This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Environmental-Economic Evaluation of Hybrid Electric and Other Advanced Vehicles
Technical Paper
2001-01-3738
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Hybrid electric vehicles (HEV) and other advanced propulsion technologies offer greater fuel economy and lower pollutant and tailpipe emissions. Some experts regard the HEV technology as a practical, attractive solution to social concerns about fuel economy (and related fossil fuel conservation) and vehicle emissions. [Maples 98] The technology is practical; however, an HEV is more expensive to produce than a conventional internal combustion engine (ICE). In a world of limited resources and many petroleum users and emissions sources, the policy question is whether the best use of resources is to build HEV, to improve the fuel economy and lower emissions from other sources, or to devote the resources to other environmental projects.
We compare the second generation (designed for the United States) Toyota Prius, to the conventional internal combustion engine Toyota Corolla. We examine both private (vehicle purchase price, maintenance, and fuel) and social (the pollutant [non-methane organic gases, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides] and carbon dioxide emissions) costs. For each of the vehicles, we evaluate lifetime vehicle exhaust emissions as well as upstream emissions from producing the fuel.
We find that the second generation Prius is still not cost-effective in improving fuel-economy and lowering emissions. For the Prius to be attractive to U.S. consumers, the price of gasoline would have to be more than three times greater than the present level. To be attractive to regulators, the social value of abating tailpipe emissions would have to be 14 times greater than conventional values. Alternatively, the value of abating greenhouse gas emissions would have to be at least $220 per ton. We judge that any HEV would have a difficult time competing with the Corolla because of the Corolla's already high fuel economy and low pollutant emissions.
We also examine the costs and benefits of making a GM Silverado pickup truck into a gasoline hybrid. Like the analysis of the Prius, we again find that the price of gasoline or social value of abating carbon dioxide would have to be higher than the base case values in order to payback the cost of converting the vehicle to an HEV. Finally, we find that at current gasoline prices and carbon dioxide valuation, a conventional vehicle would need to have a fuel economy of 13 mpg or less in order for a $4,000 cost of converting it to an HEV to get 30% better fuel economy would pay off. We conclude that HEV will not have significant sales unless fuel prices rise several-fold or unless regulators mandate them.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Lave, L. and MacLean, H., "An Environmental-Economic Evaluation of Hybrid Electric and Other Advanced Vehicles," SAE Technical Paper 2001-01-3738, 2001, https://doi.org/10.4271/2001-01-3738.Also In
References
- German, J. 2001 “Hybrid Vehicles Go to Market: Will Gas-and-Electric-Powered Automobiles Fit the Bill? TR News 213 March-April 15 22
- Hellman, K.H. Murrell, J.D. Cheng, J.P. 1986 Trends in alternate measures of vehicle fuel economy Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA
- Lave, L.B. Dowlatabadi, H. Russell, A.G. 1996 “A Free Lunch at Higher CAFÉ?: A Review of Economic, Environmental and Social Benefits,” Energy Policy 24 253 264
- Lave, L.B. MacLean, H.L. 2001 Are Hybrid Vehicles Worth It? IEEE Spectrum March 47 50
- Lave, L.B. MacLean, H.L. 2001 Are Hybrid Vehicles Worth It? IEEE Spectrum March 47 50
- MacLean, H.L. Lave, L.B. 1998 Addressing vehicle equivalency to facilitate meaningful automobile comparisons SAE
- MacLean, H. L. Lave, L. B. Lankey, R. L. Joshi, S. 2000 A life cycle comparison of alternative automobile fuels Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association 50 1769 1779
- MacLean, H.L. Lave, L.B. 1998 A life-cycle model of an automobile Environmental Science & Technology 32 7 322 330
- Maples, J. Moore, J. Jr., Schaper, V Patterson, P. 1998 Transportation and fuel technologies: performance analysis methodology 1998 U.S. Department of Energy Washington, DC
- Matthews, H.S. Lave, L.B. 2000 Application of environmental valuation for determining externality costs Environmental Science and Technology 34 8 1390 1395
- Santini D. Patterson, P. Vyas, A. 2000 The importance of vehicle costs, fuel prices, and fuel efficiency in HEV market success Proceedings of the 79th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board January 9-13 Washington, DC
- Spectrum Letters 2001 May 79 84
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1998 Evaluation of a Toyota Prius hybrid system (THS) August