This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Role of Error Budgeting in the Use of Structurally Integrated Features for Aerospace Assembly
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 19, 2000 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The Jigless Aerospace Manufacture (JAM) project has been set up to investigate the significant technological and economic issues to enable the minimisation of product specific tooling in the design and assembly of large aerostructures.
As part of this on-going work, the use of error budgeting was explored to asses it suitability as a tool to enable the design of large aerostructures that would be easily assembled without recourse to expensive jigs and fixtures. This technique, which has been successfully used for the design of precision machines [1, 2], has the potential to allow the comparison of several concepts and configurations early in the design process and so help the selection process as well as highlighting areas where redesign should be considered at the detail design stage.
This paper detail how such a technique can be used during design of aerostructures, in particular when these structures employ integrated location and reference features to help the assembly process. An example is presented, which illustrates the main concepts of error budgeting.
CitationOdi, R., Burley, G., Naing, S., and Corbett, J., "The Role of Error Budgeting in the Use of Structurally Integrated Features for Aerospace Assembly," SAE Technical Paper 2000-01-3025, 2000, https://doi.org/10.4271/2000-01-3025.
- Thompson, D C McKeown, P A “The Design of an Ultra-Precision CNC measuring Machine” Annals of the CIRP 38 1 1989 501 504
- Thompson, D C Fix, B L “Comparison Between Predicted and Actual Accuracies for an Ultra-Precision CNC Measuring Machine” Proceedings 8th International Precision Engineering Seminar Compiègne, France 15-19 May 1998 6
- Donaldson, R R Patterson, S R “Design and Construction of a Large, Vertical Axis Diamond Turning Machine” Proc. SPIE 433 Aug. 1983 62 67
- Homan, B S Thornton, A C “Precision Machine Design Assistant: A Constraint-Based Tool for the Design and Evaluation of Precision Machine Tool Concepts” Proceedings AIEDAM Spring '98 Conference 1998
- Wills-Moren, W J “Error budgeting in machine design” Lecture Notes Cranfield University Oct. 1993
- Thornton, A C “A mathematical framework for the Key Characteristics Concept” Research in Engineering Design 1999
- Mantripangada, et al. “Assembly Orientated Design: A new approach to designing assemblies” Proceedings 5th IFIP WG5.2 Workshop on Geometric Modelling in Computer-Aided Design 18-23 May 1996 Airlie, VA USA
- Lee, D J Thornton, A C “Enhanced Key Characteristics Identification Methodology for Agile Design” Agile Manufacturing Forum March 1996 Boston, MA
- Schwemmin, R J “Predicting Assembly Performance with Featurized Datum Flow Chains” Paper No. 1999-01-2271 SAE AMT Conference 8-10 June 1999 Bellevue WA, USA
- Meadows, J D “Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerancing” Marcel Dekker Inc. New York 1995 56 57
- Whitney, DE et al. “Designing assemblies” Research in Engineering Design 1999 11 229 253
- Naing S. Burley G. Odi R Williamson A Corbett, J “Design for Tooling to Enable Jigless Assembly -An integrated Methodology for Jigless Assembly” Proceedings SAE AMT Conference 16-18 May 2000 Paper No 2000-01-1765
- Burley G Naing S Odi R Corbett J “The use of integrated reference and location features in the assembly of large aerostructures” SAE Aerofast 2000, Paper 00FAS-5 New Orleans 20-22 September 2000