviation Safety Seminar (CASS) St. Louis, MO
- Chandra D.C. 1995 Pilot evaluation of datalink services for general aviation The Eighth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology 679 685
- Talotta N.J. 1997 A Field Evaluation of Data Link Flight Information Services for General Aviation Pilots Report No. DOT/FAA/CT-97/3 NTIS Springfield, VA
- Jonsson J.E. 2002 Evaluation of Aviation Weather Display and Information on a NASA 757 Flight Test NASA-TM-Manuscript in preparation NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA.
- Yuchnovicz D. Novacek P. Burgess M. Heck M. Stokes A. 2001 Use of a Data-Linked Weather Information Display and Effects on Pilot Navigation Decision Making in a Piloted Simulation Study NASA-CR-2001-211047 NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA
- Yuchnovicz D. Burgess M. Heck M. Novacek P. 2000 Assessment of the effects of delayed weather information datalinked to the cockpit on pilot navigation decision making IEEE AIAA Digital Avionics Systems Conference Philadelphia, PA
- Novacek P.F. Burgess M.A. Heck J.L. Stokes A.F. 2001 The effects of own-ship position information and NEXRAD image resolution in the use of a weather information display The 20th Digital Avionics Systems Conference Daytona Beach, FL
- Chandra D.C. Bernays D.J. Bussolari S.R. 1995a Transactions of the IEEE 258 263
- Chandra D.C. Banis K.J. Bussolari S.R. 1995b Design of a human interface for general aviation data link applications The Eighth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology Columbus, Ohio
- Lind A.T. Dershowitz A. Chandra D. Bussolari S.R. 1995 The effect of data link-provided graphical weather images on pilot decision-making The Sixth IFAC Symposium on Man-Machine Systems Cambridge, MA
- Rehman A.J. 1995 A pilot evaluation of text display formats for weather information in the cockpit DOT/FAA/CT-TN95/42 FAA Technical Center Atlantic City, NJ
- Burt J.L. Coyne J.T. Saleem J.J. Lynn E. 2002a A Human Factors Evaluation of Five Commercially Available Portable Multi-Functional Color Cockpit Displays NASA-TM-Manuscript in preparation NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA
- Latorella K. Lane S. Garland D. 2002 General Aviation Pilots' Perceived Usage and Valuation of Aviation Weather Information Sources NASA-TM-2002-211443 NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA
- Latorella K.A. Chamberlain J.P. 2001 Decision-making in flight with different convective weather information sources: Preliminary Results The Eleventh International Symposium for Aviation Psychology Columbus, Ohio
- Chamberlain J.P. Latorella K.A. 2001 Convective weather detection by general aviation pilots with conventional and data-linked graphical weather information sources The 20th Digital Avionics Systems Conference Daytona Beach, FL
- Karat C.M. 1997 Cost-justifying usability engineering in the software life cycle Helander M.G. Landauer T.K. Prabhu P.V. Handbook of Human-Computer Interaction Second Elsevier Science B.V. Amsterdam, The Netherlands
- Wiggins M. O'Hare D. 1995 Expertise in aeronautical weather-related decision making: A cross-sectional analysis of general aviation pilots Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied 1 4 305 320
- Hart S.G. Staveland L.E. 1988 Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): Results of empirical and theoretical research Hancock P.A. Meshkati N. Human Mental Workload 139 183 North-Holland Elsevier Science
- Harper B. D. Norman K. L. 1993 Improving user satisfaction: The questionnaire for user interaction satisfaction version 5.5 Proceedings of the 1st Annual Mid-Atlantic Human Factors Conference 224 228 Virginia Beach, VA
- Rasmussen J. Vicente K.J. 1989 Coping with human errors through system design: implications for ecological interface design International Journal of Man-Machine Studies 31 517 534
- Endsley M. R. 1988 Design and evaluation for situation awareness enhancement Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 32nd Annual Meeting Santa Monica, CA
- Burt J. Chamberlain J. Jones K. Coyne J. 2002b The impact of a weather information system display on general aviation pilot workload and performance Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc.
- Mulgund S. Rinkus G. Illgen C. Zacharias G. Friskie J. 1997 Olipsa: on-line intelligent processor for situation assessment The Second Annual Symposium and Exhibition on Situational Awareness in the Tactical Air Environment Patuxent River, MD
- Jonsson J.E. 2001 Personal communication. NASA Langley Research Center Hampton, VA
- Kauffmann P. Pothanun K. 2000 Estimating the Rate of Technology Adoption for Cockpit Weather Information Systems Paper 2000-01-1662 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc.
- Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) 2002 Aeronautical Information Manual, section 7-1-10 Washington, DC
- RTCA, Inc 2001 Minimum Operational Performance Standard for Flight Information Services-Broadcast (FIS-B) Data Link, RTCA/DO-267 RTCA Inc. Washington D.C. March