This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Applying Driving Simulation to Quantify Steering Effort Preference as a Function of Vehicle Speed
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 01, 1999 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper describes a study to determine how steering wheel effort preference changes with vehicle speed for average drivers. These results confirm previously published data indicating drivers prefer increased steering efforts at higher vehicle speeds and extends previous work by providing a more reliable preference function. For comparison, we include similar preference data from two separate field studies as well as pilot results obtained using the General Motors Corporation (GM) driving simulator. The preference study was performed using the Swedish Road and Traffic Research Institute (VTI) driving simulator. The VTI simulator allowed the inclusion of a motion/no-motion test condition to provide some insight regarding the use of low to medium range driving simulators for similar follow-up work.
The study demonstrates the feasibility of using driving simulators to obtain customer-based vehicle design requirements for steering feel preferences. Our experience was that the driving simulator provided a more consistent experimental environment than real world road testing and the ability to investigate hardware designs that do not yet exist in the real world. It also provided an overall faster than real world testing environment that was safer and more convenient for the subjects and experimenter. The paper discusses these advantages as well as the limitations of using driving simulators for this type of investigation.
CitationBertollini, G. and Hogan, R., "Applying Driving Simulation to Quantify Steering Effort Preference as a Function of Vehicle Speed," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0394, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-0394.
- Horiguchi, A., Suetomi, T., “A Kansei Engineering Approach to a Driver/Vehicle System’” Journal of Industrial Ergonomics #15, pp. 25-37, 1995.
- Koide, M., Kawakami, S., “Analysis of Steering Feel Evaluation in Vehicles with Power Steering,” JSAE Vol. 9 No. 3. July 1988.
- Norman, K., “Objective Evaluation of On-Center Handling Performance.” SAE 8400069, 1984.
- Green, P., Gillespie, T., Reifeis, S., Wei-Hass, L., Ottens, O., “Subjective Evaluation of Steering Effort Levels”, UMTRI-84-39, December, 1984.
- Miyamoto, T., Fujioka, T., “Steer-Restoring Torque Controlled Driving Simulator for Developing Steering Road Feel,” SAE 912690, Nov. 1991.
- Rea, T., “A Subjective Comparison of Two Variable-Effort Steering Models Using a Driving Simulator,” University of Wisconsin MSME thesis sponsored by Saginaw Steering and GM SEC, 1993.
- Bertollini, G., Johnston, C., Kulczycka, M., Kuiper, J., Thomas, W., “General Motors Driving Simulator,” SAE 940179, 1991.
- Nilsson, L., “Contributions and limitations of Simulator Studies to Driver Behavior Research,’ Driving Future Vehicles, Parkes, A., Franzen, S., Taylor and Francis, 1993.
- Kaptein, N., Theeuwes, J., Van Der Horst, R., “Driving Simulator Validity: Some Considerations,” TRB Paper 961338, 75th Meeting, 1996.
- Weir, D., Clark, A., “A Survey of Mid-Level Driving Simulators,” SAE 950172, Feb. 1995.
- Repa, B., Alexandridis, A., Howell, L., Wierwille, W., “Study of Vehicle Steering and Response Characteristics in Simulated and Actual Driving.”, SAE 780011, Feb., 1978.
- Garrott, Riley., W., “Simulator Motion Base Sizing Using Simulation,” SAE 940227, Feb. 1994.
- Nordmark, S., Jansson, H., Lidstrom, M., Palmkvist, G., “A Moving Base Driving Simulator With Wide Angle Visual System,” Paper presented at 64th. TRB, January, 1985.
- Nordmark, S., “VTI Driving Simulator Mathematical Model of a Four-Wheeled Vehicle for Simulation in Real Time,” VTI Report #267A, ISSN 0347-6030.
- Nordmark, S., “ Power Steering Model in the SAPS Study,” VTI Configuration Memo, Jan 6, 1991.