This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison between Kalman Filter and Robust Filter for Vehicle Handling Dynamics State Estimation
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 04, 2002 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper explores design methods for a vehicle handling dynamics state estimator based on a linear vehicle model. The state estimator is needed because there are some states of the vehicle that cannot be measured directly, such as sideslip velocity, and also some which are relatively expensive to measure, such as roll and yaw rates. Information about the vehicle states is essential for vehicle handling stability control and is also valuable in chassis design evaluation.
The aim of this study is to compare the performance of a Kalman filter with that of a robust filter, under conditions which would be realistic and viable for a production vehicle. Both filters are thus designed and tested with reference to a higher order source model which incorporates nonlinear saturating tyre force characteristics. Also, both filters rely solely on accelerometer sensors, which are simulated with expected noise characteristics in terms of amplitude and spectra.
As is widely known, the Kalman filter is a stochastic filter whose design depends on the nominal vehicle model and statistical information of process and measurement noises. By contrast, the robust filter is deterministic, formulated in terms of model parameter uncertainties and the expected gain of process and measurement noises. The objective of both filter designs is to minimise the variance of the estimation error. Both filters are designed to compensate the vehicle model non-linearities, parameter uncertainties and other modeling errors, which are represented in terms of process and measurement noise covariances in Kalman filter design and in terms of additive model uncertainties in robust filter design.
The study shows that the robust filter offers higher performance potential. The work concludes with a discussion on the practical realisation of each method, and gives recommendations for further research into a single design methodology which combines the benefits of both approaches.
|Technical Paper||The Effects of Suspension Stiffness on Handling Responses|
|Technical Paper||Independent Torque Distribution Strategies for Vehicle Stability Control|
|Technical Paper||Development of Integrated Chassis Control for Limit Handling|
CitationSatria, M. and Best, M., "Comparison between Kalman Filter and Robust Filter for Vehicle Handling Dynamics State Estimation," SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-1185, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-1185.
- Gordon T. J., “An Integrated Strategy for the Control of a Full Vehicle Suspension System,” Vehicle System Dynamics, vol. 25, pp. 229-242, 1996.
- Austin L. and Morrey D., “Recent Advances in Antilock Braking Systems and Traction Control Systems,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineering, vol. 214, pp. 625-638, 2000.
- El-Demerdash S. M., Sell A. M., and Cron D. A., “Vehicle Body Attitude Control Using an Electronically Controlled Active Suspension,” Society of Automotive Engineers, pp. 1232-1242, 1999.
- Kawakami H., Sato H., Tabata M., Inoue H., and Itimaru H., “Development of Integrated System Between Active Control Suspension, Active 4WS, TRC and ABS,” SAE Special Publications, vol. 917, pp. 41-48, 1992.
- Fukada Y., “Estimation of Vehicle Slip-angle with Combination Method of Model Observer and Direct Integration,” Proceedings of the International Symposium on Advanced Vehicle Control 1998, pp. 201-206, 1998.
- Kienecke U. and Daib A., “Observation of Lateral Vehicle Dynamics,” Control Engineering Practice, vol. 5, pp. 1145-1150, 1997.
- Venhovens P. J. T. and Naab K., “Vehicle Dynamics Estimation Using Kalman Filters,” Vehicle System Dynamics, vol. 32, pp. 171-184, 1999.
- Best M. C., Gordon T. J., and Dixon P. J., “An Extended Adaptive Kalman Filter for Real-time State Estimation of Vehicle Handling Dynamics,” Vehicle System Dynamics, 2000.
- Best M. C. and Gordon T. J., “Real Time State Estimation of Vehicle Handling Dynamics Using an Adaptive Kalman Filter,” Proceedings of the International Symposium on Advanced Vehicle Control 1998, pp. 183-188, 1998.
- Milliken W. F. and Milliken D. L., Race Car Vehicle Dynamics: SAE International, 1995.
- Anderson B. D. O. and Moore J. B., Optimal Control: Linear Quadratic Methods: Prentice Hall Inc, 1990.
- Bolzern P., Colaneri P. G., and Nicolao D., “Optimal Robust Filtering with Time-varying Parameter Uncertainty,” International Journal of Control, vol. 63, pp. 557-576, 1996.
- Helstrom C. W., Probability and Stochastic Process for Engineers, Second Edition ed: Macmillan Publishing Company, 1991.