This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Lifecycle Analysis for Freight Transport
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper evaluates the total lifecycle impacts for hauling freight long distances over land in the United States. The dominant modes of surface freight transport in the United States are large motor trucks (tractor-semitrailer combinations) and trains. These vehicles account for a significant portion of the transportation sector's petroleum usage and atmospheric emissions (among which nitrogen oxides and particulate matter are especially important). The objective of this paper is to evaluate the potential for reductions in energy use (in particular, petroleum use) and atmospheric emissions that result from freight transport, possibly as the result of research and development on improved technology or alternative fuels, such as Fischer-Tropsch diesel and natural gas, or from mode shifts in competitive markets. The impacts examined include energy use, both in toto and the petroleum fraction, and emissions of greenhouse gases and nitrogen oxides and particulate matter. The lifecycle starts with extraction of the raw materials for vehicle and fuel production, continues with production of the vehicle and its fuel, and concludes with combustion of the fuel during vehicle operation. Both fuels now in use and alternative fuels are considered. Energy use and emissions values for materials manufacturing and recycling have been estimated in previous Argonne studies and are used here. We conclude that there are trade-offs among impacts. For example, lowest fossil energy use does not necessarily result in lowest total energy use. We also identify trade-offs between energy use and emissions and other factors influencing mode choices, and we briefly discuss how government policies affect the choices.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Research and Development of Flexible Fuel Vehicles at Nissan |
| Technical Paper | Comparison of In-Use Emissions from Diesel and Natural Gas Trucks and Buses |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Stodolsky, F., Gaines, L., Cuenca, R., and Eberhardt, J., "Lifecycle Analysis for Freight Transport," SAE Technical Paper 982206, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/982206.Also In
References
- EIA 1996 Annual Energy Outlook Energy Information Administration, U.S. Department of Energy December 1996
- EIA 1997 Annual Energy Review 1996 Energy Information Administration, U.S. Department of Energy July 1997
- Transportation in America 11th Eno Transportation Foundation Washington, D.C. 1993
- Gaines, L.L. Stodolsky, F. Proc. AWMA Annual Meeting Toronto, Ont., Canada 1997
- Gaines, L.L. Stodolsky, F. Mandated Recycling Rates: Impacts on Energy Consumption and Municipal Solid Waste Volume Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Ill. 1993
- Gaines, L.L. Singh, M. Proc. SAE Total Life Cycle Conference and Exposition Vienna, Austria 1995
- Stodolsky, F. Vyas, A. Cuenca, R. Gaines, L.L. Proc. SAE Total Life Cycle Conference and Exposition Vienna, Austria 1995 Society of Automotive Engineers Publication
- Wang, M.Q. Gaines, L.L. Cuenca, R. Proc. AWMA Annual Meeting Toronto, Ont., Canada 1997
- Gaines, L.L. Stodolsky, F. Cuenca, R. Eberhardt Lifecycle Analysis for Heavy Vehicles J. Air and Waste Management Annual Meeting San Diego, Calif. June 1998
- “U.S. Freight Transportation Forecast… to 2003,” American Trucking Associations Foundation Alexandria, Va. April 1995
- Railroad Facts 1997 Edition American Association of Railroads Washington, D.C. September 1997
- “Rail vs. Truck Fuel Efficiency: The Relative Efficiency of Truck Competitive Rail Freight and Truck Operations Compared in a Range of Corridors,” Abacus Technology Corp. Chevy Chase, Md. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Railway Administration April 1991
- 1992 Truck Inventory and Use Survey U.S. Census Bureau Washington, D.C. 1995
- Strategic Plan U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Transportation Technologies Washington, D.C. 1997
- Stodolsky, F. Cuenca, R.M. Bonsignore, P.V. Technology and Future Prospects for Lightweight Plastic Vehicle Structures Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Ill. 1997
- Vyas, A. Center for Transportation Research, Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Ill. 1997
- EPA, California Air Resources Board, and Manufacturers of Heavy-Duty Engines Sign “Statement of Principles” U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Air and Radiation, Office of Mobile Sources Washington, D.C. 1995
- Regulatory Announcement: Environmental Benefits of Emission Standards for Locomotives US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Mobile Sources Ann Arbor, MI December 1997
- McDonnell, G. “EMD's Big Boy,” http://www.kalmbach.com/trains/Archive/Sep97/SD90story.html
- National Steel Car, Limited http://steelcar.com/Box1.htm Http://steelcar.com/INTER2.htm April 1998
- Cuenca, R. Personal communication with CSX Sealand Intermodal Chicago, Ill. July 1998
- Freight Train Simulator User's Manual for the USDOT/VNTSC Train Performance Simulator (TPS) Version 5C U.S. Department of Transportation March 1988
- “Locomotive Application Guide for the 1990's [sic] and Beyond,” Electro-Motive Service Department Training Center LaGrange, Ill.
- McDonnell, G. Breakthrough in Braking Trains Magazine Nov. 1996 Kalmbach Publishing Co.
- Environmental Protection Agency Final Emission Standards for Locomotives U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Air and Radiation, Office of Mobile Sources Washington, D.C. Dec. 1997
- Moulis, C. “Test Procedure Revisions Being Considered for Locomotive Final Rule,” U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Washington, D.C. Feb. 18 1997
- Fritz, S.G. Markworth V.O. Mason R.L. Locomotive Exhaust Emission Field Tests-Phase 1-EMD SD 40-2 and GE C40-8 Locomotives Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, TX Oct. 1994
- California Air Resources Board “Locomotive Emission Study,” Booz Allen Hamilton 1991
- Punwami, S. et al. Progress in Railroad Freight Car Engineering Stone D. Rail Transportation 1997 13 ASME NY 1997
- Bosch “Motor Vehicle Dynamics,” Automotive Handbook Robert Bosch GmbH Stuttgart, Germany 1996
- Carley, W.M. “To Avoid Collisions, Some Railroads Test Satellite Positioning,” Wall Street Journal CCXXXI 21 1 Monday June 29 1998
- “Assessment of the Effects of Proposed Locomotive Regulations on Goods Transport Modes and Locomotive Emissions,” Jack Faucett Associates, Inc. Bethesda, Md. California Air Resources Board Feb. 1996
- Gray, J. Proc. Windsor Workshop on Transportation Fuels Windsor, Ont., Canada Natural Resources Canada and U.S. Department of Energy 1997
- Wang, W. et al. Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, Pa. 1997
- “Controlling Locomotive Emissions in California,” Engine, Fuel, and Emissions Engineering, Inc. Sacramento, Calif. State of California Air Resources Board Oct. 1993